Re: [Talk-transit] Several stations in a stop_area

2022-01-22 Thread Paul Johnson
On Sat, Jan 22, 2022 at 6:38 AM Alexey Z via Talk-transit < talk-transit@openstreetmap.org> wrote: > > Hello. > > Let me raise a question/appeal about stop_area relation. PTv2 is very > disputable and imperfect, so I tried to touch a narrow and practical aspect > to solve a specific problem. I

Re: [Talk-transit] Several stations in a stop_area

2022-01-22 Thread Robin Daeneke.at
Hello, as this is about Vienna and I tend to map pt there I thought I‘d say something: Indeed, the definitions of pt-2 are slightly imperfect, and in my eye, relations should be as compact as possible with little redundancy. This is why I put all stops that are part of one station complex into

Re: [Talk-transit] Several stations in a stop_area

2022-01-22 Thread Jarek Piórkowski
Would stop_area_group be a solution here? That was proposed a while back but I'm not sure if it was officially accepted. On Sat, Jan 22, 2022, 07:36 Alexey Z via Talk-transit < talk-transit@openstreetmap.org> wrote: > > Hello. > > Let me raise a question/appeal about stop_area relation. PTv2 is

[Talk-transit] Several stations in a stop_area

2022-01-22 Thread Alexey Z via Talk-transit
  Hello.   Let me raise a question/appeal about stop_area relation. PTv2 is very disputable and imperfect, so I tried to touch a narrow and practical aspect to solve a specific problem. I really hope for your help to make the OSM PT data truly useful for data consumers.   This is the