Re: [Talk-us] Relation member order/structure; best effort worth it?

2014-01-13 Thread Paul Johnson
On Sun, Jan 12, 2014 at 7:18 AM, Peter Davies peter.dav...@crc-corp.comwrote: We would post the cardinal directions using tags for each whole directional relation. However where the Muskogee Turnpike turns from E-W to S-N, or has some even more complex deal such as E +ve and N -ve, the

Re: [Talk-us] Relation member order/structure; best effort worth it?

2014-01-12 Thread Peter Davies
I am very interested to see Paul Johnson's OK relation completion spreadsheet, as I'm trying to make a business decision on whether to use relations when importing OSM data into into our state DOT traffic information applications. These apps are neither navigation nor mapping, but share some

Re: [Talk-us] Relation member order/structure; best effort worth it?

2014-01-12 Thread Andrew Hain
Peter Davies peter.davies@... writes:  Does anyone know if the Europeans (of which I'm one, oops) have any plans to create route relations?  I have found none while in UK, NL, D, A, CH, I and F this past two weeks, but perhaps I didn't look hard enough. Route relations for roads have

Re: [Talk-us] Relation member order/structure; best effort worth it?

2014-01-12 Thread Volker Schmidt
Peter Davies peter.davies@... writes: ?Does anyone know if the Europeans (of which I'm one, oops) have any plans to create route relations? ?I have found none while in UK, NL, D, A, CH, I and F this past two weeks, but perhaps I didn't look hard enough. Route relations are routinely used

Re: [Talk-us] Relation member order/structure; best effort worth it?

2014-01-12 Thread stevea
From my viewpoint, a US crash is On OK 165 northbound at Chandler Road. Currently it looks (from the OK spreadsheet and from my own impressions elsewhere) as if state road relations are still too far from completion for use this year in operational public information systems. And on named,

[Talk-us] Relation member order/structure; best effort worth it?

2014-01-11 Thread stevea
A sidelong topic to separate relations. Volker and I just shared some email about how he uses JOSM automation to order relation elements, whereas I make some effort to smarten them up. This includes getting more, rather than fewer route is ordered messages from JOSM's relation editor's hover