Re: [sword-devel] Config file for thml module

2010-12-01 Thread Karl Kleinpaste
Chris Little writes: > I really wouldn't say that the collective output of people producing > content in ThML for the Xiphos repository has any chance of countering the > trend of OSIS/TEI content produced for CrossWire (numerically speaking). It is not and never was any kind of competition. It

Re: [sword-devel] Config file for thml module

2010-11-30 Thread Chris Little
On 11/30/2010 6:58 AM, Greg Hellings wrote: On Mon, Nov 29, 2010 at 10:36 PM, Chris Little wrote: It's also worth noting that only the OSIS and TEI counts are likely to increase much in the future. For your work, perhaps. But with the current state of OSIS vs ThML that I mentioned in my em

Re: [sword-devel] Config file for thml module [SOLVED]

2010-11-30 Thread Mario Marín
On Tue, Nov 30, 2010 at 03:35:13PM +0100, Peter von Kaehne wrote: > > > Von: "Mario Marín" > > >you can consider this thread as closed. > > LOL - if you think you could stop a developing flamefest over OSIS vs > ThML between us CrossWire lot so easily, you have a lot to learn > still... ;-) I

Re: [sword-devel] Config file for thml module

2010-11-30 Thread Greg Hellings
On Mon, Nov 29, 2010 at 10:36 PM, Chris Little wrote: > OSIS 212 modules > ThML 156 modules > Plaintext 42 modules > GBF 30 modules > TEI 22 modules And Xiphos' repository has another 41 ThML and 7 OSIS (I also see 1 plain, 1 TEI and 1 GBF) which makes it 219 OSIS and 197 ThML. My InstallMgr rep

Re: [sword-devel] Config file for thml module [SOLVED]

2010-11-30 Thread Peter von Kaehne
> Von: "Mario Marín" >you can consider this thread as closed. LOL - if you think you could stop a developing flamefest over OSIS vs ThML between us CrossWire lot so easily, you have a lot to learn still... ;-) This thread is a repetitive occurence, usually around this time of the year when

Re: [sword-devel] Config file for thml module [SOLVED]

2010-11-30 Thread Mario Marín
On Mon, Nov 29, 2010 at 09:07:16PM -0500, Brian J. Dumont wrote: > On 11/29/2010 05:18 PM, David Haslam wrote: > > Though this enquiry has generated a number of "asides", mmfmarin is still > > awaiting help on using this. > > > To summarize: it seems to me, that we've presented mmfmarin with two

Re: [sword-devel] Config file for thml module

2010-11-30 Thread Trevor Jenkins
On Mon, 29 Nov 2010, Greg Hellings wrote: > On Mon, Nov 29, 2010 at 9:30 PM, DM Smith wrote: > > ROFL is semantic markup. It is a level 1 heading. Given that this > > is one of HTML's title markup, one probably can deduce that it is a title. > > Note that IE, FireFox, Opera, Safari are not con

Re: [sword-devel] Config file for thml module

2010-11-29 Thread Chris Little
On 11/29/2010 7:19 PM, Greg Hellings wrote: It must be working, because of the two main formats that are available (semantic OSIS and presentational ThML) I'd venture to guess that ThML is the more common in SWORD modules. I'm open to being wrong, but I would guess that I'm not. This isn't p

Re: [sword-devel] Config file for thml module

2010-11-29 Thread Karl Kleinpaste
Chris Little writes: > ThML's fading value in other genre notwithstanding, it has almost > always been useless for Bibles. I have generated 44 ThML Bible modules. They look quite good. My spin of NET/NETnote is a heckuva lot better than bible.org's own -- far more featureful, and more true to e

Re: [sword-devel] Config file for thml module

2010-11-29 Thread Greg Hellings
On Mon, Nov 29, 2010 at 9:30 PM, DM Smith wrote: > ROFL is semantic markup. It is a level 1 heading. Given that this is > one of HTML's title markup, one probably can deduce that it is a title. Note > that IE, FireFox, Opera, Safari are not consistent in how they render . > Ah, but it wasn't my

Re: [sword-devel] Config file for thml module

2010-11-29 Thread DM Smith
ROFL is semantic markup. It is a level 1 heading. Given that this is one of HTML's title markup, one probably can deduce that it is a title. Note that IE, FireFox, Opera, Safari are not consistent in how they render . If you had used the tag then it would have been presentational. ;) On Nov 2

Re: [sword-devel] Config file for thml module

2010-11-29 Thread Greg Hellings
On Mon, Nov 29, 2010 at 12:57 PM, Trevor Jenkins wrote: > On Mon, 29 Nov 2010, Greg Hellings wrote: > >> And ThML continues to be used to create Bible modules because it is the best >> tool for module creators who care about their presentation more than some >> semantic dream world of markup. > >

Re: [sword-devel] Config file for thml module

2010-11-29 Thread Brian J. Dumont
On 11/29/2010 04:48 PM, Kahunapule Michael Johnson wrote: > On 11/29/2010 11:57 AM, Trevor Jenkins wrote: >> Um, strictly speaking a markup scheme (such as ThML) is divorced from >> presentational issues. Markup should identify document structure it >> shouldn't deal with display at all. But then h

Re: [sword-devel] Config file for thml module

2010-11-29 Thread Brian J. Dumont
On 11/29/2010 05:18 PM, David Haslam wrote: > Though this enquiry has generated a number of "asides", mmfmarin is still > awaiting help on using this. > To summarize: it seems to me, that we've presented mmfmarin with two options: 1. Make a ThML-ish IMP file. This is probably the fastest wa

Re: [sword-devel] Config file for thml module

2010-11-29 Thread Chris Little
On 11/29/2010 2:25 PM, Greg Hellings wrote: xml2gbs is the wrong utility. I don't even remember if that is the proper utility for anything or if it has been superseded, but it is definitely the wrong utility for him. xml2gbs is the tool for importing valid ThML & OSIS freeform books into Gen

Re: [sword-devel] Config file for thml module

2010-11-29 Thread Chris Little
On 11/29/2010 2:18 PM, David Haslam wrote: I suspect that thml2osis.xslt is now quite old. The README says it was maintained by Luke Plant. Last time we heard from him (on any topic) in this mailing list was May 14, 2009. Indeed, that isn't the converter that CCEL used. Now that I think abo

Re: [sword-devel] Config file for thml module

2010-11-29 Thread Greg Hellings
OP's question has been answered at least twice in this thread. xml2gbs is the wrong utility. I don't even remember if that is the proper utility for anything or if it has been superseded, but it is definitely the wrong utility for him. I gave more extensive directions on using ThML in my earlier e

Re: [sword-devel] Config file for thml module

2010-11-29 Thread David Haslam
I suspect that thml2osis.xslt is now quite old. The README says it was maintained by Luke Plant. Last time we heard from him (on any topic) in this mailing list was May 14, 2009. Though this enquiry has generated a number of "asides", mmfmarin is still awaiting help on using this. David -- Vie

Re: [sword-devel] Config file for thml module

2010-11-29 Thread Kahunapule Michael Johnson
Title: signature On 11/29/2010 11:57 AM, Trevor Jenkins wrote: Um, strictly speaking a markup scheme (such as ThML) is divorced from presentational issues. Markup should identify document structure it shouldn't deal with display at all. But then having been a member of IEC/ISO TC1/SC18/WG8 a

Re: [sword-devel] Config file for thml module

2010-11-29 Thread Trevor Jenkins
On Mon, 29 Nov 2010, Greg Hellings wrote: > And ThML continues to be used to create Bible modules because it is the best > tool for module creators who care about their presentation more than some > semantic dream world of markup. Um, strictly speaking a markup scheme (such as ThML) is divorced

Re: [sword-devel] Config file for thml module

2010-11-29 Thread DM Smith
On 11/29/2010 12:30 PM, Greg Hellings wrote: And ThML continues to be used to create Bible modules because it is the best tool for module creators who care about their presentation The problem I have with that part of the statement is that often presentation is presumed to be rather singul

Re: [sword-devel] Config file for thml module

2010-11-29 Thread Greg Hellings
And ThML continues to be used to create Bible modules because it is the best tool for module creators who care about their presentation more than some semantic dream world of markup. To create a ThML Bible or commentary you will need to use the imp format and then just markup within the verses wit

Re: [sword-devel] Config file for thml module

2010-11-29 Thread Brian J. Dumont
On 11/29/2010 11:17 AM, Mario Marín wrote: > >> If I understand correctly from the fact that you're using xml2gbs, >> you're working on a ThML Genbook, right? (As opposed to a Bible, >> Commentary, or Dictionary) >> > No, it's a bible. > Aha! That's why. For starters, you should ignore a

Re: [sword-devel] Config file for thml module

2010-11-29 Thread Mario Marín
On Fri, 2010-11-26 at 19:07 -0800, Chris Little wrote: > > On 11/26/2010 1:24 PM, mmfma...@gmail.com wrote: > > ModDrv? > > ModDrv=RawGenBook > > > CompressType? > > > > BlockType? > > Omit both of these. I tried that but the module is not showing its text yet. > > The module I created is rec

Re: [sword-devel] Config file for thml module

2010-11-29 Thread Mario Marín
On Fri, 2010-11-26 at 18:51 -0500, Brian J. Dumont wrote: > Hi mmfmarin, Hi Brian, thanks for your reply. > If I understand correctly from the fact that you're using xml2gbs, > you're working on a ThML Genbook, right? (As opposed to a Bible, > Commentary, or Dictionary) No, it's a bible. > I'd

Re: [sword-devel] Config file for thml module

2010-11-28 Thread jhphx
On 11/28/2010 3:05 AM, Jonathan Morgan wrote: Hi David, See http://www.ccel.org/about/copyright.html. CCEL are not claiming copyright on the text (which is public domain). What they are claiming copyright on is the XML markup (references, sections, ...). This XML markup is the version we w

Re: [sword-devel] Config file for thml module

2010-11-28 Thread Chris Little
There are a couple of further complications to any copyright claim on CCEL content (at least content produced prior to their change of policy). First, they were distributing all of that content clearly labeled as public domain. This is closely akin to copyfraud, if not necessarily the typical

Re: [sword-devel] Config file for thml module

2010-11-28 Thread Jonathan Morgan
Hi David, See http://www.ccel.org/about/copyright.html. CCEL are not claiming copyright on the text (which is public domain). What they are claiming copyright on is the XML markup (references, sections, ...). This XML markup is the version we would use in any of our modules. While this kind of

Re: [sword-devel] Config file for thml module

2010-11-27 Thread David Haslam
Chris, If CCEL really are claiming copyright on PD works (etc), is it still appropriate to include CCEL in the answer to this http://crosswire.org/wiki/EnduserFAQ#Can_I_donate_to_your_ministry.3F FAQ ? cf. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyfraud Wikipedia page about Copyfraud Has anyone fro

Re: [sword-devel] Config file for thml module

2010-11-26 Thread Chris Little
On 11/26/2010 1:24 PM, mmfma...@gmail.com wrote: Thanks for this great software. I have an old thml file and I want to create a module to open it in xiphos. The command I ran for this was: xml2gbs -fT ~/path/to/file.thml modulename The module seems OK, I get the following files: modulename.

Re: [sword-devel] Config file for thml module

2010-11-26 Thread Brian J. Dumont
Hi mmfmarin, If I understand correctly from the fact that you're using xml2gbs, you're working on a ThML Genbook, right? (As opposed to a Bible, Commentary, or Dictionary) I'd suggest you start by looking in two places. Firstly, look at the conf file for another ThML Genbook. I would suggest "S

[sword-devel] Config file for thml module

2010-11-26 Thread mmfma...@gmail.com
Thanks for this great software. I have an old thml file and I want to create a module to open it in xiphos. The command I ran for this was: xml2gbs -fT ~/path/to/file.thml modulename The module seems OK, I get the following files: modulename.bdt modulename.dat modulename.idx I don't know the