Re: [Talk-us] Categorizing Stores/Restaurants

2011-06-14 Thread Kristian Zoerhoff
Isn't there already a page for the shop=* tag? -- Kristian M Zoerhoff On Jun 14, 2011 6:05 PM, "Josh Kraayenbrink" wrote: > Is there any page on the wiki that has a methodology or straight up > categories of stores and restaurants? I was thinking about creating a page > to help those that don't k

Re: [Talk-us] Categorizing Stores/Restaurants

2011-06-14 Thread Josh Kraayenbrink
It is, but what is the convention in the states for tagging, say, Sears? Department store? Hardware store? other store? The only way you know these things is if you do A LOT of mapping and start to figure out what needs to go where. What if a newbie comes across this and they don't know what to do.

Re: [Talk-us] Categorizing Stores/Restaurants

2011-06-14 Thread Clifford Snow
I'm a newbie and I've come across similar problems. However, maybe the solution isn't so much in tags, but a need to normalize *if that's the right word" the data. Your example of Sears is good. If I populate a store with Sears, why can't I get a potlatch pull down that gives me all the correct

Re: [Talk-us] Categorizing Stores/Restaurants

2011-06-14 Thread Kristian Zoerhoff
I would think Sears = department store; they called themselves that for many years. I think something like Super Wal-Mart or (here in the Midwest) Meijer is tougher; is it department store, clothing, grocery, or something else? I'd rather have a newbie ask a million times, if they learn from it, b

Re: [Talk-us] Categorizing Stores/Restaurants

2011-06-14 Thread Richard Weait
On Tue, Jun 14, 2011 at 10:25 PM, Kristian Zoerhoff wrote: > I would think Sears = department store; they called themselves that for many > years. I think something like Super Wal-Mart or (here in the Midwest) Meijer > is tougher; is it department store, clothing, grocery, or something else? > > I

Re: [Talk-us] Categorizing Stores/Restaurants

2011-06-14 Thread Richard Welty
On 6/14/11 10:25 PM, Kristian Zoerhoff wrote: I would think Sears = department store; they called themselves that for many years. I think something like Super Wal-Mart or (here in the Midwest) Meijer is tougher; is it department store, clothing, grocery, or something else? the variety of goods f

Re: [Talk-us] Categorizing Stores/Restaurants

2011-06-16 Thread dion_dock
raayenbrink , > talk-us@openstreetmap.org > Subject: Re: [Talk-us] Categorizing Stores/Restaurants > Message-ID: > Content-Type: text/plain; charset="iso-8859-1" > > I'm a newbie and I've come across similar problems. However, maybe > the > solution isn'

Re: [Talk-us] Categorizing Stores/Restaurants

2011-06-16 Thread Kristian M Zoerhoff
On Thu, Jun 16, 2011 at 07:52:15PM +, dion_d...@comcast.net wrote: > Businesses don't make it easy when they go by multiple names. Is it IBM > or International Business Machines? > > I'm sure you'll find similar issues with punctuation. IBM or I.B.M.? Only the New York Times insists on I

Re: [Talk-us] Categorizing Stores/Restaurants

2011-06-18 Thread Toby Murray
One of the first times I remember having a similar thought of "how do I tag this?" was with the office supply store Staples. I ended up using shop=office but doing a quick XAPI query now I see that out of the ~250 Staples shops mapped, the tags look like this like this: 6 office_supply 1