Re: [talk-au] foot/bicycle = yes/designated (was Re: TfNSW Cycleways use in OSM)

2020-02-17 Thread Andrew Harvey
On Tue, 18 Feb 2020 at 17:38, Andrew Davidson wrote: > On 18/02/2020 5:11 pm, Andrew Harvey wrote: > > I hold the view that access=yes just means either physical or legal > > access is allowed (or at least not forbidden), whereas access=designated > > implies that it's signposted or otherwise

Re: [talk-au] foot/bicycle = yes/designated (was Re: TfNSW Cycleways use in OSM)

2020-02-17 Thread Andrew Davidson
On 18/02/2020 5:11 pm, Andrew Harvey wrote: I hold the view that access=yes just means either physical or legal access is allowed (or at least not forbidden), whereas access=designated implies that it's signposted or otherwise explicitly designed/used for/by that mode. I'm good with the

Re: [talk-au] foot/bicycle = yes/designated (was Re: TfNSW Cycleways use in OSM)

2020-02-17 Thread Luke Stewart
My understanding is as follows: yes means that there is the legal right to use something e.g. you have the right to walk by foot on a sidewalk. designated means that there is a legal instrument (generally signage and/or possibly road marking depending on your state) that *specifically* gives you

Re: [talk-au] foot/bicycle = yes/designated (was Re: TfNSW Cycleways use in OSM)

2020-02-17 Thread Andrew Harvey
On Tue, 18 Feb 2020 at 15:59, Andrew Davidson wrote: > On 18/02/2020 3:44 pm, Ash Logan wrote: > > In line with this, I've drafted an osmosis TagTransform file that can > > turn the raw TfNSW dataset (after being run through JOSM's OpenData > > plugin, for example) and turn it into the usual OSM

[talk-au] foot/bicycle = yes/designated (was Re: TfNSW Cycleways use in OSM)

2020-02-17 Thread Andrew Davidson
On 18/02/2020 3:44 pm, Ash Logan wrote: In line with this, I've drafted an osmosis TagTransform file that can turn the raw TfNSW dataset (after being run through JOSM's OpenData plugin, for example) and turn it into the usual OSM tagging schema. Check it out: Question: do we have a community