[Talk-GB] Definitive source for UK streetnames? - OS, 'road name signs', or a council 'list'?

2010-08-06 Thread Jason Cunningham
Just read through a short discussion about differences in street names in OSM and 'OS Locator', and problems caused by differences in names given The classic problem is where the road street sign says something like 'Dukes Drive' but OS locator states Duke's Drive. Noticed that common view was OSM

Re: [Talk-GB] Definitive source for UK streetnames? - OS, 'road name signs', or a council 'list'?

2010-08-06 Thread Tim François
I'm not really answering your question here, but thought I'd add in my two pennies: I use OSM data as the map in Navit, a sat-nav program. From my personal point of view, I find it very handy for the sat-nav to direct me to roads which have the same name as the road signs, irrespective of what t

Re: [Talk-GB] Definitive source for UK streetnames? - OS, 'road name signs', or a council 'list'?

2010-08-06 Thread Lester Caine
Jason Cunningham wrote: Just read through a short discussion about differences in street names in OSM and 'OS Locator', and problems caused by differences in names given The classic problem is where the road street sign says something like 'Dukes Drive' but OS locator states Duke's Drive. Noticed

Re: [Talk-GB] Definitive source for UK streetnames? - OS, 'road name signs', or a council 'list'?

2010-08-06 Thread Tom Hughes
On 06/08/10 14:36, Lester Caine wrote: The councils will be be working to the street table in their LLPG data, and it is that which is supplied TO OS as the 'correct' local information. There is even a mechanism for advising changes and new streets in the update format. Which doesn't explain w

Re: [Talk-GB] Definitive source for UK streetnames? - OS, 'road name signs', or a council 'list'?

2010-08-06 Thread Lester Caine
Tom Hughes wrote: On 06/08/10 14:36, Lester Caine wrote: The councils will be be working to the street table in their LLPG data, and it is that which is supplied TO OS as the 'correct' local information. There is even a mechanism for advising changes and new streets in the update format. Whic

[Talk-GB] OS OpenData Viewer

2010-08-06 Thread Ben Pollinger
Hello all, Not sure if this has been mentioned on the lists: http://www.ordnancesurvey.co.uk/oswebsite/opendata/viewer/ Note the boundary layer tab in the top-right. I was only aware of http://os.openstreetmap.org/ Cheers, Ben ___ Talk-GB mailing li

Re: [Talk-GB] Definitive source for UK streetnames? - OS, 'road name signs', or a council 'list'?

2010-08-06 Thread Andy Mabbett
On Fri, August 6, 2010 13:33, Jason Cunningham wrote: > The classic problem is where the road street sign says something like > 'Dukes Drive' but OS locator states Duke's Drive. > Has anyone heard of how this problem is dealt with by authorities Would stripping punctuation (and perhaps white sp

[Talk-GB] Motorway junction naming

2010-08-06 Thread Andy Sinclair
Hello. I notice that a number of motorway junctions near me have been tagged with rather large names. For example, the name tag for M4 J16, normally referred to locally as "Swindon West" is: "A3102 Swindon West, Wootton Bassett, RAF Lyneham, Calne" Should this be simplified in some way?

Re: [Talk-GB] Definitive source for UK streetnames? - OS, 'road name signs', or a council 'list'?

2010-08-06 Thread John Robert Peterson
This is a more fundamental problem than "which source is the correct one" -- names aren't properly defined to begin with. The source for most of these names is simply what locals referred to things as 100 years ago, and what managed to stick when some bloke on a horse with a clipboard asked them.

Re: [Talk-GB] Motorway junction naming

2010-08-06 Thread Ed Avis
Andy Sinclair writes: >I notice that a number of motorway junctions near me have been tagged >with rather large names. > >For example, the name tag for M4 J16, normally referred to locally as >"Swindon West" is: > > "A3102 Swindon West, Wootton Bassett, RAF Lyneham, Calne" > >Should this be s

Re: [Talk-GB] OS OpenData Viewer

2010-08-06 Thread Ed Avis
Ben Pollinger writes: >Not sure if this has been mentioned on the lists: > >http://www.ordnancesurvey.co.uk/oswebsite/opendata/viewer/ Those little mortar-board icons that appear for schools are fun. I wonder if they could be bulk-imported into OSM as amenity=school source=OS? At least in the c

Re: [Talk-GB] Definitive source for UK streetnames? - OS, 'road name signs', or a council 'list'?

2010-08-06 Thread 80n
I recall an intriguing case from one of the very first mapping parties in Rutland. The mapping party was held at Oakam Museum in Catmos Street. It's always been called Catmos Street. It's referred to as Catmos Street in a Francis Frith photo from the 1950s and it was still called Catmos Street i