Re: [talk-au] Boat ramp

2010-01-21 Thread James Livingston
On 21/01/2010, at 9:35 AM, Steve Bennett wrote: I would suggest tagging the way leisure=slipway. If you need to break the current specification to do so, then make a note on the wiki page. Tagging it highway=service seems wrong. Service roads do not go underwater... The tagging system is

Re: [talk-au] Boat ramp

2010-01-21 Thread John Henderson
David Murn wrote: I think slipway is the British term. From the leisure=slipway wiki page: Yes, I'm happy now that they're using the term to apply to both types of boat launching facility. Anyhow, I've changed the tagging to show highway=service to the approximate high water mark, then

Re: [talk-au] Boat ramp

2010-01-20 Thread Steve Bennett
On Wed, Jan 20, 2010 at 9:02 AM, John Henderson snow...@gmx.com wrote: Has anyone got a better suggestion for showing a boat ramp than extending a highway=service out into the water?  The leisure=slipway tag is meant to apply to nodes, not ways. I would suggest tagging the way leisure=slipway.

Re: [talk-au] Boat ramp

2010-01-20 Thread Roy Wallace
On Thu, Jan 21, 2010 at 9:35 AM, Steve Bennett stevag...@gmail.com wrote: I would suggest tagging the way leisure=slipway. If you need to break the current specification to do so, then make a note on the wiki page. Yeah, how strange that a slipWAY can supposedly only apply to a NODE.

Re: [talk-au] Boat ramp

2010-01-20 Thread David Murn
On Thu, 2010-01-21 at 10:35 +1100, Steve Bennett wrote: On Wed, Jan 20, 2010 at 9:02 AM, John Henderson snow...@gmx.com wrote: Has anyone got a better suggestion for showing a boat ramp than extending a highway=service out into the water? The leisure=slipway tag is meant to apply to nodes,

Re: [talk-au] Boat ramp

2010-01-20 Thread John Henderson
Steve Bennett wrote: I would suggest tagging the way leisure=slipway. If you need to break the current specification to do so, then make a note on the wiki page. Tagging it highway=service seems wrong. Service roads do not go underwater... The tagging system is supposed to be flexible and

Re: [talk-au] Boat ramp

2010-01-20 Thread Stephen Hope
2010/1/21 David Murn da...@incanberra.com.au: Also, from the wiki for 'service': Generally for access to a building, motorway service station, beach, campsite, industrial estate, business park, etc.. This doesnt sound wrong to me, if a service road can lead to a beach or campsite, why not to

Re: [talk-au] Boat ramp

2010-01-20 Thread John Smith
2010/1/21 Stephen Hope slh...@gmail.com: A service road can lead to a boat ramp.  But the boat ramp itself is not a point, it's a line. It's usually pretty clear where the ramp starts - where it ends is usually harder to find unless you go wading. Assuming you don't go head over tail on the

Re: [talk-au] Boat ramp

2010-01-20 Thread John Henderson
Stephen Hope wrote: A service road can lead to a boat ramp. But the boat ramp itself is not a point, it's a line. It's usually pretty clear where the ramp starts - where it ends is usually harder to find unless you go wading. Don't worry if it doesn't currently render. Record it in the

Re: [talk-au] Boat ramp

2010-01-20 Thread David Murn
On Thu, 2010-01-21 at 13:51 +1000, Stephen Hope wrote: 2010/1/21 David Murn da...@incanberra.com.au: Also, from the wiki for 'service': Generally for access to a building, motorway service station, beach, campsite, industrial estate, business park, etc.. This doesnt sound wrong to me,

Re: [talk-au] Boat ramp

2010-01-20 Thread David Murn
On Thu, 2010-01-21 at 16:53 +1100, John Henderson wrote: How about tagging boat ramps as: highway=service service=boat_ramp I think a slipway is different from a boat ramp. I know a slipway as a track (perhaps with rollers) for launching boats and for winching them ashore for repairs.

Re: [talk-au] Boat ramp

2010-01-19 Thread David Murn
Hi John, Ive been tagging a few boatramps lately, and your suggestion is basically exactly what Ive been doing, but I have also wondered if it is the best method, and had a few questions. Firstly, leisure=slipway works fine for most cases of boatramps, but some boatramps arent 'leisure', for