+1 for XML bundle configs - especially in redistributed code. Until a
couple of weeks ago I LOATHED XML and always used YAML in my Symfony2
experiments. As my applications grow, I've come to rely on XML schema
errors to alert me when I fat finger a config, which has bitten me in
the ass with YAML a
On 9/7/10 2:05 PM, Jordi Boggiano wrote:
On 07.09.2010 13:57, Fabien Potencier wrote:
I have the answer for redistributable bundles: they must use XML as
their only way to provide configuration (as explained in the
documentation). Annotations must only be used for end-user code.
Which means yo
On 07.09.2010 13:57, Fabien Potencier wrote:
> I have the answer for redistributable bundles: they must use XML as
> their only way to provide configuration (as explained in the
> documentation). Annotations must only be used for end-user code.
Which means you can't easily take your yml-configured
On 9/7/10 1:42 PM, Thomas Rabaix wrote:
I just keep thinking about people writing bundles and integrating these
bundles. Bundles should be able to work out of the box (with DI or
annotation), but all settings should be easily changes without extended
too much classes.
I have the answer for red
On 07.09.2010, at 13:42, Thomas Rabaix wrote:
> I just keep thinking about people writing bundles and integrating these
> bundles. Bundles should be able to work out of the box (with DI or
> annotation), but all settings should be easily changes without extended too
> much classes.
do you th
Annotations should be used to set default values and the AnnotationReader
should be able to get these settings from an external configuration files
and merge them together. I guess I can write my own AnnotationReader, but
this should be done by the core team so all symfony projects will use the
sam
On 07.09.2010, at 12:59, Navid Mitchell wrote:
>> anyway, it was just an example about a general concern i have with
>> annotations. for one they need to still enable extending, that being said in
>> many cases extending will obviously be limited by whats possible without
>> breaking the "is a
Thanks everyone for taking the time to give me their feedback
>> I'm not sure however if the multiplication of configuration options
>> (xml/yaml/php/annotations) isn't gonna bite us in the ass at some point
>> int he future.. It's nice and all that things are so flexible but aren't
>> we abusing
