Re: [Standards] Comments on XEP-0301 (possible impact on -0308 in Section 4.2.3)

2012-08-03 Thread Paul E. Jones
Peter, > > Section 4.2.3 > > > > XEP-0308 specifies use of "id" in and . Could we > > not just use "" along with ""? It would require some > > text in > > XEP-0308 that says that if is received without , it > > shall be ignored. In -0301, it would not be ignored. "id" works, but > > I would

[Standards] Comments on XEP-0301 (possible impact on -0308 in Section 4.2.3)

2012-08-03 Thread Paul E. Jones
Mark, et al, I re-read the draft and here are my comments. After I wrote all of this, I thought it sounds like I'm pounding on everything. Overall, the text was great.. it has come a long way. That said, here are my comments and questions: Section 1: "and is favored by deaf and hard of hearing