Re: [TCP] Is technical writing worth the hype and pain?

2009-12-24 Thread Beth Agnew
No, I do not agree that it is a ridiculous and thankless job. Educate those around you as to your true competencies, which are plain language writing, procedural writing, clear and concise communication, liaison between developers and others in the company, user analysis, task analysis, usabili

Re: [TCP] Is technical writing worth the hype and pain?

2009-12-24 Thread Al Geist
Sorry to hear you're having such a hard time at your company Raj. I have been lucky in that with the exception of working for one of the auto companies in the late 1960s (shortly after graduating high school), I've always been treated as a valuable member of a team. I will admit that this is partly

Re: [TCP] Is technical writing worth the hype and pain?

2009-12-24 Thread Melissa Nelson
I have had times when I felt this way. But you know what, at those times I asked around and I was not the only feeling that way, even developers can feel that way at times too! Different projects, different PMs, different days of the week..can all lead one to feel a bit frustrated and undervalu

Re: [TCP] Is technical writing worth the hype and pain?

2009-12-24 Thread Bill Swallow
> At times, I wonder why technical writers are the least common denominators in > a software company. Only if you allow yourself to be. > For example, if I submit a document for review, people schedule it for the > last few hours of a business day. This amply explains the 'importance' given >

Re: [TCP] Is technical writing worth the hype and pain?

2009-12-24 Thread Jack DeLand
I wouldn't say it's "ridiculous and thankless", but it is just a fact of corporate life that some functions will be more highly valued. If I had only limited funds and could retain either a tech writer or an engineer, I would have to choose the engineer. We may tell people "how to make the pr

Re: [TCP] Is technical writing worth the hype and pain?

2009-12-24 Thread Jason A. Czekalski
Raj, No, you are not alone, and it is not just software companies. I have dealt with this same exact problem in the past. That being said, I agree with the rest of the group that basically said that how you get treated is up to you. In my case, I work in manufacturing, and have for over 35 year

Re: [TCP] Is technical writing worth the hype and pain?

2009-12-24 Thread Gene Kim-Eng
It can be if you let it, but so can any job. I have heard this same complaint from mechanical engineers working at mostly electronics companies, and from software engineers working at places where software is not the primary product. And imagine what life was like for auditors at mortgage compa

Re: [TCP] Is technical writing worth the hype and pain?

2009-12-24 Thread David Farbey
Yes Raj, things can be frustrating when you are a technical writer, but things can be equally frustrating in many other jobs. Other people have already replied to you and pointed out that individuals often don't realise how much control they can have over their careers, and that applies to tech

Re: [TCP] Is technical writing worth the hype and pain?

2009-12-24 Thread Dan Goldstein
There's no organization comparable to the AMA for tech writers because the two professions are totally dissimilar -- not only in people's subjective view of them, but also in their objective natures. > -Original Message- > From: Jack DeLand > Sent: Thursday, December 24, 2009 10:33 AM > To

Re: [TCP] Is technical writing worth the hype and pain?

2009-12-24 Thread Al Geist
David Farbey wrote: " But if you really think you are stuck in a "ridiculous and thankless job", then I would seriously suggest you find a different career where you may be happier. For example, I was a career-track civil servant in a Government department, and despite the job security and the p