Re: [Standards] XMPP URI usage in "HTTP over XMPP"

2013-07-10 Thread Ralph Meijer
On 2013-07-10 22:27, Dave Cridland wrote: > So, to be able to create such a seamless transition (which is also important in semantic web scenarios) we need an URI scheme that works in a syntactically identical manner as the already existing http URI scheme. Now, there exists another such URI sch

Re: [Standards] XMPP URI usage in "HTTP over XMPP"

2013-07-10 Thread Dave Cridland
On 10 Jul 2013 10:37, "Peter Waher" wrote: > Regarding why the existing xmpp scheme cannot be used, and maintain compatibility, especially as you suggested a new query type needs to be defined, is because of the desire to be able to create seamless transitions of existing web applications from HTT

Re: [Standards] XMPP URI usage in "HTTP over XMPP"

2013-07-10 Thread Peter Waher
Hello Ralph Thanks for your comments. > I agree with Peter (Saint-Andre). Just introducing a new scheme doesn't feel > right to me. At the very least I'd like to see a rational for not using the > xmpp scheme, which should be able to handle the use cases, that goes beyond > the lack of charact

Re: [Standards] XMPP URI usage in "HTTP over XMPP"

2013-07-10 Thread Peter Waher
Hello Peter Thanks for your comments. I'll respond to each in turn: >> Hello Ralph >> >> Thanks for your mail. You're absolutely correct. It was sloppy of me >> to propose a URI scheme with the same name as the previous xmpp >> scheme. I'm sorry. >> >> I've therefore renamed the scheme to ht