Re: [Tagging] difference between park and garden

2010-06-06 Thread Steve Bennett
Fwiw, I tag them all "park". Is there any legal difference? It occurs to me that many gardens have fences and gates and are only open during certain hours, but I don't know if that's a general property. Note that most of the parks in central Melbourne are called "garden" (Flagstaff Gardens, Treasu

Re: [Tagging] Proposing bazaars

2010-06-06 Thread John Smith
On 7 June 2010 03:57, John Smith wrote: > In this case I'm guessing you could probably extend the existing > marketplace tag with a sub-tag, rather than a new key/value pair, eg: > > amenity=marketplace > marketplace=bazaar I was nudged to expand my comment a little. Sub-typing is beneficial beca

Re: [Tagging] Proposing bazaars

2010-06-06 Thread Alan Mintz
At 2010-06-06 10:46, pavithran wrote: >On 6 June 2010 22:40, John Smith wrote: > > > There is already a similar tag: > > > > http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Approved_features/Marketplace > > > > Although I don't know if it is similar enough or not, or if it can be > > extended or not, but might

Re: [Tagging] Proposing bazaars

2010-06-06 Thread John Smith
On 7 June 2010 03:38, pavithran wrote: > Sorry for that . I thought a page with status = not defined might be > the correct way . I have created pages for motorcycle shop and > motorcycle repair . Should have created a proposal page also for them Or at least discuss things first to find out if th

Re: [Tagging] Proposing bazaars

2010-06-06 Thread John Smith
On 7 June 2010 03:46, pavithran wrote: > No market places is different ! Market place more or less is like an > area . I used it for this area . Not all market places are areas, the Rocks Markets in Sydney closes the road and has them located on the road. > Well I am talking about roads . that

Re: [Tagging] Proposing bazaars

2010-06-06 Thread pavithran
On 6 June 2010 22:40, John Smith wrote: > There is already a similar tag: > > http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Approved_features/Marketplace > > Although I don't know if it is similar enough or not, or if it can be > extended or not, but might be worth considering at least before > confusing pe

Re: [Tagging] Proposing bazaars

2010-06-06 Thread y...@o2.pl
2010/6/6 pavithran : > Sorry for that . I thought a page with status = not defined might be > the correct way . I have created pages for motorcycle shop and > motorcycle repair . Should have created a proposal page also for them I moved page to http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Proposed_features/

Re: [Tagging] Proposing bazaars

2010-06-06 Thread pavithran
On 6 June 2010 22:48, Ben Laenen wrote: > > Please make a proposal page first before making the new Tag:highway=bazaar Sorry for that . I thought a page with status = not defined might be the correct way . I have created pages for motorcycle shop and motorcycle repair . Should have created a prop

Re: [Tagging] Proposing bazaars

2010-06-06 Thread Ben Laenen
Please make a proposal page first before making the new Tag:highway=bazaar page. This looks like a tag which needs quite some discussion first. Greetings Ben pavithran wrote: > First of all I am using a non native english name called 'bazaar' > which most of you might have heard from 'cathedra

Re: [Tagging] Proposing bazaars

2010-06-06 Thread John Smith
On 7 June 2010 00:42, pavithran wrote: > How to tag ? > Well I started a wiki page which could be further expanded . > http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:highway%3Dbazaar There is already a similar tag: http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Approved_features/Marketplace Although I don't know i

[Tagging] Proposing bazaars

2010-06-06 Thread pavithran
First of all I am using a non native english name called 'bazaar' which most of you might have heard from 'cathedral and bazaar' . What is bazaar ? Shopping streets in developing countries tend to be very narrow and are buzzing with activity . They are heavily crowded with less chance of trucks,car