RE: Discussion: RP Yadis URL?

2006-10-16 Thread Recordon, David
Of Martin Atkins Sent: Monday, October 16, 2006 12:37 AM To: specs@openid.net Subject: Re: Discussion: RP Yadis URL? Recordon, David wrote: > > I'm torn if this parameter should be added to the spec at this time or > not. Adding the parameter is conceptually simple, though I

Re: Discussion: RP Yadis URL?

2006-10-16 Thread Martin Atkins
Recordon, David wrote: > > I'm torn if this parameter should be added to the spec at this time or > not. Adding the parameter is conceptually simple, though I don't think > there is agreement on what the RP should be publishing in their Yadis > file. There is the section > http://openid.net/spec

RE: Discussion: RP Yadis URL?

2006-10-15 Thread Recordon, David
perability warnings go off in my head. I'd rather see us do this right or not do it at all right now. --David -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Drummond Reed Sent: Sunday, October 15, 2006 9:59 AM To: 'Johannes Ernst';

Re: Re[4]: Discussion: RP Yadis URL?

2006-10-15 Thread Dick Hardt
On 15-Oct-06, at 10:54 AM, Chris Drake wrote: > Hi Dick, > > 1. IdP's "advertising" a list of sites that accept OpenID - like the >way PayPal list stores that accept their currency I guess. It's >annoying to a user to have to come back to the place they just >clicked in order to click

Re[4]: Discussion: RP Yadis URL?

2006-10-15 Thread Chris Drake
o Working Draft 11 of XRI >> Resolution >> DR> 2.0 starting this week. So it seems all the OpenID >> Authentication 2.0 spec >> DR> needs to specify is that they work against the return_to URL. >> >> DR> =Drummond >> >> DR> -Original Messag

Re: Re[2]: Discussion: RP Yadis URL?

2006-10-15 Thread Dick Hardt
rting this week. So it seems all the OpenID > Authentication 2.0 spec > DR> needs to specify is that they work against the return_to URL. > > DR> =Drummond > > DR> -Original Message- > DR> From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] > DR> [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf &g

Re[2]: Discussion: RP Yadis URL?

2006-10-15 Thread Chris Drake
gt; =Drummond DR> -Original Message- DR> From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] DR> [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf DR> Of Johannes Ernst DR> Sent: Sunday, October 15, 2006 12:00 AM DR> To: specs@openid.net DR> Subject: Re: Discussion: RP Yadis URL? DR> Yes. Or any of the other d

RE: Discussion: RP Yadis URL?

2006-10-15 Thread Drummond Reed
=Drummond -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Johannes Ernst Sent: Sunday, October 15, 2006 12:00 AM To: specs@openid.net Subject: Re: Discussion: RP Yadis URL? Yes. Or any of the other defined algorithms for obtaining the XRDS file, given the

Re: Discussion: RP Yadis URL?

2006-10-15 Thread Johannes Ernst
Yes. Or any of the other defined algorithms for obtaining the XRDS file, given the return_to URL. On Oct 14, 2006, at 23:50, Dick Hardt wrote: I assume you are referring to the return_to URL? Current libraries add all kinds of parameters to that URL, would you be suggesting that the IdP do

Re: Discussion: RP Yadis URL?

2006-10-14 Thread Dick Hardt
I assume you are referring to the return_to URL? Current libraries add all kinds of parameters to that URL, would you be suggesting that the IdP does a GET on the return_to URL with content-type of XRDS? If so, then we should add that to the spec. I'd then like to get clear on what would ne

Re: Discussion: RP Yadis URL?

2006-10-14 Thread Johannes Ernst
Given that the RP has at least one URL, we can perform regular Yadis discovery on it. (Likely, all of the RP's URLs point to the same Yadis document.) I don't think an extension to the protocol is needed. On Oct 14, 2006, at 22:39, Dick Hardt wrote: Currently there is no method for the IdP

Discussion: RP Yadis URL?

2006-10-14 Thread Dick Hardt
Currently there is no method for the IdP to learn anything about the RP. As a path for extensibility, would anyone have a problem with having an optional parameter in the AuthN Request for the location of the RP's Yadis document? -- Dick ___ specs