Re: [Standards] [XEP-0234] Jingle File Transfer, Last Call and File Sharing

2018-02-26 Thread Simon Friedberger
Don't you in most cases want hashes anyway to ensure the integrity of the files? It's also not actually that resource intensive to calculate the hash of a file. Definitely negligible to transferring it. On 26.02.2018 16:45, Goffi wrote: > > My problem is that I don't want to always calculate

Re: [Standards] Message-IDs

2018-02-26 Thread Simon Friedberger
So, lest this discussion just die. Here is a proposal: * Client-A generates message-ID based on HASH(connection_counter, server_salt). The connection_counter needs to be maintained only for one connection. The server salt is server generated, anew for each connection and is

Re: [Standards] Message-IDs

2018-02-14 Thread Simon Friedberger
Hi Michal, thank you for your comments. I will address them inline. > I'm really tempted to say that the new message routing (in next gen > XMPP as discussed during summit) > must require the message stanza to have "id" attribute. I personally > think that uuid v4 would enough here. > This, to

Re: [Standards] Message-IDs

2018-02-13 Thread Simon Friedberger
Hi Florian, thanks for chiming in! On 13.02.2018 17:57, Simon Friedberger wrote: >>     C2. According to Daniel it is not clear which ID should be used when >>     referencing things. In other words if he gets a delivery receipt >> for an >>     ID the