[Standards] XEP-0332 Last Call comment summary

2014-11-05 Thread Dave Cridland
This is a summary of Last Call comments concerning XEP-0332, and is a method of attempting to (re)stimulate discussion in order to get the XEP moved from Experimental. It does not constitute a formal action of Council, Board, or the XSF as a whole, nor set any kind of precedent - it results from a

Re: [Standards] XEP-0332 Last Call comment summary

2014-11-05 Thread Christian Schudt
I follow 3a). Generally the whole document is hard to understand for me. Reasons for that are: 1. The introduction and motivation is written very abstract and it's hard to grasp the intent.    It could use some friendly How it works section, similar to other XEPs. 2. Some terminology (like XML

Re: [Standards] XEP-0332 Last Call comment summary

2014-11-05 Thread Lance Stout
2) The revision of the XEP in question is 0.3; note that there are comments in the thread about the update to this revision which do not appear to be answered: I would also add: h) The use of an xml/ element is prohibited by the XML spec (can't start tags with 'xml' or variants thereof),