Re: [Standards] Connection Type in XEP-0198 'location' (Direct-TLS vs STARTTLS)

2017-12-20 Thread Jonas Wielicki
On Mittwoch, 20. Dezember 2017 14:38:08 CET Jonas Wielicki wrote: > On Mittwoch, 20. Dezember 2017 13:50:11 CET Georg Lukas wrote: > > * Jonas Wielicki [2017-12-20 13:06]: > > > I think it would make more sense to specify the SRV-record field. > > > > I would agree in theory, but SRV records are

Re: [Standards] Connection Type in XEP-0198 'location' (Direct-TLS vs STARTTLS)

2017-12-20 Thread Jonas Wielicki
On Mittwoch, 20. Dezember 2017 13:50:11 CET Georg Lukas wrote: > * Jonas Wielicki [2017-12-20 13:06]: > > > a) the server inspects the client connection type and returns the port > > > for the same connection type in 0198/location, i.e. if the client > > > connected via Direct-TLS to 5223, the ser

Re: [Standards] Connection Type in XEP-0198 'location' (Direct-TLS vs STARTTLS)

2017-12-20 Thread Georg Lukas
* Jonas Wielicki [2017-12-20 13:06]: > > a) the server inspects the client connection type and returns the port > > for the same connection type in 0198/location, i.e. if the client > > connected via Direct-TLS to 5223, the server will return server:5223. > > This will obviously break clients that

Re: [Standards] Connection Type in XEP-0198 'location' (Direct-TLS vs STARTTLS)

2017-12-20 Thread Jonas Wielicki
On Mittwoch, 20. Dezember 2017 12:07:28 CET Georg Lukas wrote: > Hi, > > when reading the Instant-Stream-Resumption Proto-XEP, I encountered > > this piece, which shows a deeper problem in 0198/6120: > | The element can optionally also contain a 'location' > | attribute which specifies the prefe

[Standards] Connection Type in XEP-0198 'location' (Direct-TLS vs STARTTLS)

2017-12-20 Thread Georg Lukas
Hi, when reading the Instant-Stream-Resumption Proto-XEP, I encountered this piece, which shows a deeper problem in 0198/6120: | The element can optionally also contain a 'location' | attribute which specifies the preferred IP address or hostname, and a | TCP port number of the host which should