Re: [Talk-GB] Licensing compatibility

2018-02-15 Thread Simon Poole
Its my personal opinion (which I believe is clear from the text), but given that the attribution terms are essentially the same as for the ODbL, a licence we just happen to have a lot of experience with :-), it is fairly clear that we would be contradicting our stance on acceptable attribution of O

Re: [Talk-GB] Licensing compatibility

2018-02-15 Thread Brian Prangle
Thanks for that Simon - is that just your personal opinion? Should I contact LWG for an official OSMF position? On 15 February 2018 at 09:03, Simon Poole wrote: > AFAIK we've not had any data licensed on ODC-BY 1.0 imported, at least not > on a larger scale. > > The ODC-BY licence was supposed t

Re: [Talk-GB] Licensing compatibility

2018-02-15 Thread Simon Poole
AFAIK we've not had any data licensed on ODC-BY 1.0 imported, at least not on a larger scale. The ODC-BY licence was supposed to be compatible with distribution on ODBL terms just as CC BY should be with CC BY-SA (I would however argue that both do not actually meet that goal), so most terms are s

[Talk-GB] Licensing compatibility

2018-02-14 Thread Brian Prangle
Hi Following my blog criticising BT for not releasing data, Inlink UK have been in touch saying they'd be only too glad to release their data so we can use it in OSM. They've asked the following qu