Re: New Exception Request: GPL Cooperation Commitment 1.0

2018-10-18 Thread Bradley M. Kuhn
J Lovejoy wrote just now: > I agree that it would be productive to discuss these at the same time, I was on the call today as well, and as I mentioned there, I was the person who initially asked they be considered separately, but as Fontana says Fontana wrote: > > Re-reading the GitHub issue,

Re: New Exception Request: GPL Cooperation Commitment 1.0

2018-10-18 Thread J Lovejoy
Hi Richard, all, I have not had a chance to post the minutes from today’s call, but this conversation is something we touched upon in terms of planning for post-3.3 release. I agree that it would be productive to discuss these at the same time, as well as the larger issue of potentially revisi

Re: New Exception Request: GPL Cooperation Commitment 1.0

2018-10-18 Thread Richard Fontana
I previously wrote, referring to https://github.com/spdx/license-list-XML/issues/655 > as Bradley Kuhn says in a comment to that issue, "drafted somewhat > differently and therefore presumably should be analyzed differently > so as not to conflate apples and oranges". On further thought, there ar

Re: New Exception Request: GPL Cooperation Commitment 1.0

2018-10-18 Thread Matija ?uklje
On četrtek, 18. oktober 2018 13:08:59 CEST Richard Fontana wrote: > But we think from the SPDX perspective adding GPLCC-1.0 is > justified because its use by projects and appearance in > downstream products and distributions is likely to grow, even > if slowly. I think this is a very likely situat

New Exception Request: GPL Cooperation Commitment 1.0

2018-10-18 Thread Richard Fontana
Heya, This is a request for addition of the GPL Cooperation Commitment version version 1.0 to the SPDX list of License Exceptions ( https://spdx.org/licenses/exceptions-index.html ) 1. Proposed Full Name: GPL Cooperation Commitment 1.0 2. Proposed Short Identifier: GPLCC-1.0 3. URL refere