Re: [spring] [ippm] FW: New Version Notification for draft-filsfils-spring-path-tracing-00.txt

2022-03-14 Thread Greg Mirsky
Hi Ahmed and the Authors, thank you for sharing this information. I've read the draft and have several questions and comments: - It is not clear if you propose a new active measurement protocol or view it as a hybrid method (based on RFC 7799 classification). On one hand, packets are

[spring] SPRING Chairs observation on WG calls for consensus

2022-03-14 Thread Joel M. Halpern
In discussion with chairs of other routing working groups, it was noted that there is sometimes confusion or misunderstanding about what is sought when the chairs conduct adoption calls and WG last calls. The top line is that we are looking for working group support and review. In the case of

[spring] WG adoption for draft-boutros-spring-elan-services-over-sr-00

2022-03-14 Thread Boutros, Sami
Dear WG Chairs, The authors would like to request a WG adoption for this draft, the draft was presented at last IETF. We could present the draft at this IETF too, if you folks like. Thanks, Sami ___ spring mailing list spring@ietf.org

Re: [spring] Network Programming Interface for Provisioning of Underlay Services to Overlay Networks Using SRv6 (draft-xie-spring-srv6-npi-for-overlay)

2022-03-14 Thread Andrew Alston - IETF
Jingrong, Limited Domain (in my view) refers to a domain where all points are under single administrative control. I.E the source, destination and anything in the middle must fall under the same administrative control, otherwise, you are not within the limited domain. This can be extended

Re: [spring] New Version Notification for draft-filsfils-spring-path-tracing-00.txt

2022-03-14 Thread Andrew Alston - IETF
Hi There, Speaking entirely as a working group participant, I have two substantial concerns with this document at first skim read. Firstly - the 12 bits for an interface ID - I have serious concerns that this will be far from sufficient. Keep in mind you have interface specific VLAN's (that

Re: [spring] Network Programming Interface for Provisioning of Underlay Services to Overlay Networks Using SRv6 (draft-xie-spring-srv6-npi-for-overlay)

2022-03-14 Thread Xiejingrong (Jingrong)
Hi, I think I now understand better the concern about "the use of SIDs over the public Internet". In my previous mail, the SID2/SID3 used between CPE2-Internet-CPE3 is to explain the layering model (over vs across), but it is not the proposal of the draft. The draft is talking about the