Author: sam
Date: Sun Nov 30 19:06:35 2008
New Revision: 185482
URL: http://svn.freebsd.org/changeset/base/185482

Log:
  Major overhaul:
  o eliminate private state indexed by 802.11 rate codes; use the hal's
    rate tables directly to get the same info
  o calculate a mask of operational rates to optimize lookups and checks
    (instead of using for loops and similar)
  o optimize size bin operations
  o ignore rates marked as "do not use" in the hal phy tables
  o fix bug that caused upshifting to break in 11g once the rate dropped
    below 11Mb/s
  o add more intelligent multi-rate tx schedules
  o add support for 1/2 and 1/4 width channels
  o add dev.ath.X.sample_stats sysctl to dump runtime statistics to the console
    (needs to go up to a user app)
  o export more tuning knobs via sysctls (still a couple of magic constants)

Modified:
  head/sys/dev/ath/ath_rate/sample/sample.c
  head/sys/dev/ath/ath_rate/sample/sample.h

Modified: head/sys/dev/ath/ath_rate/sample/sample.c
==============================================================================
--- head/sys/dev/ath/ath_rate/sample/sample.c   Sun Nov 30 18:56:41 2008        
(r185481)
+++ head/sys/dev/ath/ath_rate/sample/sample.c   Sun Nov 30 19:06:35 2008        
(r185482)
@@ -62,6 +62,7 @@ __FBSDID("$FreeBSD$");
 #include <net/if.h>
 #include <net/if_media.h>
 #include <net/if_arp.h>
+#include <net/ethernet.h>              /* XXX for ether_sprintf */
 
 #include <net80211/ieee80211_var.h>
 
@@ -100,36 +101,35 @@ __FBSDID("$FreeBSD$");
  * a few different packet sizes independently for each link.
  */
 
-#define STALE_FAILURE_TIMEOUT_MS 10000
-#define MIN_SWITCH_MS 1000
-
 static void    ath_rate_ctl_reset(struct ath_softc *, struct ieee80211_node *);
 
+static const int packet_size_bins[NUM_PACKET_SIZE_BINS] = { 250, 1600 };
+
 static __inline int
 size_to_bin(int size) 
 {
-       int x = 0;
-       for (x = 0; x < NUM_PACKET_SIZE_BINS; x++) {
-               if (size <= packet_size_bins[x]) {
-                       return x;
-               }
-       }
+#if NUM_PACKET_SIZE_BINS > 1
+       if (size <= packet_size_bins[0])
+               return 0;
+#endif
+#if NUM_PACKET_SIZE_BINS > 2
+       if (size <= packet_size_bins[1])
+               return 1;
+#endif
+#if NUM_PACKET_SIZE_BINS > 3
+       if (size <= packet_size_bins[2])
+               return 2;
+#endif
+#if NUM_PACKET_SIZE_BINS > 4
+#error "add support for more packet sizes"
+#endif
        return NUM_PACKET_SIZE_BINS-1;
 }
-static __inline int
-bin_to_size(int index) {
-       return packet_size_bins[index];
-}
 
 static __inline int
-rate_to_ndx(struct sample_node *sn, int rate) {
-       int x = 0;
-       for (x = 0; x < sn->num_rates; x++) {
-               if (sn->rates[x].rate == rate) {
-                       return x;
-               }      
-       }
-       return -1;
+bin_to_size(int index)
+{
+       return packet_size_bins[index];
 }
 
 void
@@ -143,336 +143,399 @@ ath_rate_node_cleanup(struct ath_softc *
 {
 }
 
-
 /*
- * returns the ndx with the lowest average_tx_time,
+ * Return the rix with the lowest average_tx_time,
  * or -1 if all the average_tx_times are 0.
  */
-static __inline int best_rate_ndx(struct sample_node *sn, int size_bin, 
-                                 int require_acked_before)
+static __inline int
+pick_best_rate(struct sample_node *sn, const HAL_RATE_TABLE *rt,
+    int size_bin, int require_acked_before)
 {
-       int x = 0;
-        int best_rate_ndx = 0;
-        int best_rate_tt = 0;
-        for (x = 0; x < sn->num_rates; x++) {
-               int tt = sn->stats[size_bin][x].average_tx_time;
-               if (tt <= 0 || (require_acked_before && 
-                               !sn->stats[size_bin][x].packets_acked)) {
+        int best_rate_rix, best_rate_tt;
+       uint32_t mask;
+       int rix, tt;
+
+        best_rate_rix = 0;
+        best_rate_tt = 0;
+       for (mask = sn->ratemask, rix = 0; mask != 0; mask >>= 1, rix++) {
+               if ((mask & 1) == 0)            /* not a supported rate */
                        continue;
-               }
 
-               /* 9 megabits never works better than 12 */
-               if (sn->rates[x].rate == 18) 
+               tt = sn->stats[size_bin][rix].average_tx_time;
+               if (tt <= 0 ||
+                   (require_acked_before &&
+                    !sn->stats[size_bin][rix].packets_acked))
                        continue;
 
                /* don't use a bit-rate that has been failing */
-               if (sn->stats[size_bin][x].successive_failures > 3)
+               if (sn->stats[size_bin][rix].successive_failures > 3)
                        continue;
 
-               if (!best_rate_tt || best_rate_tt > tt) {
+               if (best_rate_tt == 0 || tt < best_rate_tt) {
                        best_rate_tt = tt;
-                       best_rate_ndx = x;
+                       best_rate_rix = rix;
                }
         }
-        return (best_rate_tt) ? best_rate_ndx : -1;
+        return (best_rate_tt ? best_rate_rix : -1);
 }
 
 /*
- * pick a good "random" bit-rate to sample other than the current one
+ * Pick a good "random" bit-rate to sample other than the current one.
  */
 static __inline int
-pick_sample_ndx(struct sample_node *sn, int size_bin) 
+pick_sample_rate(struct sample_softc *ssc , struct sample_node *sn,
+    const HAL_RATE_TABLE *rt, int size_bin)
 {
-       int x = 0;
-       int current_ndx = 0;
-       unsigned current_tt = 0;
+#define        DOT11RATE(ix)   (rt->info[ix].dot11Rate & IEEE80211_RATE_VAL)
+       int current_rix, rix;
+       unsigned current_tt;
+       uint32_t mask;
        
-       current_ndx = sn->current_rate[size_bin];
-       if (current_ndx < 0) {
+       current_rix = sn->current_rix[size_bin];
+       if (current_rix < 0) {
                /* no successes yet, send at the lowest bit-rate */
                return 0;
        }
-       
-       current_tt = sn->stats[size_bin][current_ndx].average_tx_time;
-       
-       for (x = 0; x < sn->num_rates; x++) {
-               int ndx = (sn->last_sample_ndx[size_bin]+1+x) % sn->num_rates;
 
-               /* don't sample the current bit-rate */
-               if (ndx == current_ndx) 
+       current_tt = sn->stats[size_bin][current_rix].average_tx_time;
+
+       rix = sn->last_sample_rix[size_bin]+1;  /* next sample rate */
+       mask = sn->ratemask &~ (1<<current_rix);/* don't sample current rate */
+       while (mask != 0) {
+               if ((mask & (1<<rix)) == 0) {   /* not a supported rate */
+       nextrate:
+                       if (++rix >= rt->rateCount)
+                               rix = 0;
                        continue;
+               }
 
                /* this bit-rate is always worse than the current one */
-               if (sn->stats[size_bin][ndx].perfect_tx_time > current_tt) 
-                       continue;
+               if (sn->stats[size_bin][rix].perfect_tx_time > current_tt) {
+                       mask &= ~(1<<rix);
+                       goto nextrate;
+               }
 
                /* rarely sample bit-rates that fail a lot */
-               if (ticks - sn->stats[size_bin][ndx].last_tx < ((hz * 
STALE_FAILURE_TIMEOUT_MS)/1000) &&
-                   sn->stats[size_bin][ndx].successive_failures > 3)
-                       continue;
-
-               /* don't sample more than 2 indexes higher 
-                * for rates higher than 11 megabits
-                */
-               if (sn->rates[ndx].rate > 22 && ndx > current_ndx + 2)
-                       continue;
-
-               /* 9 megabits never works better than 12 */
-               if (sn->rates[ndx].rate == 18) 
-                       continue;
+               if (sn->stats[size_bin][rix].successive_failures > 
ssc->max_successive_failures &&
+                   ticks - sn->stats[size_bin][rix].last_tx < 
ssc->stale_failure_timeout) {
+                       mask &= ~(1<<rix);
+                       goto nextrate;
+               }
 
-               /* if we're using 11 megabits, only sample up to 12 megabits
-                */
-               if (sn->rates[current_ndx].rate == 22 && ndx > current_ndx + 1) 
-                       continue;
+               /* don't sample more than 2 rates higher for rates > 11M */
+               if (DOT11RATE(rix) > 2*11 && rix > current_rix + 2) {
+                       mask &= ~(1<<rix);
+                       goto nextrate;
+               }
 
-               sn->last_sample_ndx[size_bin] = ndx;
-               return ndx;
+               sn->last_sample_rix[size_bin] = rix;
+               return rix;
        }
-       return current_ndx;
+       return current_rix;
+#undef DOT11RATE
 }
 
 void
 ath_rate_findrate(struct ath_softc *sc, struct ath_node *an,
                  int shortPreamble, size_t frameLen,
-                 u_int8_t *rix, int *try0, u_int8_t *txrate)
+                 u_int8_t *rix0, int *try0, u_int8_t *txrate)
 {
+#define        DOT11RATE(ix)   (rt->info[ix].dot11Rate & IEEE80211_RATE_VAL)
+#define        RATE(ix)        (DOT11RATE(ix) / 2)
        struct sample_node *sn = ATH_NODE_SAMPLE(an);
        struct sample_softc *ssc = ATH_SOFTC_SAMPLE(sc);
        struct ifnet *ifp = sc->sc_ifp;
        struct ieee80211com *ic = ifp->if_l2com;
-       int ndx, size_bin, mrr, best_ndx, change_rates;
+       const HAL_RATE_TABLE *rt = sc->sc_currates;
+       const int size_bin = size_to_bin(frameLen);
+       int rix, mrr, best_rix, change_rates;
        unsigned average_tx_time;
 
+       if (sn->static_rix != -1) {
+               rix = sn->static_rix;
+               *try0 = ATH_TXMAXTRY;
+               goto done;
+       }
+
        mrr = sc->sc_mrretry && !(ic->ic_flags & IEEE80211_F_USEPROT);
-       size_bin = size_to_bin(frameLen);
-       best_ndx = best_rate_ndx(sn, size_bin, !mrr);
 
-       if (best_ndx >= 0) {
-               average_tx_time = sn->stats[size_bin][best_ndx].average_tx_time;
+       best_rix = pick_best_rate(sn, rt, size_bin, !mrr);
+       if (best_rix >= 0) {
+               average_tx_time = sn->stats[size_bin][best_rix].average_tx_time;
        } else {
                average_tx_time = 0;
        }
-       
-       if (sn->static_rate_ndx != -1) {
-               ndx = sn->static_rate_ndx;
-               *try0 = ATH_TXMAXTRY;
-       } else {
-               *try0 = mrr ? 2 : ATH_TXMAXTRY;
-               
-               if (sn->sample_tt[size_bin] < average_tx_time * 
(sn->packets_since_sample[size_bin]*ssc->ath_sample_rate/100)) {
-                       /*
-                        * we want to limit the time measuring the performance
-                        * of other bit-rates to ath_sample_rate% of the
-                        * total transmission time.
-                        */
-                       ndx = pick_sample_ndx(sn, size_bin);
-                       if (ndx != sn->current_rate[size_bin]) {
-                               sn->current_sample_ndx[size_bin] = ndx;
-                       } else {
-                               sn->current_sample_ndx[size_bin] = -1;
-                       }
-                       sn->packets_since_sample[size_bin] = 0;
-
+       /*
+        * Limit the time measuring the performance of other tx
+        * rates to sample_rate% of the total transmission time.
+        */
+       if (sn->sample_tt[size_bin] < average_tx_time * 
(sn->packets_since_sample[size_bin]*ssc->sample_rate/100)) {
+               rix = pick_sample_rate(ssc, sn, rt, size_bin);
+               IEEE80211_NOTE(an->an_node.ni_vap, IEEE80211_MSG_RATECTL,
+                    &an->an_node, "size %u sample rate %d current rate %d",
+                    bin_to_size(size_bin), RATE(rix),
+                    RATE(sn->current_rix[size_bin]));
+               if (rix != sn->current_rix[size_bin]) {
+                       sn->current_sample_rix[size_bin] = rix;
                } else {
-                       change_rates = 0;
-                       if (!sn->packets_sent[size_bin] || best_ndx == -1) {
-                               /* no packet has been sent successfully yet */
-                               for (ndx = sn->num_rates-1; ndx > 0; ndx--) {
-                                       /* 
-                                        * pick the highest rate <= 36 Mbps
-                                        * that hasn't failed.
-                                        */
-                                       if (sn->rates[ndx].rate <= 72 && 
-                                           
sn->stats[size_bin][ndx].successive_failures == 0) {
-                                               break;
-                                       }
+                       sn->current_sample_rix[size_bin] = -1;
+               }
+               sn->packets_since_sample[size_bin] = 0;
+       } else {
+               change_rates = 0;
+               if (!sn->packets_sent[size_bin] || best_rix == -1) {
+                       /* no packet has been sent successfully yet */
+                       for (rix = rt->rateCount-1; rix > 0; rix--) {
+                               if ((sn->ratemask & (1<<rix)) == 0)
+                                       continue;
+                               /* 
+                                * Pick the highest rate <= 36 Mbps
+                                * that hasn't failed.
+                                */
+                               if (DOT11RATE(rix) <= 72 && 
+                                   
sn->stats[size_bin][rix].successive_failures == 0) {
+                                       break;
                                }
-                               change_rates = 1;
-                               best_ndx = ndx;
-                       } else if (sn->packets_sent[size_bin] < 20) {
-                               /* let the bit-rate switch quickly during the 
first few packets */
-                               change_rates = 1;
-                       } else if (ticks - ((hz*MIN_SWITCH_MS)/1000) > 
sn->ticks_since_switch[size_bin]) {
-                               /* 2 seconds have gone by */
-                               change_rates = 1;
-                       } else if (average_tx_time * 2 < 
sn->stats[size_bin][sn->current_rate[size_bin]].average_tx_time) {
-                               /* the current bit-rate is twice as slow as the 
best one */
-                               change_rates = 1;
                        }
+                       change_rates = 1;
+                       best_rix = rix;
+               } else if (sn->packets_sent[size_bin] < 20) {
+                       /* let the bit-rate switch quickly during the first few 
packets */
+                       change_rates = 1;
+               } else if (ticks - ssc->min_switch > 
sn->ticks_since_switch[size_bin]) {
+                       /* min_switch seconds have gone by */
+                       change_rates = 1;
+               } else if (2*average_tx_time < 
sn->stats[size_bin][sn->current_rix[size_bin]].average_tx_time) {
+                       /* the current bit-rate is twice as slow as the best 
one */
+                       change_rates = 1;
+               }
 
-                       sn->packets_since_sample[size_bin]++;
-                       
-                       if (change_rates) {
-                               if (best_ndx != sn->current_rate[size_bin]) {
-                                       IEEE80211_NOTE(an->an_node.ni_vap,
-                                           IEEE80211_MSG_RATECTL,
-                                           &an->an_node,
+               sn->packets_since_sample[size_bin]++;
+               
+               if (change_rates) {
+                       if (best_rix != sn->current_rix[size_bin]) {
+                               IEEE80211_NOTE(an->an_node.ni_vap,
+                                   IEEE80211_MSG_RATECTL,
+                                   &an->an_node,
 "%s: size %d switch rate %d (%d/%d) -> %d (%d/%d) after %d packets mrr %d",
-                                           __func__,
-                                           packet_size_bins[size_bin],
-                                           
sn->rates[sn->current_rate[size_bin]].rate,
-                                           
sn->stats[size_bin][sn->current_rate[size_bin]].average_tx_time,
-                                           
sn->stats[size_bin][sn->current_rate[size_bin]].perfect_tx_time,
-                                           sn->rates[best_ndx].rate,
-                                           
sn->stats[size_bin][best_ndx].average_tx_time,
-                                           
sn->stats[size_bin][best_ndx].perfect_tx_time,
-                                           sn->packets_since_switch[size_bin],
-                                           mrr);
-                               }
-                               sn->packets_since_switch[size_bin] = 0;
-                               sn->current_rate[size_bin] = best_ndx;
-                               sn->ticks_since_switch[size_bin] = ticks;
-                               /* 
-                                * Set the visible txrate for this node.
-                                */
-                               an->an_node.ni_txrate = 
sn->rates[best_ndx].rate;
+                                   __func__,
+                                   bin_to_size(size_bin),
+                                   RATE(sn->current_rix[size_bin]),
+                                   
sn->stats[size_bin][sn->current_rix[size_bin]].average_tx_time,
+                                   
sn->stats[size_bin][sn->current_rix[size_bin]].perfect_tx_time,
+                                   RATE(best_rix),
+                                   
sn->stats[size_bin][best_rix].average_tx_time,
+                                   
sn->stats[size_bin][best_rix].perfect_tx_time,
+                                   sn->packets_since_switch[size_bin],
+                                   mrr);
                        }
-                       ndx = sn->current_rate[size_bin];
-                       sn->packets_since_switch[size_bin]++;
+                       sn->packets_since_switch[size_bin] = 0;
+                       sn->current_rix[size_bin] = best_rix;
+                       sn->ticks_since_switch[size_bin] = ticks;
+                       /* 
+                        * Set the visible txrate for this node.
+                        */
+                       an->an_node.ni_txrate = DOT11RATE(best_rix);
                }
+               rix = sn->current_rix[size_bin];
+               sn->packets_since_switch[size_bin]++;
        }
-
-       KASSERT(ndx >= 0 && ndx < sn->num_rates, ("ndx is %d", ndx));
-
-       *rix = sn->rates[ndx].rix;
-       if (shortPreamble) {
-               *txrate = sn->rates[ndx].shortPreambleRateCode;
-       } else {
-               *txrate = sn->rates[ndx].rateCode;
-       }
+       *try0 = mrr ? sn->sched[rix].t0 : ATH_TXMAXTRY;
+done:
+       KASSERT(rix >= 0 && rix < rt->rateCount, ("rix is %d", rix));
+
+       *rix0 = rix;
+       *txrate = rt->info[rix].rateCode
+               | (shortPreamble ? rt->info[rix].shortPreamble : 0);
        sn->packets_sent[size_bin]++;
+#undef DOT11RATE
+#undef RATE
 }
 
+#define A(_r) \
+    (((_r) == 6)   ? 0 : (((_r) == 9)   ? 1 : (((_r) == 12)  ? 2 : \
+    (((_r) == 18)  ? 3 : (((_r) == 24)  ? 4 : (((_r) == 36)  ? 5 : \
+    (((_r) == 48)  ? 6 : (((_r) == 54)  ? 7 : 0))))))))
+static const struct txschedule series_11a[] = {
+       { 3,A( 6), 3,A(  6), 0,A(  6), 0,A( 6) },       /*   6Mb/s */
+       { 4,A( 9), 3,A(  6), 4,A(  6), 0,A( 6) },       /*   9Mb/s */
+       { 4,A(12), 3,A(  6), 4,A(  6), 0,A( 6) },       /*  12Mb/s */
+       { 4,A(18), 3,A( 12), 4,A(  6), 2,A( 6) },       /*  18Mb/s */
+       { 4,A(24), 3,A( 18), 4,A( 12), 2,A( 6) },       /*  24Mb/s */
+       { 4,A(36), 3,A( 24), 4,A( 18), 2,A( 6) },       /*  36Mb/s */
+       { 4,A(48), 3,A( 36), 4,A( 24), 2,A(12) },       /*  48Mb/s */
+       { 4,A(54), 3,A( 48), 4,A( 36), 2,A(24) }        /*  54Mb/s */
+};
+#undef A
+
+#define G(_r) \
+    (((_r) == 1)   ? 0 : (((_r) == 2)   ? 1 : (((_r) == 5.5) ? 2 : \
+    (((_r) == 11)  ? 3 : (((_r) == 6)   ? 4 : (((_r) == 9)   ? 5 : \
+    (((_r) == 12)  ? 6 : (((_r) == 18)  ? 7 : (((_r) == 24)  ? 8 : \
+    (((_r) == 36)  ? 9 : (((_r) == 48)  ? 10 : (((_r) == 54)  ? 11 : 
0))))))))))))
+static const struct txschedule series_11g[] = {
+       { 3,G( 1), 3,G(  1), 0,G(  1), 0,G( 1) },       /*   1Mb/s */
+       { 4,G( 2), 3,G(  1), 4,G(  1), 0,G( 1) },       /*   2Mb/s */
+       { 4,G(5.5),3,G(  2), 4,G(  1), 2,G( 1) },       /* 5.5Mb/s */
+       { 4,G(11), 3,G(5.5), 4,G(  2), 2,G( 1) },       /*  11Mb/s */
+       { 4,G( 6), 3,G(5.5), 4,G(  2), 2,G( 1) },       /*   6Mb/s */
+       { 4,G( 9), 3,G(  6), 4,G(5.5), 2,G( 1) },       /*   9Mb/s */
+       { 4,G(12), 3,G( 11), 4,G(5.5), 2,G( 1) },       /*  12Mb/s */
+       { 4,G(18), 3,G( 12), 4,G( 11), 2,G( 1) },       /*  18Mb/s */
+       { 4,G(24), 3,G( 18), 4,G( 12), 2,G( 1) },       /*  24Mb/s */
+       { 4,G(36), 3,G( 24), 4,G( 18), 2,G( 1) },       /*  36Mb/s */
+       { 4,G(48), 3,G( 36), 4,G( 24), 2,G( 1) },       /*  48Mb/s */
+       { 4,G(54), 3,G( 48), 4,G( 36), 2,G( 1) }        /*  54Mb/s */
+};
+#undef G
+
+#define H(_r) \
+    (((_r) == 3)   ? 0 : (((_r) == 4.5) ? 1 : (((_r) == 6)  ? 2 : \
+    (((_r) == 9)   ? 3 : (((_r) == 12)  ? 4 : (((_r) == 18) ? 5 : \
+    (((_r) == 24)  ? 6 : (((_r) == 27)  ? 7 : 0))))))))
+static const struct txschedule series_half[] = {
+       { 3,H( 3), 3,H(  3), 0,H(  3), 0,H( 3) },       /*   3Mb/s */
+       { 4,H(4.5),3,H(  3), 4,H(  3), 0,H( 3) },       /* 4.5Mb/s */
+       { 4,H( 6), 3,H(  3), 4,H(  3), 0,H( 3) },       /*   6Mb/s */
+       { 4,H( 9), 3,H(  6), 4,H(  3), 2,H( 3) },       /*   9Mb/s */
+       { 4,H(12), 3,H(  9), 4,H(  6), 2,H( 3) },       /*  12Mb/s */
+       { 4,H(18), 3,H( 12), 4,H(  9), 2,H( 3) },       /*  18Mb/s */
+       { 4,H(24), 3,H( 18), 4,H( 12), 2,H( 6) },       /*  24Mb/s */
+       { 4,H(27), 3,H( 24), 4,H( 18), 2,H(12) }        /*  27Mb/s */
+};
+#undef H
+
+#define Q(_r) \
+    (((_r) == 1.5) ? 0 : (((_r) ==2.25) ? 1 : (((_r) == 3)  ? 2 : \
+    (((_r) == 4.5) ? 3 : (((_r) ==  6)  ? 4 : (((_r) == 9)  ? 5 : \
+    (((_r) == 12)  ? 6 : (((_r) == 13.5)? 7 : 0))))))))
+static const struct txschedule series_quarter[] = {
+       { 3,Q( 1.5),3,Q(1.5), 0,Q(1.5), 0,Q(1.5) },     /* 1.5Mb/s */
+       { 4,Q(2.25),3,Q(1.5), 4,Q(1.5), 0,Q(1.5) },     /*2.25Mb/s */
+       { 4,Q(   3),3,Q(1.5), 4,Q(1.5), 0,Q(1.5) },     /*   3Mb/s */
+       { 4,Q( 4.5),3,Q(  3), 4,Q(1.5), 2,Q(1.5) },     /* 4.5Mb/s */
+       { 4,Q(   6),3,Q(4.5), 4,Q(  3), 2,Q(1.5) },     /*   6Mb/s */
+       { 4,Q(   9),3,Q(  6), 4,Q(4.5), 2,Q(1.5) },     /*   9Mb/s */
+       { 4,Q(  12),3,Q(  9), 4,Q(  6), 2,Q(  3) },     /*  12Mb/s */
+       { 4,Q(13.5),3,Q( 12), 4,Q(  9), 2,Q(  6) }      /*13.5Mb/s */
+};
+#undef Q
+
 void
 ath_rate_setupxtxdesc(struct ath_softc *sc, struct ath_node *an,
                      struct ath_desc *ds, int shortPreamble, u_int8_t rix)
 {
        struct sample_node *sn = ATH_NODE_SAMPLE(an);
-       int rateCode = -1;
-       int frame_size = 0;
-       int size_bin = 0;
-       int ndx = 0;
-
-       size_bin = size_to_bin(frame_size);     // TODO: it's correct that 
frame_size alway 0 ?
-       ndx = sn->current_rate[size_bin]; /* retry at the current bit-rate */
-       
-       if (!sn->stats[size_bin][ndx].packets_acked) {
-               ndx = 0;  /* use the lowest bit-rate */
-       }
+       const struct txschedule *sched = &sn->sched[rix];
+       const HAL_RATE_TABLE *rt = sc->sc_currates;
+       uint8_t rix1, s1code, rix2, s2code, rix3, s3code;
 
-       if (shortPreamble) {
-               rateCode = sn->rates[ndx].shortPreambleRateCode;
-       } else {
-               rateCode = sn->rates[ndx].rateCode;
-       }
-       ath_hal_setupxtxdesc(sc->sc_ah, ds
-                            , rateCode, 3              /* series 1 */
-                            , sn->rates[0].rateCode, 3 /* series 2 */
-                            , 0, 0                     /* series 3 */
-                            );
+       /* XXX precalculate short preamble tables */
+       rix1 = sched->r1;
+       s1code = rt->info[rix1].rateCode
+              | (shortPreamble ? rt->info[rix1].shortPreamble : 0);
+       rix2 = sched->r2;
+       s2code = rt->info[rix2].rateCode
+              | (shortPreamble ? rt->info[rix2].shortPreamble : 0);
+       rix3 = sched->r3;
+       s3code = rt->info[rix3].rateCode
+              | (shortPreamble ? rt->info[rix3].shortPreamble : 0);
+       ath_hal_setupxtxdesc(sc->sc_ah, ds,
+           s1code, sched->t1,          /* series 1 */
+           s2code, sched->t2,          /* series 2 */
+           s3code, sched->t3);         /* series 3 */
 }
 
 static void
 update_stats(struct ath_softc *sc, struct ath_node *an, 
                  int frame_size,
-                 int ndx0, int tries0,
-                 int ndx1, int tries1,
-                 int ndx2, int tries2,
-                 int ndx3, int tries3,
+                 int rix0, int tries0,
+                 int rix1, int tries1,
+                 int rix2, int tries2,
+                 int rix3, int tries3,
                  int short_tries, int tries, int status)
 {
        struct sample_node *sn = ATH_NODE_SAMPLE(an);
        struct sample_softc *ssc = ATH_SOFTC_SAMPLE(sc);
-       int tt = 0;
-       int tries_so_far = 0;
-       int size_bin = 0;
-       int size = 0;
-       int rate = 0;
-
-       size_bin = size_to_bin(frame_size);
-       size = bin_to_size(size_bin);
+       const int size_bin = size_to_bin(frame_size);
+       const int size = bin_to_size(size_bin);
+       int tt, tries_so_far;
 
-       if (!(0 <= ndx0 && ndx0 < sn->num_rates))
+       if (!IS_RATE_DEFINED(sn, rix0))
                return;
-       rate = sn->rates[ndx0].rate;
+       tt = calc_usecs_unicast_packet(sc, size, rix0, short_tries,
+               MIN(tries0, tries) - 1);
+       tries_so_far = tries0;
 
-       tt += calc_usecs_unicast_packet(sc, size, sn->rates[ndx0].rix, 
-                                       short_tries,
-                                       MIN(tries0, tries) - 1);
-       tries_so_far += tries0;
-       if (tries1 && tries0 < tries) {
-               if (!(0 <= ndx1 && ndx1 < sn->num_rates))
+       if (tries1 && tries_so_far < tries) {
+               if (!IS_RATE_DEFINED(sn, rix1))
                        return;
-               tt += calc_usecs_unicast_packet(sc, size, sn->rates[ndx1].rix, 
-                                               short_tries,
-                                               MIN(tries1 + tries_so_far, 
tries) - tries_so_far - 1);
+               tt += calc_usecs_unicast_packet(sc, size, rix1, short_tries,
+                       MIN(tries1 + tries_so_far, tries) - tries_so_far - 1);
+               tries_so_far += tries1;
        }
-       tries_so_far += tries1;
 
-       if (tries2 && tries0 + tries1 < tries) {
-               if (!(0 <= ndx2 && ndx2 < sn->num_rates))
+       if (tries2 && tries_so_far < tries) {
+               if (!IS_RATE_DEFINED(sn, rix2))
                        return;
-               tt += calc_usecs_unicast_packet(sc, size, sn->rates[ndx2].rix, 
-                                              short_tries,
-                                               MIN(tries2 + tries_so_far, 
tries) - tries_so_far - 1);
+               tt += calc_usecs_unicast_packet(sc, size, rix2, short_tries,
+                       MIN(tries2 + tries_so_far, tries) - tries_so_far - 1);
+               tries_so_far += tries2;
        }
 
-       tries_so_far += tries2;
-
-       if (tries3 && tries0 + tries1 + tries2 < tries) {
-               if (!(0 <= ndx3 && ndx3 < sn->num_rates))
+       if (tries3 && tries_so_far < tries) {
+               if (!IS_RATE_DEFINED(sn, rix3))
                        return;
-               tt += calc_usecs_unicast_packet(sc, size, sn->rates[ndx3].rix, 
-                                               short_tries,
-                                               MIN(tries3 + tries_so_far, 
tries) - tries_so_far - 1);
+               tt += calc_usecs_unicast_packet(sc, size, rix3, short_tries,
+                       MIN(tries3 + tries_so_far, tries) - tries_so_far - 1);
        }
-       if (sn->stats[size_bin][ndx0].total_packets < (100 / (100 - 
ssc->ath_smoothing_rate))) {
+
+       if (sn->stats[size_bin][rix0].total_packets < 
ssc->smoothing_minpackets) {
                /* just average the first few packets */
-               int avg_tx = sn->stats[size_bin][ndx0].average_tx_time;
-               int packets = sn->stats[size_bin][ndx0].total_packets;
-               sn->stats[size_bin][ndx0].average_tx_time = 
(tt+(avg_tx*packets))/(packets+1);
+               int avg_tx = sn->stats[size_bin][rix0].average_tx_time;
+               int packets = sn->stats[size_bin][rix0].total_packets;
+               sn->stats[size_bin][rix0].average_tx_time = 
(tt+(avg_tx*packets))/(packets+1);
        } else {
                /* use a ewma */
-               sn->stats[size_bin][ndx0].average_tx_time = 
-                       ((sn->stats[size_bin][ndx0].average_tx_time * 
ssc->ath_smoothing_rate) + 
-                        (tt * (100 - ssc->ath_smoothing_rate))) / 100;
+               sn->stats[size_bin][rix0].average_tx_time = 
+                       ((sn->stats[size_bin][rix0].average_tx_time * 
ssc->smoothing_rate) + 
+                        (tt * (100 - ssc->smoothing_rate))) / 100;
        }
        
-       if (status) {
+       if (status != 0) {
                int y;
-               sn->stats[size_bin][ndx0].successive_failures++;
+               sn->stats[size_bin][rix0].successive_failures++;
                for (y = size_bin+1; y < NUM_PACKET_SIZE_BINS; y++) {
-                       /* also say larger packets failed since we
-                        * assume if a small packet fails at a lower
+                       /*
+                        * Also say larger packets failed since we
+                        * assume if a small packet fails at a
                         * bit-rate then a larger one will also.
                         */
-                       sn->stats[y][ndx0].successive_failures++;
-                       sn->stats[y][ndx0].last_tx = ticks;
-                       sn->stats[y][ndx0].tries += tries;
-                       sn->stats[y][ndx0].total_packets++;
+                       sn->stats[y][rix0].successive_failures++;
+                       sn->stats[y][rix0].last_tx = ticks;
+                       sn->stats[y][rix0].tries += tries;
+                       sn->stats[y][rix0].total_packets++;
                }
        } else {
-               sn->stats[size_bin][ndx0].packets_acked++;
-               sn->stats[size_bin][ndx0].successive_failures = 0;
+               sn->stats[size_bin][rix0].packets_acked++;
+               sn->stats[size_bin][rix0].successive_failures = 0;
        }
-       sn->stats[size_bin][ndx0].tries += tries;
-       sn->stats[size_bin][ndx0].last_tx = ticks;
-       sn->stats[size_bin][ndx0].total_packets++;
-
+       sn->stats[size_bin][rix0].tries += tries;
+       sn->stats[size_bin][rix0].last_tx = ticks;
+       sn->stats[size_bin][rix0].total_packets++;
 
-       if (ndx0 == sn->current_sample_ndx[size_bin]) {
+       if (rix0 == sn->current_sample_rix[size_bin]) {
                IEEE80211_NOTE(an->an_node.ni_vap, IEEE80211_MSG_RATECTL,
                   &an->an_node,
 "%s: size %d %s sample rate %d tries (%d/%d) tt %d avg_tt (%d/%d)", 
                    __func__, 
                    size,
                    status ? "FAIL" : "OK",
-                   rate, short_tries, tries, tt, 
-                   sn->stats[size_bin][ndx0].average_tx_time,
-                   sn->stats[size_bin][ndx0].perfect_tx_time);
+                   rix0, short_tries, tries, tt, 
+                   sn->stats[size_bin][rix0].average_tx_time,
+                   sn->stats[size_bin][rix0].perfect_tx_time);
                sn->sample_tt[size_bin] = tt;
-               sn->current_sample_ndx[size_bin] = -1;
+               sn->current_sample_rix[size_bin] = -1;
        }
 }
 
@@ -492,19 +555,18 @@ ath_rate_tx_complete(struct ath_softc *s
        struct sample_node *sn = ATH_NODE_SAMPLE(an);
        const struct ath_tx_status *ts = &bf->bf_status.ds_txstat;
        const struct ath_desc *ds0 = &bf->bf_desc[0];
-       int final_rate, short_tries, long_tries, frame_size;
+       int final_rix, short_tries, long_tries, frame_size;
        const HAL_RATE_TABLE *rt = sc->sc_currates;
        int mrr;
 
-       final_rate = sc->sc_hwmap[
-           rt->rateCodeToIndex[ts->ts_rate &~ HAL_TXSTAT_ALTRATE]].ieeerate;
+       final_rix = rt->rateCodeToIndex[ts->ts_rate &~ HAL_TXSTAT_ALTRATE];
        short_tries = ts->ts_shortretry;
        long_tries = ts->ts_longretry + 1;
        frame_size = ds0->ds_ctl0 & 0x0fff; /* low-order 12 bits of ds_ctl0 */
        if (frame_size == 0)                /* NB: should not happen */
                frame_size = 1500;
 
-       if (sn->num_rates <= 0) {
+       if (sn->ratemask == 0) {
                IEEE80211_NOTE(an->an_node.ni_vap, IEEE80211_MSG_RATECTL,
                    &an->an_node,
                    "%s: size %d %s rate/try %d/%d no rates yet", 
@@ -516,9 +578,7 @@ ath_rate_tx_complete(struct ath_softc *s
        }
        mrr = sc->sc_mrretry && !(ic->ic_flags & IEEE80211_F_USEPROT);
        if (!mrr || !(ts->ts_rate & HAL_TXSTAT_ALTRATE)) {
-               int ndx = rate_to_ndx(sn, final_rate);
-
-               if (ndx < 0) {
+               if (!IS_RATE_DEFINED(sn, final_rix)) {
                        badrate(ifp, 0, ts->ts_rate, long_tries, ts->ts_status);
                        return;
                }
@@ -530,18 +590,18 @@ ath_rate_tx_complete(struct ath_softc *s
                     __func__,
                     bin_to_size(size_to_bin(frame_size)),
                     ts->ts_status ? "FAIL" : "OK",
-                    final_rate, short_tries, long_tries);
+                    final_rix, short_tries, long_tries);
                update_stats(sc, an, frame_size, 
-                            ndx, long_tries,
+                            final_rix, long_tries,
                             0, 0,
                             0, 0,
                             0, 0,
                             short_tries, long_tries, ts->ts_status);
        } else {
-               int hwrate0, rate0, tries0, ndx0;
-               int hwrate1, rate1, tries1, ndx1;
-               int hwrate2, rate2, tries2, ndx2;
-               int hwrate3, rate3, tries3, ndx3;
+               int hwrate0, rix0, tries0;
+               int hwrate1, rix1, tries1;
+               int hwrate2, rix2, tries2;
+               int hwrate3, rix3, tries3;
                int finalTSIdx = ts->ts_finaltsi;
 
                /*
@@ -559,30 +619,17 @@ ath_rate_tx_complete(struct ath_softc *s
                        hwrate3 = MS(ds0->ds_ctl3, AR5416_XmitRate3);
                }
 
-               rate0 = sc->sc_hwmap[rt->rateCodeToIndex[hwrate0]].ieeerate;
+               rix0 = rt->rateCodeToIndex[hwrate0];
                tries0 = MS(ds0->ds_ctl2, AR_XmitDataTries0);
-               ndx0 = rate_to_ndx(sn, rate0);
 
-               rate1 = sc->sc_hwmap[rt->rateCodeToIndex[hwrate1]].ieeerate;
+               rix1 = rt->rateCodeToIndex[hwrate1];
                tries1 = MS(ds0->ds_ctl2, AR_XmitDataTries1);
-               ndx1 = rate_to_ndx(sn, rate1);
 
-               rate2 = sc->sc_hwmap[rt->rateCodeToIndex[hwrate2]].ieeerate;
+               rix2 = rt->rateCodeToIndex[hwrate2];
                tries2 = MS(ds0->ds_ctl2, AR_XmitDataTries2);
-               ndx2 = rate_to_ndx(sn, rate2);
 
-               rate3 = sc->sc_hwmap[rt->rateCodeToIndex[hwrate3]].ieeerate;
+               rix3 = rt->rateCodeToIndex[hwrate3];
                tries3 = MS(ds0->ds_ctl2, AR_XmitDataTries3);
-               ndx3 = rate_to_ndx(sn, rate3);
-
-               if (tries0 && ndx0 < 0)
-                       badrate(ifp, 0, hwrate0, tries0, ts->ts_status);
-               if (tries1 && ndx1 < 0)
-                       badrate(ifp, 1, hwrate1, tries1, ts->ts_status);
-               if (tries2 && ndx2 < 0)
-                       badrate(ifp, 2, hwrate2, tries2, ts->ts_status);
-               if (tries3 && ndx3 < 0)
-                       badrate(ifp, 3, hwrate3, tries3, ts->ts_status);
 
                IEEE80211_NOTE(an->an_node.ni_vap, IEEE80211_MSG_RATECTL,
                    &an->an_node,
@@ -592,10 +639,19 @@ ath_rate_tx_complete(struct ath_softc *s
                     finalTSIdx,
                     long_tries, 
                     ts->ts_status ? "FAIL" : "OK",
-                    rate0, tries0,
-                    rate1, tries1,
-                    rate2, tries2,
-                    rate3, tries3);
+                    rix0, tries0,
+                    rix1, tries1,
+                    rix2, tries2,
+                    rix3, tries3);
+
+               if (tries0 && !IS_RATE_DEFINED(sn, rix0))
+                       badrate(ifp, 0, hwrate0, tries0, ts->ts_status);
+               if (tries1 && !IS_RATE_DEFINED(sn, rix1))
+                       badrate(ifp, 1, hwrate1, tries1, ts->ts_status);
+               if (tries2 && !IS_RATE_DEFINED(sn, rix2))
+                       badrate(ifp, 2, hwrate2, tries2, ts->ts_status);
+               if (tries3 && !IS_RATE_DEFINED(sn, rix3))
+                       badrate(ifp, 3, hwrate3, tries3, ts->ts_status);
 
                /*
                 * NB: series > 0 are not penalized for failure
@@ -606,10 +662,10 @@ ath_rate_tx_complete(struct ath_softc *s
                 */
                if (tries0) {
                        update_stats(sc, an, frame_size, 
-                                    ndx0, tries0, 
-                                    ndx1, tries1, 
-                                    ndx2, tries2, 
-                                    ndx3, tries3, 
+                                    rix0, tries0, 
+                                    rix1, tries1, 
+                                    rix2, tries2, 
+                                    rix3, tries3, 
                                     short_tries, long_tries, 
                                     long_tries > tries0);
                        long_tries -= tries0;
@@ -617,9 +673,9 @@ ath_rate_tx_complete(struct ath_softc *s
                
                if (tries1 && finalTSIdx > 0) {
                        update_stats(sc, an, frame_size, 
-                                    ndx1, tries1, 
-                                    ndx2, tries2, 
-                                    ndx3, tries3, 
+                                    rix1, tries1, 
+                                    rix2, tries2, 
+                                    rix3, tries3, 
                                     0, 0, 
                                     short_tries, long_tries, 
                                     ts->ts_status);
@@ -628,8 +684,8 @@ ath_rate_tx_complete(struct ath_softc *s
 
                if (tries2 && finalTSIdx > 1) {
                        update_stats(sc, an, frame_size, 
-                                    ndx2, tries2, 
-                                    ndx3, tries3, 
+                                    rix2, tries2, 
+                                    rix3, tries3, 
                                     0, 0,
                                     0, 0,
                                     short_tries, long_tries, 
@@ -639,7 +695,7 @@ ath_rate_tx_complete(struct ath_softc *s
 
                if (tries3 && finalTSIdx > 2) {
                        update_stats(sc, an, frame_size, 
-                                    ndx3, tries3, 
+                                    rix3, tries3, 
                                     0, 0,
                                     0, 0,
                                     0, 0,
@@ -656,6 +712,21 @@ ath_rate_newassoc(struct ath_softc *sc, 
                ath_rate_ctl_reset(sc, &an->an_node);
 }
 
+static const struct txschedule *mrr_schedules[IEEE80211_MODE_MAX+2] = {
+       NULL,           /* IEEE80211_MODE_AUTO */
+       series_11a,     /* IEEE80211_MODE_11A */
+       series_11g,     /* IEEE80211_MODE_11B */
+       series_11g,     /* IEEE80211_MODE_11G */
+       NULL,           /* IEEE80211_MODE_FH */
+       series_11a,     /* IEEE80211_MODE_TURBO_A */
+       series_11g,     /* IEEE80211_MODE_TURBO_G */
+       series_11a,     /* IEEE80211_MODE_STURBO_A */
+       series_11a,     /* IEEE80211_MODE_11NA */
+       series_11g,     /* IEEE80211_MODE_11NG */
+       series_half,    /* IEEE80211_MODE_HALF */
+       series_quarter, /* IEEE80211_MODE_QUARTER */
+};
+
 /*
  * Initialize the tables for a node.
  */
@@ -663,14 +734,22 @@ static void
 ath_rate_ctl_reset(struct ath_softc *sc, struct ieee80211_node *ni)
 {
 #define        RATE(_ix)       (ni->ni_rates.rs_rates[(_ix)] & 
IEEE80211_RATE_VAL)
+#define        DOT11RATE(_ix)  (rt->info[(_ix)].dot11Rate & IEEE80211_RATE_VAL)
        struct ath_node *an = ATH_NODE(ni);
        const struct ieee80211_txparam *tp = ni->ni_txparms;
        struct sample_node *sn = ATH_NODE_SAMPLE(an);
        const HAL_RATE_TABLE *rt = sc->sc_currates;
-       int x, y, srate;
+       int x, y, srate, rix;
 
        KASSERT(rt != NULL, ("no rate table, mode %u", sc->sc_curmode));
-        sn->static_rate_ndx = -1;
+
+       KASSERT(sc->sc_curmode < IEEE80211_MODE_MAX+2,
+           ("curmode %u", sc->sc_curmode));
+       sn->sched = mrr_schedules[sc->sc_curmode];
+       KASSERT(sn->sched != NULL,
+           ("no mrr schedule for mode %u", sc->sc_curmode));
+
+        sn->static_rix = -1;
        if (tp != NULL && tp->ucastrate != IEEE80211_FIXED_RATE_NONE) {
                /*
                 * A fixed rate is to be used; ic_fixed_rate is the
@@ -689,122 +768,227 @@ ath_rate_ctl_reset(struct ath_softc *sc,
                 * can fail.
                 */
                if (srate >= 0)
-                       sn->static_rate_ndx = srate;
+                       sn->static_rix = sc->sc_rixmap[srate];
        }
 
-       sn->num_rates = ni->ni_rates.rs_nrates;
-        for (x = 0; x < ni->ni_rates.rs_nrates; x++) {
-               sn->rates[x].rate = ni->ni_rates.rs_rates[x] & 
IEEE80211_RATE_VAL;
-               sn->rates[x].rix = sc->sc_rixmap[sn->rates[x].rate];
-               if (sn->rates[x].rix == 0xff) {
-                       IEEE80211_NOTE(ni->ni_vap, IEEE80211_MSG_RATECTL, ni,
-                           "%s: ignore bogus rix at %d", __func__, x);
+       /*
+        * Construct a bitmask of usable rates.  This has all
+        * negotiated rates minus those marked by the hal as
+        * to be ignored for doing rate control.
+        */
+       sn->ratemask = 0;
+       for (x = 0; x < ni->ni_rates.rs_nrates; x++) {
+               rix = sc->sc_rixmap[RATE(x)];
+               if (rix == 0xff)
                        continue;
-               }
-               sn->rates[x].rateCode = rt->info[sn->rates[x].rix].rateCode;
-               sn->rates[x].shortPreambleRateCode = 
-                       rt->info[sn->rates[x].rix].rateCode | 
-                       rt->info[sn->rates[x].rix].shortPreamble;
+               /* skip rates marked broken by hal */
+               if (!rt->info[rix].valid)
+                       continue;
+               KASSERT(rix < SAMPLE_MAXRATES,
+                   ("rate %u has rix %d", RATE(x), rix));
+               sn->ratemask |= 1<<rix;
        }
 #ifdef IEEE80211_DEBUG
        if (ieee80211_msg(ni->ni_vap, IEEE80211_MSG_RATECTL)) {
+               uint32_t mask;
+
                ieee80211_note(ni->ni_vap, "[%6D] %s: size 1600 rate/tt",
-                   __func__, ni->ni_macaddr, ":");
-               for (x = 0; x < sn->num_rates; x++) {
-                       if (sn->rates[x].rix == 0xff)
+                   ni->ni_macaddr, ":", __func__);
+               for (mask = sn->ratemask, rix = 0; mask != 0; mask >>= 1, 
rix++) {
+                       if ((mask & 1) == 0)
                                continue;
-                       printf(" %d/%d", sn->rates[x].rate,
-                           calc_usecs_unicast_packet(sc, 1600,
-                               sn->rates[x].rix, 0,0));
+                       printf(" %d/%d", DOT11RATE(rix) / 2,
+                           calc_usecs_unicast_packet(sc, 1600, rix, 0,0));
                }
                printf("\n");
        }
 #endif
        for (y = 0; y < NUM_PACKET_SIZE_BINS; y++) {
                int size = bin_to_size(y);
-               int ndx = 0;
+               uint32_t mask;
+
                sn->packets_sent[y] = 0;
-               sn->current_sample_ndx[y] = -1;
-               sn->last_sample_ndx[y] = 0;
+               sn->current_sample_rix[y] = -1;
+               sn->last_sample_rix[y] = 0;
+               /* XXX start with first valid rate */
+               sn->current_rix[y] = ffs(sn->ratemask)-1;
                
-               for (x = 0; x < ni->ni_rates.rs_nrates; x++) {
-                       sn->stats[y][x].successive_failures = 0;
-                       sn->stats[y][x].tries = 0;
-                       sn->stats[y][x].total_packets = 0;
-                       sn->stats[y][x].packets_acked = 0;
-                       sn->stats[y][x].last_tx = 0;
+               /*
+                * Initialize the statistics buckets; these are
+                * indexed by the rate code index.
+                */
+               for (rix = 0, mask = sn->ratemask; mask != 0; rix++, mask >>= 
1) {
+                       if ((mask & 1) == 0)            /* not a valid rate */
+                               continue;
+                       sn->stats[y][rix].successive_failures = 0;
+                       sn->stats[y][rix].tries = 0;
+                       sn->stats[y][rix].total_packets = 0;
+                       sn->stats[y][rix].packets_acked = 0;
+                       sn->stats[y][rix].last_tx = 0;
                        
-                       sn->stats[y][x].perfect_tx_time = 
-                               calc_usecs_unicast_packet(sc, size, 
-                                                         sn->rates[x].rix,
-                                                         0, 0);
-                       sn->stats[y][x].average_tx_time = 
sn->stats[y][x].perfect_tx_time;
+                       sn->stats[y][rix].perfect_tx_time =
+                           calc_usecs_unicast_packet(sc, size, rix, 0, 0);

*** DIFF OUTPUT TRUNCATED AT 1000 LINES ***
_______________________________________________
svn-src-all@freebsd.org mailing list
http://lists.freebsd.org/mailman/listinfo/svn-src-all
To unsubscribe, send any mail to "[EMAIL PROTECTED]"

Reply via email to