Re: [Standards] serious bugs in XEP-0220 (Server Dialback)

2011-04-25 Thread Peter Saint-Andre
On 4/22/11 12:27 PM, Peter Saint-Andre wrote: > On 4/22/11 7:27 AM, Philipp Hancke wrote: >> I think the bug is less serious than you think ... >> >>> There are two basic problems: >>> >>> 1. In all of the examples of XEP-0220, the dialback key should be the >>> same key -- but the key varies acros

Re: [Standards] serious bugs in XEP-0220 (Server Dialback)

2011-04-22 Thread Peter Saint-Andre
On 4/22/11 7:27 AM, Philipp Hancke wrote: > I think the bug is less serious than you think ... > >> There are two basic problems: >> >> 1. In all of the examples of XEP-0220, the dialback key should be the >> same key -- but the key varies across examples. > > The XEP shows _two_ dialback session

Re: [Standards] serious bugs in XEP-0220 (Server Dialback)

2011-04-22 Thread Philipp Hancke
I think the bug is less serious than you think ... There are two basic problems: 1. In all of the examples of XEP-0220, the dialback key should be the same key -- but the key varies across examples. The XEP shows _two_ dialback sessions on two TCP connections. If you re-read it with that POV

[Standards] serious bugs in XEP-0220 (Server Dialback)

2011-04-21 Thread Peter Saint-Andre
I just completed a review of XEP-0220, which went through a Last Call in late 2010 and is now under consideration by the XMPP Council for advancement from Experimental to Draft (whether it should have been Experimental after we copied it from RFC 3920 is another question...). I think this spec con