Re: handling of url redirection

2008-02-28 Thread Martin Atkins
Jonathan Daugherty wrote: This is what I was getting at- it'd be good to give users an identical experience when they sign into various OpenID-enabled apps. Just to be clear, this is not an interop issue. This is a matter of drawing the line between what is sane and what is not. For

Re: handling of url redirection

2008-02-23 Thread David Recordon
Hi Marv, This has never been specified as a relying party could choose to follow as many redirects as it wishes. Maybe there should be a hard line drawn though from an interoperability side? --David On Feb 17, 2008, at 3:06 PM, SignpostMarv Martin wrote: Was talking with keturn in #openid

Re: handling of url redirection

2008-02-23 Thread SignpostMarv Martin
David Recordon wrote: Hi Marv, This has never been specified as a relying party could choose to follow as many redirects as it wishes. Maybe there should be a hard line drawn though from an interoperability side? This is what I was getting at- it'd be good to give users an identical

Re: handling of url redirection

2008-02-23 Thread Jonathan Daugherty
This is what I was getting at- it'd be good to give users an identical experience when they sign into various OpenID-enabled apps. Just to be clear, this is not an interop issue. This is a matter of drawing the line between what is sane and what is not. For pathological cases (e.g.,

RE: handling of url redirection

2008-02-23 Thread Eran Hammer-Lahav
] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Jonathan Daugherty Sent: Sunday, February 24, 2008 2:10 AM To: SignpostMarv Martin Cc: [EMAIL PROTECTED]; specs@openid.net Subject: Re: handling of url redirection This is what I was getting at- it'd be good to give users an identical experience when