Re: [Standards] Soliloquy (self-message) routing rules (RFC6121, XEP-0280)

2017-03-20 Thread Philipp Hörist
Hi, To only generate "sent" carbons when a message is sent to ourself, seems like a easy solution that would make the self messaging use case a bit less complex. I see no downsides to this. To drop that one message that has to be issued according to 6121, seems ok. Philipp __

Re: [Standards] Soliloquy (self-message) routing rules (RFC6121, XEP-0280)

2017-03-20 Thread Edwin Mons
On 20/03/2017 16:22, Georg Lukas wrote: > Hi, > > sometimes IM users want to talk to themselves, e.g. to send a URL from > one device to another, or to take notes. In systems like Slack this is > recognized and the self-message area is provided as a draft board. > > In modern XMPP (6121+Carbons/MAM

[Standards] Soliloquy (self-message) routing rules (RFC6121, XEP-0280)

2017-03-20 Thread Georg Lukas
Hi, sometimes IM users want to talk to themselves, e.g. to send a URL from one device to another, or to take notes. In systems like Slack this is recognized and the self-message area is provided as a draft board. In modern XMPP (6121+Carbons/MAM), messages-to-self are always delivered twice(*), b