[Tango-L] El Lloron

2010-08-26 Thread Jack Dylan
Please forgive me if this is a dumb question, but I've received conflicting information. Is 'El Lloron' by Canaro/Fama a milonga or a tango? Thanks, Jack ___ Tango-L mailing list Tango-L@mit.edu http://mailman.mit.edu/mailman/listinfo/tango-l

[Tango-L] El lloron

2010-08-26 Thread Charles Roques
> Is 'El Lloron' by Canaro/Fama a milonga or a tango? It is considered a milonga. I have several versions including one by Firpo on a compilation entitled "Las Milongas mas Milongas" Some very early songs could sound like either until the distinct songs types coalesced into the forms we now r

Re: [Tango-L] El Lloron

2010-08-26 Thread Peter Turowski
> Is 'El Lloron' by Canaro/Fama a milonga or a tango? It's up to the dancers - some take it as a tangomilonga with 80 BPM, some rock the dancefloor with double speed. Some even interpret it as a candombe, but I didn't see a tango interpretation yet. Regards Peter

Re: [Tango-L] El Lloron

2010-08-26 Thread Andy Ungureanu
The question is not dumb, because most djs play "El lloron" as a milonga. The score is written as "Tango" and not even as "Tango Milonga". The structure of the bass line is "long-short-short" that is close but different than the milonga rhythm which is "longer-very short-short-short". The mel

Re: [Tango-L] El Lloron

2010-08-26 Thread Charles Roques
Jack, Andy wrote: This just points out that a few songs are open to interpretation so you just have to wing it and dance as you feel the response, or as the DJ does. D'Agostino plays El Portenito as a milonga but few others do. Some of the earliest tango songs were little of both milonga an