Re: [Tango-L] Changes of direction

2008-07-04 Thread Jack Dylan
Chris' comments don't really seem to tell the story correctly. What I've learned from Gustavo Naveira and others is that there are only 6 'changes of direction' and each is a single step. They are: Right foot front cross to left foot back cross; Right foot back cross to left foot front cross; R

Re: [Tango-L] Changes of direction

2008-07-04 Thread Jack Dylan
I suppose it's just convention that has caused the figures described as 'Changes of Direction' to include a pivot. As Iron Logic says, without the pivot they become rock steps which are OK but are beginner figures, whereas I consider  'Changes of Direction' to be more of an advanced figure. Fo

Re: [Tango-L] Changes of direction

2008-07-04 Thread Jack Dylan
'Changes of Direction' change the direction of the turn in a Giro. Since the Giro consists of only 3 steps - side, forward and back and we have only 2 feet, I don't see how there can be more than 6. But I'm willing to be proved wrong if Chris can give us another example. Jack - Original M

Re: [Tango-L] What the heck is a Right foot front cross step?

2008-07-05 Thread Jack Dylan
The great thing about Naveira's terminology is that the lady's step is determined by her position relative to the man. For example; if the lady steps LF backward on the man's right side, this would be a LF back cross. This means, for example, that the man could lead her directly into a Back Oc

Re: [Tango-L] What the heck is a Right foot front cross step?

2008-07-05 Thread Jack Dylan
Astrid, These concepts are only of any value to the man, as leader; they have no relevance to the lady, as follower. So don't worry your pretty little head about it :-)) Jack - Original Message > From: Astrid <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > > I did not follow the thread as I hate reading these mi

Re: [Tango-L] Changes of direction

2008-07-10 Thread Jack Dylan
David, A Change of Direction, as the term now seems to be commonly used, includes a change in the direction of a Giro. A LF Front Cross is part of a Giro to Left [CCW]. If you the lead the lady to a RF Back [Open] Step this is still part of a Giro to Left as is shown by the fact that the lad

Re: [Tango-L] So what is an OPEN mean?

2008-07-10 Thread Jack Dylan
Larry,   I assume you mean the difference between an 'open step' and 'crossed step''.   OK, I'll do my best.   Have a girl stand facing you, feet together, and then have her turn 90deg left so that you're on her right side. If she now steps LF back, this would be a LF Back Cross. >From your per

Re: [Tango-L] Traspie

2008-07-12 Thread Jack Dylan
Mario, Well, I thought I knew what a traspie is but all I see at 1.03 is a lurch forward and at 1.12 a lurch backvward - definitely not to be recommended in a milonga. Are you being serious Mario, or is this an inside-joke that I haven't been around long enough to 'get'. Maybe we need more word

Re: [Tango-L] Traspie

2008-07-12 Thread Jack Dylan
Mario, I'm sure you're doing a great Traspie - as you say ..."why so difficult?". 3 short steps in 2 beats of music. Well, my friend, the difficult part is leading the lady to do an equally great Traspie. I see lots of guys doing 'great' Traspie while the lady is just shuffling her feet and

Re: [Tango-L] "Would you like to lead or follow?"

2008-07-19 Thread Jack Dylan
- Original Message > From: Mario [EMAIL PROTECTED]  I did a couple more lines in my best Christopher Walken voice (whenever I > feel vulnerable, I go to Chris) and then we danced. Is that also because Christopher Walken started his show-biz career as a dancer? ___

Re: [Tango-L] "Would you like to lead or follow?"

2008-07-19 Thread Jack Dylan
I was planning to reply to Martin but Ron and Sergio have said it all much better than I could. And thanks to Nina for giving a lady's view. To me, Tango is a dance between a man and a woman. Part of the man's role is to lead and part of the woman's role is to follow. But there's more to the man

Re: [Tango-L] Gender roles in tango

2008-07-20 Thread Jack Dylan
Mel, A fabulous dance by a couple obviously trained in ballet. But I'd be interested to hear just why you think they are dancing 'tango'. Seriously, Jack - Original Message > From: "[EMAIL PROTECTED]" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > > I searched on YouTube and found a good example of two men danc

Re: [Tango-L] How do yoou know it is tango

2008-07-21 Thread Jack Dylan
Pupi Castello was correct and I think everyone who learns tango discovers this for himself. Which I suspect is why many people enjoy Nuevo. No need to worry about that pesky walk :-) Jack - Original Message > From: "[EMAIL PROTECTED]" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > > Which reminds of what fa

Re: [Tango-L] The Brothers Macana

2008-07-21 Thread Jack Dylan
Thank you Deby; that is indeed very interesting. I always had the impression that the brothers were dancing a caricature of tango  and, from their name, it now seems that that is their intention. It's unfortunate that others, such as Miguel y Augusto, appear to be so deadly serious while dancing

Re: [Tango-L] The real, true, AUTHENTIC Argentine tango

2008-07-21 Thread Jack Dylan
Larry, I think you need to lighten up. I haven't been writing here for long but I was reading previously and I don't thing things are not as bad as you make out. The only people who refer to real, authentic tango seem to be those who say tango should be danced as the Argentines dance it. Pretty

Re: [Tango-L] World stage tango championship in B.A.

2008-07-22 Thread Jack Dylan
Sergio, Yes, a fabulous tango. But is that what tango is to you - steps and figures? Two men could dance exactly the same routine, Maybe, technically, equally as well. But, to me anyway, it would look and, more importantly, feel like a completely different dance. Don't we talk a lot about the fe

Re: [Tango-L] The language of Tango

2008-07-23 Thread Jack Dylan
Larry, As others have said - nice post; I also like the 'tango is a house of many rooms' analogy. The people who built this house, and their successors, the current guardians, are wonderful, generous people and they allow me to use the house whenever I want. They even allow me to take it to oth

Re: [Tango-L] Gratuitous insults and "social" tango

2008-07-24 Thread Jack Dylan
It certainly wasn't my intention to insult Nuevo dancers. I like to dance some Nuevo elements and I enjoy watching good Nuevo dancers. My point was that, in my opinion, the walk is less important to Nuevo dancers than to those who dance Salon or even Milonguero style. It appears that Nuevo is mor

Re: [Tango-L] Nuevo Figures

2008-07-24 Thread Jack Dylan
David, You disagree but then immediately prove my point by describing 2 such Nuevo figures. A Salon or Milonguero dancer might have no such figures to describe. Even Ochos an Giros are just walking steps divided by pivots. Btw, I never said Nuevo figures were not led. I assume they are. But they

Re: [Tango-L] Nuevo lead and follow and repressed teaching

2008-07-27 Thread Jack Dylan
Trini, Very true. When a lady is tipped into a Vocada, she needs to be able to keep her body straight so that only a horizontal force is exerted against the man. The man can then support this with his body weight and no strength is required. [The typical Gavito Lean]. Some ladies sag into the ma

Re: [Tango-L] Nuevo lead and follow and repressed teaching

2008-07-27 Thread Jack Dylan
Oh yeah, I recognise that. I know some intermediate guys that teach their own partner and they actually look quite good together. The problem comes when the girl tries to dance with somebody else and she has no idea what  the man wants her to do because she can't recognise a 'familiar pattern'.

Re: [Tango-L] Nuevo lead and follow and repressed teaching

2008-07-28 Thread Jack Dylan
Trini,   I know exactly what you're talking about and maybe I'm too cynical but I don't think the guys who dance with women who don't take classes are looking for feedback on their tango. I suspect their motives lie elsewhere. o_O If a man is really interested in tango, he's going to dance with w

Re: [Tango-L] new video

2008-07-29 Thread Jack Dylan
It was a very nice dance by Andreas and Anne-Cécile. Very nice. But I like my Tangos, Milongas and Vals' to be very different dances. Milonga is fun, playful and cheeky while Vals is elegant, sweeping, flowing and romantic. As Tete put it - "when I Vals, I want to fly". But, nonetheless, Andreas

Re: [Tango-L] Dividing Tango

2008-07-30 Thread Jack Dylan
Hmmm, this might be true in principle, but in my experience, every woman who dances wants to look beautiful. I don't think they'd agree that ... "It doesn't really matter what the dance looks like,"   And isn't it part of the man's job to help his partner look beautiful as well as feel beautiful

Re: [Tango-L] Dividing Tango

2008-07-31 Thread Jack Dylan
David, Very well said. I often strike a little pose with my partners, especially at the end of the dance, or maybe even during a dance. But it's got absolutely nothing to do with ... "showing off to an audience." I just do it to have little fun with my partner. But, from the tone of many of

Re: [Tango-L] No need to take sides

2008-07-31 Thread Jack Dylan
I disagree with most of what Lois Donnay wrote in her latest message and was planning a response until I saw that Sergio had already replied and said most of what I was also going to say. I quite often assist my teacher in her classes and my experience is that most beginner students are happier

Re: [Tango-L] The Volcada

2008-07-31 Thread Jack Dylan
Man, I'm glad I'm not a teacher trying to explain a figure on this list. Not with critics like Larry around and just waiting to pounce. Personally, I thought JPS did a good job in explaining the most common and popular form of Volcada and  I've little doubt that he explains it and its different

Re: [Tango-L] The Volcada

2008-07-31 Thread Jack Dylan
Astrid, It's the Gavito Lean. Some call it a Carpa or tent, others call it a Puente or bridge, Jack - Original Message > From: Astrid <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > >  > I had no idea that there was any such move as a "tent" in tango. You > mean tent as in the woman being the canvas and the c

Re: [Tango-L] Open/crossed step uses?

2008-08-03 Thread Jack Dylan
Larry, Sacadas are another good example of the usefulness of the open/cross system understanding. Walking outside partner on the right or left sides, I can always do a Sacada on the lady's trailing leg. But the Sacadas and their results will be very different depending on whether mine or my part

Re: [Tango-L] How to lead volcadas

2008-08-03 Thread Jack Dylan
Larry, I also first learned a basic Volcada as you describe it, i.e. as a simple forward lean. The problem is that times have changed and, largely because of Nuevo terminology, few people call that a Volcada anymore. As mentioned in another post, that figure is now called a Carpa [tent] or Pu

Re: [Tango-L] Social Tango

2008-08-08 Thread Jack Dylan
Joe, I admire you, but from my own experience, I think you're unusual. Most people, after they've been dancing for a few years, develop a 'preferred style'. Of course there will always be exceptions such as changing style for a performance or dancing with a partner who has a fondness for Nuevo

Re: [Tango-L] How to lead volcadas

2008-08-08 Thread Jack Dylan
Chris, I completely agree with you and no one has ever said that ... "one particular predefined sequence is the only thing that is called volcada". I don't know where you got that idea. Just check YouTube and you'll find countless variations of Volcadas. It's my view that tango is a fast-evolving

Re: [Tango-L] Boleos - back and front

2008-08-08 Thread Jack Dylan
- Original Message > From: David Thorn <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > > First few seconds.  Liz is lead to spiral at the waist, her leg does float > behind and then wraps around front, and then > she is lead to settle onto her left foot.    A front boleo???  A front > ocho???  > Simply a cross

Re: [Tango-L] What does it take?

2008-08-18 Thread Jack Dylan
Mario, Don't make the mistake of trying to model your dance on someone else. Ricardo Vidort and the other milongueros come from a bygone age. Yes, let's marvel at their dancing but, when a milonguero dies, his dance dies with him and that's the way it has to be. What you need to do is find yo

Re: [Tango-L] Tangozone (was dull, dull, dull)

2008-08-27 Thread Jack Dylan
Ilene, That's OK for you ladies but, as a man, I'm way too busy taking care of my partner and navigating the crowded floor, not to mention trying to be seductive and creative, to even think about the 'tangozone' for myself. I'd like to ask the other guys out there, is it even possible for the m

Re: [Tango-L] dull, dull, dull

2008-08-29 Thread Jack Dylan
Mario, I'm assuming you wrote this post just to get people talking. OK, I'll bite. I don't enjoy classes and I don't enjoy practicing. But I do both so that my dancing skills and technique will improve and I can better enjoy the milongas. I hope the day will come when I need never attend anoth

Re: [Tango-L] dull, dull, dull (Mario)

2008-08-29 Thread Jack Dylan
Caroline,   I can certainly sympathise - a year of nothing but classes and practicas must have been terrible and would be enough to destroy almost anyone's love of tango. I'm just surprised that your teacher and others in your class didn't encourage you to attend milongas. Hereabouts, most peopl

Re: [Tango-L] Partner rotation technique

2008-09-03 Thread Jack Dylan
What my own teacher does if he he thinks there's going to be a gender imbalance in one of his classes is to phone up a few of his regular students to ask them to come along to act as dance partners. No charge of course. I always agree because I get a free refresher class and I get to meet the f

Re: [Tango-L] Labor Day Festival: a complaint

2008-09-05 Thread Jack Dylan
I also dislike this 30 seconds of chit-chat on the dance floor. Just what is its purpose? Someone told me it was so that the dancers could hear the music before starting to dance but, IMO, that just doesn't ring true.. Firstly, they're chatting, not listening and, secondly, the 5 seconds to make

Re: [Tango-L] Volcada (instructional video)

2008-09-11 Thread Jack Dylan
Trini, You asked a good question that, IMO, Jean-Pierre didn't really answer. I think he is doing what I often do and is treating the Carpa and the Volcada as 2 separate figures, with the Carpa being a prelude to the Volcada.. However, as has been correctly pointed out by Larry and others, the

Re: [Tango-L] How to initiate lean

2008-09-13 Thread Jack Dylan
Igor, I'm prepared to believe that it's possible to lead the lady into a Carpa or to Apilado without using suspension and that's one reason why I posted. But, as I need to make a backward step to initiate the lean, you haven't explained why the lady won't make a corresponding forward step. I k

Re: [Tango-L] How to initiate lean

2008-09-16 Thread Jack Dylan
- Original Message > From: Igor Polk <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > After she steps forward, then there is time when she brings the back leg to > the "collect" position. At this time you move faster and initiate the lean. > Once she feels the lean, she will not be able to move to the next step. >

Re: [Tango-L] Lead an invitation that can be ignored or faught

2008-09-18 Thread Jack Dylan
I agree with Sergio that it sounds like a joke. I've always understood and been taught that tango is all about 'lead and follow', as is every other partner dance. Surely, leading is the man's major responsibility in tango. How can the lady ignore or fight his lead unless, of course, she doesn't

Re: [Tango-L] Tango Milonguero - Eduardo El Nene Masci

2008-09-18 Thread Jack Dylan
Is this Tango Liso? I always thought tango liso was a very smooth, simple dance  with few steps and figures. But this video includes some fancy footwork, sacadas, high front and back boleos and a even a planeo. Jack - Original Message > From: Mario <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > > Eduardo

Re: [Tango-L] front ochos or crosses in close embrace?

2008-09-28 Thread Jack Dylan
I agree. Contra-body torsion is extremely important in tango and requires a flexible spine. One of my favourite warm-up exercises is to stand backing a wall, a short distance away. With hands up, palms out and without moving the feet, twist as much as you can to place your palms on the wall.

Re: [Tango-L] Tergiversar = to distort, twist

2008-09-28 Thread Jack Dylan
David,   Nice find! Thank goodness we now have a voice that people might listen to :-)   Or maybe not. Who wants to be the first to tell us that Gavito got it wrong?   Jack - Original Message > From: David <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > > PS: Who made this quote? > > "I lead every thing. Every

Re: [Tango-L] Lead an invitation that can be ignored or faught

2008-09-28 Thread Jack Dylan
Wow, some of you guys are tough. It seems that Sean will not only not dance with women who are not good dancers but with women who agree to dance with men who are not good dancers. It makes me feel a little sorry for the nice ladies who agree to dance with me :-). Does it mean they will miss ou

Re: [Tango-L] Gavito's Lead & Plan B

2008-09-29 Thread Jack Dylan
This is very frustrating because many people are still talking at cross purposes. As many have already said, misunderstanding a lead and doing something unintended is a totally different thing to deliberately refusing a lead for no other reason than the lady wanting to do something other than w

Re: [Tango-L] front ochos or crosses in close embrace?

2008-10-03 Thread Jack Dylan
I'm always looking for ways to improve my Front Ochos in close embrace and finally found some time to read Eero Olli's lengthy post. While I appreciate his effort, I quickly got lost. If anyone else understand's what he is trying to say, could they please enlighten me. I got lost here ... "the

Re: [Tango-L] Lead and follow

2008-10-08 Thread Jack Dylan
Sergio Vandekier wrote: > > The woman should be instructed to do nothing unless she gets a clear lead > from > the man. > This is extremely important, especially in classes. All the time I see ladies in class doing the steps themselves and then later, these same ladies complain that their

Re: [Tango-L] Lead and follow

2008-10-11 Thread Jack Dylan
I'm still open to the idea, but I'm not convinced about any big improvement that the man will make by learning to dance the woman's role. Yes, of course the man must understand the woman's role and must know all her steps and pivots that he is going to lead but, IMHO, I don't think that require

Re: [Tango-L] Mario, Malina Detlef milonga clip

2008-10-15 Thread Jack Dylan
What I really dislike about the milonga video is Melina's left arm position.. That looks really uncomfortable for Detlef. In the second dance on the video her arm is back to a more-normal over the shoulder position. Jack - Original Message > From: "Nussbaum, Martin" [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Re: [Tango-L] What to do when the floor is tight

2008-10-18 Thread Jack Dylan
> From: Tango Society of Central Illinois <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > For the crowded floor: > > - Hold your partner close. > - Take small steps. > - etec, etc > Since Larry has had 20, or is it 30, years experience of Tango, I would assume he already knows these simple rules and is looking to be mor

[Tango-L] Milongueando 2009

2008-10-25 Thread Jack Dylan
Does anyone know anything about Milongueando 2009? It's quite expensive but is it worth attending since I could be in BsAs at that time? Their website says it's the 3rd International Encuentro of Tango Milonguero in Buenos Aires. Did anyone attend either of the first two? Their website is at:  

Re: [Tango-L] From: Mario Re: Firpo

2008-11-05 Thread Jack Dylan
I've also taken classes with Jorge Firpo and, while he's very good and a lot of fun, it's a huge stretch to classify him as 'a great dancer and teacher'. For my taste, he over-emphasises the importance of embellishments for both man and lady. I prefer to keep things more simple and elegant. But

Re: [Tango-L] What's going on here?

2008-11-08 Thread Jack Dylan
What's the big deal here and why even post this question? It's just a group of people enjoying their Tango; no more, no less. OK, they're not experts, but so what? Mario, I've noticed this tendency in you before. You show all the signs of becoming a first-class Tango snob. Jack > From: Mario

Re: [Tango-L] Milonga Codes and weird anecdotes

2008-11-11 Thread Jack Dylan
Melina, Thanks for the common-sense advice on how to behave in the milongas - at least, you would think it is common sense :-). And thanks for your anecdotes of milongas in the USA. Yes, I believe you. My partner and I have lived long, full lives both in the world of dance and in business. One

Re: [Tango-L] Dörte Ricklefsen y Ramiro Gigliotti

2008-11-12 Thread Jack Dylan
Mostly, yes but the figure from 2.10 to 2.20 was hardly Salon Tango, IMHO. I'd say that figure was Nuevo. But I agree; very nice demonstration of Tango in open-embrace. Jack > From: Trini y Sean (PATangoS) <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > > Mario, that was salon tango.  No nuevo.  > _

Re: [Tango-L] Tango Styles

2008-11-13 Thread Jack Dylan
Sergio, I certainly bow to your superior knowledge of Tango. But! I didn't mention this in my previous post but Dörte Ricklefsen y Ramiro Gigliotti do a 'change of direction' at 0.23 of the original video and they also do one at 1.07 of the second video you posted. I wasn't really sure if this

Re: [Tango-L] Will the REAL lead please stand?

2008-11-15 Thread Jack Dylan
Sorry Mario, but I see no sign at all that the lady [much better word than 'follow', ugh!] takes over the lady. 1.05? Mario, perhaps you've never seen a lady walk forwards before. Not that common, especially in crowded milongas, but not unusual either. Jack - Original Message > From

Re: [Tango-L] The closest-to-perfect tango couple

2008-11-19 Thread Jack Dylan
I love the exuberence of youth as displayed by Pablo Rodriguez & Noelia Hurtado. But for other extreme you need go no further than Mario's previous YouTube video of Javier Rodriguez and Andrea Misse. Elegance personified. Jack > From: "[EMAIL PROTECTED]" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > > I wonder. 

Re: [Tango-L] under-turned and over-turned ochos

2008-11-22 Thread Jack Dylan
Larry, You often amaze me with your posts and now I don't know whether you're playing with us or not. Just who were these "three dozen teachers" who could teach Ochos and fail to mention that the amount of turn can vary? Sorry, but it just beggars belief. OK, overturned Ochos can wait, but, IMH

Re: [Tango-L] Where does the lead leave off and the follow begin??

2008-11-23 Thread Jack Dylan
> From: Martin Waxman <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > > The lead leaves off after the mark; the follow begins when the lead > is interpreted/understood. > I don't fully understand Martin's answer because he uses the words 'mark' and 'lead' in the same sentence and I don't know whether he uses them with

Re: [Tango-L] How tango evolves

2008-11-24 Thread Jack Dylan
OK, I'm confused. > From: Nina Pesochinsky <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > > Vince is right.  Those are the big changes and they result in the  > changes in tango. > Vince and Nina agree - except that I get the impression that the factors listed by Vince as causes for change are approved of by Vince bu

Re: [Tango-L] Tango Pedantics

2008-11-25 Thread Jack Dylan
Thanks Charles: > From: "[EMAIL PROTECTED]" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > > Actually the tango de salon that is danced today is pretty much the same as > it was then anyway.  Tango de salon never went away nor really changed that > much, if at all. > And Ron: > From: Tango Society of Central Illi

Re: [Tango-L] How tango evolves

2008-11-25 Thread Jack Dylan
Barbara, I'd like to agree with you but, if the couples haven't been to Argentina, how can they actually KNOW what real tango is? I'm sure you do know couples who dance traditional tango beautifully without visiting Argentina but I suspect it's because they like you and they like the way you da

Re: [Tango-L] How tango evolves

2008-11-26 Thread Jack Dylan
Trini, Thank you, thank you - absolutely magnificent! And did you notice how almost all the YouTube comments were in Spanish? I saw Miguel Zotto in BsAs a few years ago. The audience, mostly Argentine, went crazy. Miguel is a true tango icon. Jack > From: Trini y Sean (PATangoS) <[EMAIL PROT

Re: [Tango-L] Good Fun, Excellent Dancing

2008-11-27 Thread Jack Dylan
I took classes with Eduardo Capussi and Mariana Flores back in 2000 [approx]. It was solid, traditional tango with lots of walking and simple figures - and it wasn't a beginner class. In 1995/96 my first teacher was Pablo Inza, who is now one of the leading Nuevo dancers, But, back then he was a

Re: [Tango-L] How tango evolves

2008-11-28 Thread Jack Dylan
> From: "[EMAIL PROTECTED]" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > > http://www.youtube..com/watch?v=a-5Bxtck3Uw > >  This, incidentally, is > Chicho in 2003, during the two years on which he visited L.A. a half > dozen times and during which I took several lessons from him.  He went > to milongas about a doze

Re: [Tango-L] Tango Pedantics

2008-12-03 Thread Jack Dylan
> From: Joe Grohens <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > > Mingo said that the clip was showing, not how Petroleo danced, but how  > they used to dance in the old days, _before_ the developments (read  > improvements) that Petroleo and his cohort brought into the tango.  > Petroleo was demonstrating this prim

Re: [Tango-L] Tango music files..? anyone?

2008-12-05 Thread Jack Dylan
Thanks for this. I must admit I'm a total duffer when it comes to computers but even I managed to download the '70 Most Danced Tangos' Is this legal? I mean, I've spent a small fortune buying CDs on-line and now I get 70 great tracks for free. Just doesn't seem right. Jack - Original Mess

Re: [Tango-L] obsession with nuevo - a remedy?

2008-12-06 Thread Jack Dylan
Larry, I've had at least 2 instructors teach me the 'butt kick', both times for Milonga. One of them even included a lady's 'butt kick' in response to the man's. Jack > From: "[EMAIL PROTECTED]" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > > You'll also see some movements that no one today has copied, even nuevo

Re: [Tango-L] the truth about the audience. Amaury de Siqueira

2008-12-10 Thread Jack Dylan
The original question from Larry was: "Why does the Argentine tango spawn such passionate controversies?" If Amaury's answer is correct and that the controversies reveal more about the participants than about the dance, does that mean the question can be re-phrased to: "Why does the Argentine

Re: [Tango-L] Close Embrace in ?

2008-12-10 Thread Jack Dylan
Mario, Yes, the lady's left breast between your two is the position for the "V" embrace and this is by far the most popular embrace used in the milongas of Buenos Aires. But there are a growing number of teachers, who often promote their classes as 'Milonguero Style', who teach a different em

Re: [Tango-L] There is nothing nuevo under the sun.

2008-12-10 Thread Jack Dylan
Jay, I guess my answer would be ... "well, it LOOKS like a Tango" But I think I'd reserve judgement until I heard the music. And isn't the same true of most other dances? Is a Waltz really a Waltz if the music is not Waltz? I don't think so. In Ballroom dancing they have a catch-all name f

Re: [Tango-L] Close Embrace in ?

2008-12-10 Thread Jack Dylan
The lady has a choice of 3 positions. In my personal order of preference: 1. She can look straight ahead, i.e facing or touching the right side of the man's head or face; 2. Head turned slightly left looking over the man's right shoulder; or 3. Head turned slightly right. Many ladies use a diffe

Re: [Tango-L] Your milonga secrets

2008-12-16 Thread Jack Dylan
Here's the best video I've seen on how to dance some nice Milonga. http://hk.youtube.com/watch?v=VRQ1T5zKTJ4 Jack From: "larry...@juno.com" larry...@juno.com Looking back over the last couple dozen threads I see almost no mention of milongas. Do you do them? Any secrets of how to do them, and

Re: [Tango-L] Your milonga secrets

2008-12-18 Thread Jack Dylan
Trini and Jay, Sorry, but I just don't get this. When dancing Milonga in particular, because of the quicker tempo and shorter reaction time for my partner, I dance in very close embrace with the best connection I can muster. So if I'm dancing to what I 'hear' in the music, I lead my partner to

Re: [Tango-L] Your milonga secrets

2008-12-21 Thread Jack Dylan
Norm, Since you obviously think it''s important, could you provide us with an explanation, preferably with examples, of what you mean by a 'syncopated rhythm' in milonga? Cheers, Jack > From: Norman Tiber nati...@charter.net > Understanding the difference between “double time” and  > “sync

Re: [Tango-L] Very smooth tango= foxtrot, Klaus

2009-02-04 Thread Jack Dylan
C'mon, Martin, you've gone from a very ordinary, intermediate nobody, like many of us I suspect, to one of the world's greatest exponents of Tango. Not really a fair comparison. But, you're right, Klaus should be aiming a lot, lot higher. Jack - Original Message > From: "Nussbaum, M

Re: [Tango-L] Pity the poor Milonguru

2009-02-06 Thread Jack Dylan
I was sitting in Nino Bien the other night, opposite my partner as we sipped our Chandon, probaby looking like a couple of newbie tourists. I've been before but not for a couple of years. Anyway, an old guy walked behind my partner, put his hand on one of her bare shoulders and stroked her neck

Re: [Tango-L] chicho - sorry

2009-02-10 Thread Jack Dylan
I've been trying to stay away from Ballroom discussions but, c'mon Damian! I've studied Ballroom in the UK with the world's greatest dancers and teachers, including my personal favourite - John Wood. NOT ONE EVER mentioned a chest lead. If they used another term that you're interpreting as a 'c

Re: [Tango-L] improving discussion in our forum -- sugestions

2009-02-12 Thread Jack Dylan
Certainly not from Buenos Aires! I'm currently taking classes with Susanna Miller in Mlongueando 2009. Almost her first statement was that "the idea that milongueros lead from the chest is a myth - they use their hands and arms". For the last 2 days, after years of leading from the chest, I

Re: [Tango-L] lead with arms

2009-02-12 Thread Jack Dylan
Igor, It wasn't Back Ochos in general but a particular Back Ocho. Susana Mller was assisted in the class by a milonguero who has danced for more than 70 years and is well known for this Back Ocho. Sorry, but I didn't catch his name but I've seen him many times in the milongas, despite him being

Re: [Tango-L] Shocked

2009-02-24 Thread Jack Dylan
A 'discussion' implies people offering different views. So far everyone has agreed that teaching in a milonga is a big no-no. So, where's the discussion, other than confirming what we all already know. I really don't understand why Klaus wasted his time in writing such a silly post and wasted o

Re: [Tango-L] Cabeceo [was "Shocked"]

2009-02-24 Thread Jack Dylan
This might come as a surprise to many but not everyone in enamored with the cabeceo. My partner danced Ballroom for many years, where the tradition is that the man comes to her table and politely asks her  for the pleasure of the next dance. And, if he has a little charming chat, then so much th

Re: [Tango-L] Shocked

2009-02-26 Thread Jack Dylan
I think Jay is going to have to explain a lot more about the form of teaching in a milonga that he thinks is acceptable. IMO, it's not just about disrupting the other dancers; its also about the fact that most ladies truly hate it. I also consider it disrespectful to the lady - unless she actua

Re: [Tango-L] Shocked

2009-02-26 Thread Jack Dylan
I agree with Trini. My response would probably have been "don't worry about it; let's just try again."  Later, when leading the cross again, I would make the lead very clear so that I'm sure she'd follow correctly.. Then I could say something like ... "OK, no problem". This kind of thing h

Re: [Tango-L] How wide is the base of "The Lead Pyramid"?

2009-02-26 Thread Jack Dylan
I think 'Rebound' is the modern terminology and 'Rock-step' is the older terminology. Also called an 'Amague' or 'fake'. Jack > From: NANCY > > > What is a check step in tango?  > > ___ Tango-L mailing list Tango-L@mit.edu http://mai

Re: [Tango-L] dark milongas

2009-03-01 Thread Jack Dylan
At El Beso milongas they change the lighting to change the mood. They have maximum lighting for the cabaceo between tandas, dim slightly for the dancing and then it dims right down at the end of the tanda to allow for a nice romantic ending. It then goes up again to allow people to leave the fl

Re: [Tango-L] musings

2009-03-11 Thread Jack Dylan
Mario, You might be interested to know that I saw Alberto Dassieu recently at a milonga in Buenos Aires. Strangely, it was on a very quiet night at El Beso, which is mostly frequented by tourists and I guess he was there to escort a Japanese couple who appeared to be his students. Alberto rar

Re: [Tango-L] Any Nuevo Milongas?

2009-04-08 Thread Jack Dylan
This brings up an interesting subject that I'm not sure has been discussed before. Is there any such thing as a 'Nuevo Milonga'? As Vince points out, everyone treats Practica X as a milonga, but the organisers call it a practica and that's how it's listed in El Tangauta and B.A. Tango. Similar

Re: [Tango-L] Nuevo Milonga: An Oxymoron

2009-04-09 Thread Jack Dylan
Thanks Ron, I agree - 100%. But not sure if others, outside of Argentina, will agree. Jack - Original Message > From: Tango Society of Central Illinois > > The term 'Nuevo Milonga' is an oxymoron. > ___ Tango-L mailing list

Re: [Tango-L] The Truth About Tango Nuevo

2009-04-11 Thread Jack Dylan
I don't actually agree with that. I think Argentine Tango belongs to the Argentines. Anyone is free to dance it but you should respect the fact that it's not yours. What right do you have to change it and continue to call it Argentine Tango? Jack > From: David Thorn > > If you would like

Re: [Tango-L] Report from Buenos Aires #2

2009-04-13 Thread Jack Dylan
Michael, Thanks for the reports - very accurate from my experiences and very useful for first-time visitors to BsAs. But I don't agree with your term 'original style' because, as Trini has already pointed out, we don't really know what that is and it would result in a lot of disagreements.

Re: [Tango-L] genre bendre

2009-04-13 Thread Jack Dylan
The first thing they are is professional dancers. My very first Tango lessons, in the mid-90s, were with Pablo Inza [with his then-wife, Gladys Fernandez] when they were already travelling the world as tango teachers. Back then Pablo was super-traditional and conservative with short slicked-ba

Re: [Tango-L] Where in BsAs do the nuevos hang out?

2009-04-14 Thread Jack Dylan
> From: "larry...@juno.com" > > Maybe those of you who have a lot of experience in the Buenos Aires > tango scene can tell us - where do "tango nuevo" dancers usually go > to dance? > Practica X, Tango Cool, El Motivo and La Viruta. Larry, enjoy yourself. I hope you're fast on your feet to ta

Re: [Tango-L] ..1 1/2 yrs of watching YouTube

2009-04-15 Thread Jack Dylan
I agree with Mario. If I'm going to do a linear walk to the cross, I'll ALWAYS do it in crossed feet. It's just much more comfortable and keeps the lady closer. If I step outside right in parallel, it's because I intend to do something else before reaching the cross position. There are many o

Re: [Tango-L] ..1 1/2 yrs of watching YouTube

2009-04-16 Thread Jack Dylan
> From: Trini y Sean (PATangoS) patan...@yahoo.com >It's interesting that you noted the music as being important for > the milonguero.  That's one of the reasons cross system is used so much.  I'm surprised to hear you say that and I'm not sure if I really agree. As Mario noted: "6. All rhyt

Re: [Tango-L] Report from Buenos Aires #4: Before you dance

2009-04-17 Thread Jack Dylan
> From: Michael tangoman...@cavtel.net > C) Currency Exchange > Use Banco de Nacional Argentina at the airport and not kiosks. There > is no commission charge at the bank. If possible, get all the pesos > you´ll need. You´ll have to wait in line if you decide to do it in > town. In fact waiting i

  1   2   3   >