Re: [Talk-GB] Checking UK Towns

On 30/01/2019 15:08, Gregory Marler wrote: > In a lot of cases the towns nicely relate to parish wards (admin_level=10). I understood admin_level=10 was for whole parishes, not parish wards. Surely parish wards should be boundary=political just like district and county electoral

Re: [Talk-GB] Checking UK Towns

On 30/01/2019 16:00, Tom Hughes wrote: The fundamental problem with this, as Jerry has just said, is that many towns in the UK have no defined boundary. Even where there is an administrative entity there is no guarantee that it's boundary equates to what most people would view as the

Re: [Talk-GB] Checking UK Towns

I also have a couple of observations about these changes. 1) Sometimes an admin_centre is being added to a boundary=political (e.g. parliamentary constituencies, electoral wards). I am not sure this is appropriate. 2) There are multiple definitions of "town", and I don't know which definition

Re: [Talk-GB] Checking UK Towns

I've already raised concerns I have in a changeset comment about these edits adding admin_level=10 administrative boundary relations for voids between civil parishes. They are tagged with designation=non-civil_parish. This has been discussed on this list previously. My main objection is that

Re: [Talk-GB] Checking UK Towns

On 30/01/2019 15:08, Gregory Marler wrote: A small amount of my time has been funded by Open Cage Data to check towns in the UK. Ideally it should be possible to get a town as both a node and a relation. The fundamental problem with this, as Jerry has just said, is that many towns in the UK

Re: [Talk-GB] Checking UK Towns

A few points: * I believe you should complete the relevant organised edit page on the wiki. * I think any use of admin_level=11 or indeed any use of admin_level at all for un-parished areas needed to be discussed up front. Places

[Talk-GB] Checking UK Towns

You might spot my recent map edits with a changeset such as... "*Checking data and relations for towns in Lincolnshire. This changeset forms part of paid work to improve OpenStreetMap data. #UKTownCheck #OrganisedEditing*" A small amount of my time has been funded by Open Cage Data to check towns