CULTURAL QA 07202422 TOPIC- GENERAL- BASE QUORA QA- Compiled
Q1 Why do temples not give free meals to devotees like gurdwaras do? KR Being a young FOODY did not try to learn as the compiler who visited so many temples, also failed to provide a good answer. Basically, a temple provides only free food; anna dhanam (incidentally before reading this, how Kerala History depicts through the udayan Cheralathan King family having provided anna dhanam to Mahabharatha war time I had written) is the basic concept of India. WHAT IS PRSASADAM? GOD IS NOT GOING TO EAT; it is provided as anna dhanam to the people who may come around the noon or night before the closure of the temple. When the same is expanded according to the fund’s availability or regulations of the king or the constitutions, they become anna dhanam to 50000 per day. Gurudwara learnt it from the Hinduism and not the reverse. The TN by regulation provide food in all temples. Sai temple is the biggest food provider than TTD. Have you seen the drums erected there in Sai Temple of Nasik seeradi Maharashtra? Ramanatha swamy Rameswaram, Arunachala of Tiruvannamalai and Madurai Meenakshi temple serve food not at one or two times a day, but whenever you step into shall be provided. Isha , Sabari mala and Godmen and Mutt centres provide food all the time. Should I list more? ----------------------------------------------------------------------- Q2 What is a comical accident case in India? My note-Happa- Source is told. Otherwise my only critic Mr Rajaram with negative words would have asked for source and blame me for furnishing worng information in groups. I have never met in my life such a critic adding only negative response to this much extent on a person and furnishing rubbish addition mostly not related to the QA. I pity Mr Rajaram . A QA is intended only for answer to the point and not pages of data. Dear friends, I am forced to make the above note, after going through very bad reactions of Mr Rajaram on my recent QA postings. You may go through his responses. KR This has 2 definite deviations; is that funny? Comedy? The unintelligent Gopalakrishnan alone can think that way; also when writing something writing only the nonsense, he thinks as sense is not a sense of presentations; as his sense is senseless, that too in the late evening, when he writes Annadhanam is only in TTD, so too, 5 pieces cut and paste, somehow, Something, not only makes him a fool, but also his inability to cope with, make him abuse, as if others are fools. Now even in this news he speaks about vande Bharath 83 cases that too as a joke; but what is the reality? Now source BBC. Source for nonsense is needed; when he writes epics, science etc he has to provide; not for Sunil Gavaskar photo. Now the blatant news source he skipped in haste: Indian trains ran over more than 13,000 cattle in 2022 according to data released by the government. This is up 24% from 2019, when 10,609 cattle were hit by trains, according to numbers shared by nine of 17 railway zones in India with the BBC. Cattle deaths from train collisions isn't new in India, though the media's scrutiny of these deaths has increased over the past few years as the country launches newer trains. In 2019, a semi-high speed Vande Bharat Express train broke down just a day after it was flagged off by Prime Minister Narendra Modi. At the time, a railways spokesperson was quoted as saying that the train may have struck cattle on the line. Last October, Vande Bharat Express trains hit cattle three times in the western state of Gujarat, causing delays and damage. And last week, another flagship train in the series was damaged after it ran into cattle during a trial run ahead of its scheduled launch. And similar accidents do occur in Mumbai Chhatrapati airport eagles strikes while take off and landing. So many places are there. And they are not funny but childish reports. -------------------------------------------------------- Q3 How long did it take for Gutenberg's invention to spread across Europe? 3rd time in the year; what Gopala can do? he needs everyday 5 pieces cut and paste; and he does not have the aptitude to think also. He also thinks that he is a peacock dancing in the rain though a turkey only Sorry sir I am forced to hit him as he started the game. Was there not printing before Gutenberg? The history of printing starts as early as 3000 BCE, when the proto-Elamite and Sumerian civilizations used cylinder seals to certify documents written in clay tablets. Other early forms include block seals, hammered coinage, pottery imprints, and cloth printing. Initially a method of printing patterns on cloth such as silk, woodblock printing for texts on paper originated in China by the 7th century during the Tang dynasty, leading to the spread of book production and woodblock printing in other parts of Asia such as Korea and Japan. The Chinese Buddhist Diamond Sutra, printed by woodblock on 11 May 868, is the earliest known printed book with a precise publishing date. *Movable type* (even before Guten berg] was invented by Chinese artisan Bi Sheng in the 11th century during the Song dynasty, but it received limited use compared to woodblock printing. However, the use of copper movable types was documented in a Song-era book from 1193, and the earliest printed paper money using movable metal type to print the identifying codes were made in 1161. The technology also spread outside China, with the oldest extant printed book using metal movable type being the Jikji, printed in Korea in 1377 during the Goryeo era. Woodblock printing was also used in Europe until the mid-15th century. Late medieval German inventor Johannes Gutenberg created the first printing press based on previously known mechanical presses and a process for mass-producing metal type. By the end of the 15th century, his invention and widescale circulation of the Gutenberg Bible became responsible for a burgeoning economical book publishing industry across Renaissance Europe and eventually among the colonial publishers and printers that emerged in the British-American colonies. This industry enabled the communication of ideas and the sharing of knowledge on an unprecedented scale, leading to the global spread of the printing press during the early modern period. Alongside the development of text printing, new and lower-cost methods of image reproduction were developed, including lithography, screen printing and photocopying. So, this is not my new one and the same thing was provided in his earlier parts too. Yet Gopala do not develop knowhow at all.! ---------------------------------------------------------------- Q4 Can you name any politicians in India who have not been involved in corruption or bad politics? KR Gopalakrishnan gets wild; he copies north patriotism; who is Ayub khan? Pak president? Shall I account his history of corruption? 2 Sastri Good 3 Kamaraj was not there? Namboodirippadu? Kakkan? So many are there. But when you copy and paste, mind does not think well. Happy (huppa) in providing wrong sources for error prone resources. ------------------------------------------------------------------------- Q5 Why don't we demolish slums and tell the inhabitants to go back to their villages (India)? KR The subject is world wide sir; you’re basking under Quora may not incite you to learn more; al you have asked were answered already by the world thinkers. Have you read any of them? It is relevant for all; if you think otherwise, I don’t care for the fools. The world’s largest slums include Khayelitsha in Cape Town, South Africa (400,000 people); Kibera in Nairobi, Kenya (700,000); Dharavi in Mumbai, India (one million); Neza in Mexico (1.2 million); and Orangi Town in Karachi, Pakistan, which, with 2.4 million inhabitants, is the world’s largest slum. Despite the fact that many slums are as large as many cities that benefit from economies of scale, their inhabitants face a ‘poverty penalty’, paying more for basic services than those in richer areas. They remain exposed to hostile policy environments, social exclusion, climate change and inadequate public health systems. Only 20 per cent of Kibera has electricity and each latrine is shared by 50 shacks. Violence can be shocking: in Orangi Town, 77 per cent of women report having been raped. So how to create real change? It used to be thought that the best method of limiting *slums was to encourage people to stay in rural areas, but nowadays, most experts agree that incentivising people to remain in the countryside doesn’t work*. The pull factor is just too strong. People will come to the city whether or not there are services to meet their needs. If you try to forcibly block people from coming, evict them from slums, you just displace them to another part of the city. The only thing that it creates is bitterness and social division. Julian Baskin, Principal Urban Advisor, Cities Alliance ‘Urbanisation has often been viewed as a negative process characterised by arguments to keep people in rural areas,’ says Minna Örnéus, senior programme specialist at the SIDA’s Unit for Global Cooperation on Environment. ‘But this view is misplaced – not to mention having questionable implications for people’s freedom of movement. ‘Migrating to cities is attractive and, to some extent, reflects progress with development if it is managed the right way,’ she continues. ‘Look at Europe – we are really urbanised. People look for opportunities in cities that are lacking where they came from. Maybe they can’t support their whole family in a rural area. If you’re young, maybe you’re attracted by the urban lifestyle and promises of better-paid jobs.’ *One impact of creating a hostile environment for migrants to cities is that slums are perceived as a bolt-on*. This translates into a lack of access to urban amenities and social infrastructure, and the non-availability of community buildings, public spaces, sports facilities, schools, and health services. Housing will generally comprise poorly built, tightly packed concrete blocks. ‘Ten years ago, urbanisation was seen as a problem and symptomatic of a failure of rural development,’ says Julian Baskin, senior urban advisor at Cities Alliance, a UN agency. ‘This went as far as actively not investing in cities, in case it attracted people. But if you try to forcibly block people from coming, evict them from slums, you just displace them to another part of the city. The only thing it creates is bitterness and social division.’ Thinking has partly shifted because data built up over decades demonstrate a link between urbanisation and lower poverty rates. According to the UN Department of Economic and Social Affairs, urban areas account for 70 per cent of global GDP. ‘The evidence shows that no nation can become a middle-income country (MIC) without urbanisation,’ says Baskin. ‘The moment Ghana hit a threshold of 50 per cent of its population being urbanised, it was also designated a MIC.’ This does not, however, mean the rural economy should be overlooked or discouraged. ‘Urban and rural areas should not be polarised,’ Baskin argues. ‘They are mutually reinforcing. Good rural development depends on successful cities. The future lies in getting the cities right.’ Efforts to address this are increasingly reflected in a change in approach by policymakers: in the 21st century, slum upgrading programmes tend to be more encompassing and integrated, recognising the multi-faceted nature of poverty. Thinking has shifted to view slum communities as a vital part of the city and how it functions. Rather than being spatially excluded, they should be at the centre of city and national development. However, as a consequence, upgrading projects have become complex undertakings. Removing the stigma Mistry recalls working in Delhi’s slums during the early 2000s, where he was struck by how the urban poor succeeded in organising themselves to secure their right to food. ‘That focus on rights [of all kinds] still exists today and can only succeed with much greater interaction between communities of the urban poor and local government,’ he says. ‘There is still a need for transforming the stigma that has existed around slum dwellers.’ Providing slums with basic municipal services is a way towards formalising them, and also a significant step towards local governments realising that the urban poor have a fundamental right to live in decent conditions. Minna Örnéus, Senior Programme Specialist, Sida Concrete policy changes towards slums have been slow to emerge, but another factor that has helped shift perspectives is a growing realisation among governments those informal urban economies, especially in sub-Saharan Africa, make a significant contribution to economic development and the functioning of cities (and up to 80 per cent of certain national economies in the developing world). Slum communities should be at the centre of their city and national development,’ says a spokesperson for Muungano wa Wanavijiji, the Kenyan federation of slum dwellers (‘United Slum Dwellers’ in Kiswahili), a social movement of slum residents, urban poor, universities, civil society, the private sector and Nairobi’s county government. ‘Slum upgrading is possible, but only where communities themselves are at the centre of their development.’ Economic informality generates new employment in the developing world, even if there are downsides, such as high levels of under-employment, insecurity and low-income level. ‘Where this realisation exists, there is a bigger willingness to work with communities of the urban poor,’ says Örnéus, ‘to try to bring them into the formal system, which can support the proper functioning of a city through, for example, widening the tax base.’ West Point, informal settlement in Monrovia, Liberia Better planning, more rights Experts also recognise that the rationale for planning in slums must be turned on its head. Traditionally, planning in cities in the developing world was based on European models of identifying land, buying and then planning and servicing it before building houses, all of which can take years. ‘In developing cities, urbanisation happens at an infinitely faster rate,’ says Baskin. Mistry puts it a little more bluntly, pointing to ‘archaic’ urban planning regulations and systems ‘that were originally established in colonial times, mainly to serve the colonial bureaucracy, with the aim of controlling local populations and which now serve the ruling elites.’ Early attempts to improve slums concentrated on the provision of water, sanitation and drainage infrastructure. Today, the best planning is instead about giving people security of tenure, ensuring that inhabitants live away from danger zones, such as flood lines of rivers, or are set back from slopes and landslides (in development circles, the strategic use of targeted public interventions to trigger large-scale transformation is sometimes referred to as ‘urban acupuncture’). Baskin points to an example from Luanda, where poorer inhabitants of the capital, weren’t given rights to their homes and so invested what little money they earned in cars – because there was no incentive to improve where they lived. ‘Why to argue for better sanitation or security if you could be moved on the next day?’ he says. Making security of tenure work is possible but far from straightforward. In Uganda, local authorities in Mbale City recognised that existing conventional methods of land registration like surveying and titling were not flexible to the peculiar and complex context of rights in informal settlements and, perhaps more to the point, are unaffordable for the majority of slum dwellers. Instead, security of tenure was achieved through consultation – by participatory slum profiling (which simply means involving the local people in mapping out areas of action in their locality) and household enumerations (a field activity that creates a comprehensive list of all households within the cluster area). This work resulted in the development of two precinct neighbourhood plans and improved security for several slum dwellers who acquired tenure documents for their land rights. The scheme is now being rolled out in ten more municipalities across the country. But Baskin insists that ‘land tenure does not have to be complex. It can be as simple as giving guarantees that people will not be forcibly evicted from their land. That makes a huge difference to what people will invest in.’ Detailed mapping of settlements can make a psychological as well as a practical difference, as it gives a name and address to every person. This, in turn, stirs a sense of citizenship. Other innovations are being facilitated by technology and allow for the decentralisation of what would be huge infrastructure undertakings that might otherwise take years. These include ecological or biofuel toilets that can be used within a home and negate the need to build vast networks of sewers; and solar energy, which also negates the need for large electricity installations. Covid and slum improvements The pandemic has thrown an unforgiving light on the hardships of slums. In the West, millions of people were able to stay at home, subsidised by their governments. This wasn’t available to slum dwellers in the developing world. According to Cities Alliance, ‘slums were not immediately accessible and the scale of needs was unmanageable’. ‘The biggest challenge was the recognition of how short-term the informal economy is within slum areas,’ says Julian Baskin, senior urban advisor at Cities Alliance. ‘People were told to stay at home; police tried to lock down markets. But it became apparent just how quickly people would begin to starve. People work in the day to buy food for the same night. It wasn’t workable.’ The long-term response, he argues, must be to invest in urban agriculture, so that food can be stockpiled and distributed in such circumstances. According to the Swedish International Development Cooperation Agency, ‘much of the progress made in the fight against poverty over many years has been rolled back by the pandemic’, but spokesperson Mistry says adaptations to best meet the Covid-related needs of communities can still go hand in hand with improving conditions. ‘SIDA has worked through partners such as Slum Dwellers International and Cities Alliance to install hand-washing stations, disseminate masks and create local small-scale health units’, which both mitigate Covid pressures and improve services. Community cohesion Infrastructure is self-evidently important, but what really makes a difference, says Baskin, is community organisation, which has a greater capacity to kick-start improvements. ‘You need people who can represent the community, forums that invest in dialogue. Even if people are poor, things will happen. If you don’t have that, then criminal elements step into the void.’ Örnéus agrees, adding: ‘It’s not just about housing and infrastructure, it’s also about empowering the urban poor and building their capacity to engage and be aware of their rights. The participation of slum dwellers is the key to a successful slum-upgrading programme.’ Örnéus stresses the importance of gradual upgrading and contrasts this with policies prevalent during the 1980s under which whole slum areas would be forcibly removed, the land cleared and, in effect, ‘retro-fitted’ with infrastructure. ‘Although in some places, the situation has improved, people are still forcibly evicted every year and millions are threatened with forced evictions.’ Nevertheless, there are good examples of approaches that both involve slum residents and view slums as an integral part of the city. In Nairobi, a project overseen by Muungano wa Wanavijij puts the emphasis on inclusivity: slums have been compartmentalised into 1,000 groups, each comprising some 100 people. Each slum group is autonomous and seeks to galvanise community efforts to improve living conditions. This community-based approach was applied to Mukuru, a vast, sprawling 243-hectare informal settlement in Nairobi. Mukuru was declared a special planning area, with priority and funding given for projects that enabled the slum to be improved and integrated into the city’s fabric. A resident was chosen to represent each group of households and thousands of people were asked for their views; 250 community mobilisers were engaged to raise awareness of the project. Residents were trained to collect data. Every latrine, water tap and electricity pole in the settlement was mapped. Among the outcomes has been the replacement of 3,800 filthy pit latrines. Now, 1,000 households have access to flushing toilets and running water. Mukuru is also Kenya’s pioneering social-housing project as the government has approved the construction of 13,000 new houses there. Second cities Directing rural migrants to secondary cities is another way in which thinking has shifted in recent years. ‘The primary cities have born the huge brunt of urbanisation and there’s little capacity to expand land; you get backlogs, they’re precarious,’ says Baskin. ‘Across Africa, we are seeing a big strategic shift to secondary cities.’ One advantage is that migrants can move to a city nearer to their rural origins, where the language may be the same as in their village. Should they lose their job or times get hard, they can return home and use their social networks to avoid being sucked into debt far from home. The way the world is looking right now, urbanisation is taking place really rapidly, especially in developing countries. These countries are severely lacking the governance, capacity and resources to cope. Yet most donors still focus on the bigger cities as it can be more difficult to work with secondary cities and implement improvements. ‘The megacities – Rio, Bombay, Delhi and the like – have community organisations that are much more developed and co-ordinated, which makes it easier to change perceptions there,’ says Mistry. ‘Secondary cities are seeing the same problems [that emerged in the largest cities] but don’t have the same resources as the bigger cities to meet the needs of their swelling populations.’ While planners and grassroots agencies know what is likely to work, progress can be painfully slow. Self-evidently, income and funding make a difference in outcomes for slum upgrading. Cities in developing nations typically have barely a quarter of the resources of those in a developed nation. Per capita spending in most African cities is US$50 per household. In Europe, the figure is US$2,100. ‘It would be interesting to see the impact on a Western European city of a 75 per cent cut in funding,’ says Baskin. ‘Many cities [in developing nations] pay salaries that are not competitive. You have top management, no middle management and a huge number of unskilled workers. The informal economy is huge.’ Avoiding gentrification One potential consequence of slum upgrading is gentrification, the phenomenon seen across developed cities where a neglected area is improved to the extent that wealthier people move in and the original occupants are displaced. This was the risk facing Barrio 31 in Buenos Aires, a settlement situated downtown, close to affluent neighbourhoods. Between 2015 and 2019, the city provided 18 kilometres of basic infrastructure and services to the area, including sewers, drainage, water, public lighting and roads. It also renovated 26 public spaces, improved 1,700 housing units, constructed 1,200 new residences and provided three new public schools and three healthcare centres. The conditions were ripe for more affluent incomers to take advantage of these improvements. However, they’ve been kept at bay by a series of practical and legal measures. Land titles were given to residents with a subsidised 30-year mortgage. At 250 square metres, plot sizes are smaller than the minimum plot standard of the wider city and development rights were limited to the construction of properties with a maximum of three floors above ground level. In addition, new residents must pay three times the property tax. These measures also provided safeguards against slums slipping backwards because they prevented private landlords from buying up vacant land and then stimulating slum conditions by building unregulated structures for rent. Climate change Another challenge is that slum areas are often perilously located. However, if you can get this right, slum upgrading can help address issues around climate change while also implementing sustainable-development priorities. ‘Climate change is already having disproportionate impacts in slum areas,’ says Örnéus. ‘Slums are often located in hazard-prone areas, on steep-sided hills or along floodplains, making them already prone to floods and landslides. Their location only worsens their vulnerability to climate change impacts. This is why governments have to pay special attention to how to mitigate climate risks in slum areas when they develop their adaptation action plans.’ Even so, climate change is likely to provide a brake on progress in slum upgrading. ‘I hope we don’t always have slums,’ says Örnéus. ‘But the way the world is looking right now, urbanisation is taking place really rapidly, especially in developing countries. These countries are severely lacking the governance, capacity and resources to cope.’ Örnéus stresses the importance of not generalising about what works and what doesn’t because ‘every city is different and everyone moving to a city has a different reason for doing so.’ There’s a necessity, she argues, for policymakers to remain agile in their thinking and to avoid slipping into old tropes that drop-in solutions will work everywhere. Patience will be key, says Baskin, who’s optimistic that we’ll see meaningful, widespread change. ‘Incrementally, we will get improvements, more territorial interaction between urban and rural areas,’ he says. ‘The headwinds are going in the right direction but it isn’t going to happen overnight. We’re not going to suddenly end up with model visions of cities all over the developing world.’ NB: The place is Karail, the largest informal settlement in Dhaka, but the story is not particular to there. A billion people live in such places around the world. That number is slated to reach 3 billion people in the next 30 years. This means informal settlements are one of the major ways developing cities are being produced. Conventional planning approaches such as slum clearance, cookie-cutter high-rises, peripheral resettlement and back-to-village programs have often failed to manage them. UN-Habitat, the body with global responsibility for issues of urban growth, advocates city-wide slum upgrading and integration with metropolitan plans. Such programs are explicitly “participatory” and inclusive. Specifically, UN-Habitat recommends member states “recognise the rights and contributions of slum dwellers and change the view that they are illegal”. 2050 will have 40% more huts, 3 billion out of 8 as of date ratio living in huts. What is your proposition sir? Servants, labourers etc are nonsense. In the 1950s how did you manage without them? Have you seen typical huts in New York? Problem is freedom of mind and the solution is the space problem. K Rajaram IRS 22724 NOTE GOPALA ALL KNEW YOUR LIMITATIONS; SO DO NOT PRETEND AS IF YOU ARE A THINK TANK AND SOMEONE IS ERRONEOUSLY AGAINST YOU; NO; YOU ARE AGAINST YOURSELF. YOUR ACTION YOUR OWN INVITE PROBLEMS WHICH HURTS YOU EVERYDAY BUT CHANGE SHALL ARISE AT YOUR END. On Mon, 22 Jul 2024 at 10:38, Gopala Krishnan <gopa4...@gmail.com> wrote: > CULTURAL QA 07-2024-22 > > TOPIC- GENERAL- BASE QUORA QA- Compiled > > Q1 Why do temples not give free meals to devotees like > gurdwaras do? > > A1 Aashish Kumar Dimri, One who loves his food !Jul 13 > > Tirupati : It runs a state of art grand free kitchen known as Anna > Prasadam Kshetram. > > It runs one of the largest temple kitchens across the world. > > Every visitor at Lord Venkateswara temple is obliged to enjoy free Prasad > (full breakfast ; lunch and dinner). > > No wonder, nearly 50000 devotees are served daily by TTD. > > Tirumala Tirupati Devasthanams’ volunteers also serve free meals to many > others- outside temple premises. > > Breakfast : Every day , devotees and visitors are provided either Upma or > Pongal or Vermicelli upma and delicious chutney as healthy breakfast. > > Lunch : Visitors can also partake sumptuous vegetarian lunch between 10.30 > A.M. to 04.00 P.M daily . > > It includes - Chakkara Pongal, curry, Chutney, Rice, Sambar, Rasam & > Buttermilk (Chanch) > > Dinner : They can also enjoy similar vegetarian dishes as dinner. > > Free : Well, the only conditions are cleanliness and reverence to Hindu > faith. > > There is no moral policing or social taboos and dogmas. Aggression and > arrogance are never displayed by any servitor or devotee. > > Ample : Devotees are served oft and again with utmost dedication and > humility. Interestingly, many food experts claim that TTD serves more > food to hungry souls than presumption and assumption . > > Those who have darshan of Lord Venkateswara also receive special ladoo as > a blessing. > > Well : Afterall they are treated as special guests or beloved ones of > omnipotent almighty. > > Remember : There are many Hindu shrines across India and abroad that > follow Anna Danam. > > Prayer:Sri Venkateshaya Namah Govinda Govinda Govinda ! > > Q2 What is a comical accident case in India? > > A2 Rupinder Singh,lives in India9h > > One morning in the middle of April 2023, 82-year-old Shivdayal Sharma was > urinating near a railway track in Alwar, Rajasthan. Suddenly, a flying cow > fell on him and he died on the spot.The cow had flown in the air after > being hit by a Vande Bharat train that left from Kali Mori gate. Many > such cases have been reported of cattle dying after straying onto railway > tracks of VB trains. > > Shivdayal had retired from the Indian Railways as an electrician two > decades ago. He was around 30 meters away from where the train hit the cow. > > It flew that distance and fell on the old man. Another man near the spot > narrowly escaped. > > As per 2022 reports, as many as 68 cases were reported in 6 months of > Vande Bharat trains suffering minor damage after hitting cattle on the > tracks. > > More such cases have been reported on the Mumbai-Gujarat route. Union > Railways Minister Ashwini Vaishnav claimed collision with cattle was > unavoidable and VB trains were designed accordingly. > > To keep cattle away from tracks, Vaishnav announced the cleanup of garbage > and removal of vegetation from around the tracks. > > Western Railway decided to install metal fences along the Mumbai-Ahmedabad > route to stop cattle from straying onto tracks. > > Sources:- IndiaToday 2362617,- LiveMint 11671011310508 > > - Zee News 2597507 > > *My note**-Happa- Source is told. Otherwise my only critic **Mr Rajaram > with negative words ** would have asked for source and blame me for > furnishing worng information in groups. * > > *I have never met in my life such a critic **adding only negative > response **to this much extent on a person and furnishing **rubbish > addition mostly not related to the QA. **I pity Mr Rajaram **. A QA is > intended only for answer to the point and not pages of data**.* > > *Dear friends**, **I am forced to make the above note, after going > through very bad reactions of Mr Rajaram on my recent QA postings. You may > go through his responses .* > > Q3 How long did it take for Gutenberg's invention to spread > across Europe? > > A3 Silk Road, Physics/History Connoisseur, AI Machine > Learning. Jul 3 > > This dude came up with a way to crank out books like hotcakes. > > It was 1450 or thereabouts, in Mainz, Germany. Johannes Gutenberg, a > goldsmith by trade, had this wild idea. > > Instead of painstakingly copying books by hand, why not make little metal > letters, arrange them in lines, and then BAM - press them onto paper? > > It was a game-changer, and it didn't take long for word (or rather, > printed page) to spread. > > By the end of the 15th century, Gutenberg's printing press was like > wildfire across Europe. > > Within a few decades, printing shops had popped up in over 270 cities. > Imagine the scene: ink-stained apprentices running around, the rhythmic > thump of the press, and the smell of fresh paper filling the air. > > It was a revolution, plain and simple. > > By 1480, just thirty years after Gutenberg's first Bible rolled off the > press, printing shops were humming away in 110 different places, from > Germany to Italy, France, Spain, and beyond. > > This wasn't just some niche technology; it was in "universal use" across > the continent. > > The reasons for such a fast integration into society are plentiful. > > The printing press made books a hell of a lot cheaper. Before, they were > luxury items, hand-copied by monks and reserved for the elite. > > Now, anyone who could read (and that number was growing, thanks to the > printing press itself) could get their hands on a book. > > It was like the internet of its day, democratizing knowledge and spreading > ideas like never before.The printing press also made it possible to produce > books in massive quantities. We're talking thousands of copies of the same > text, all identical, all ready to be shipped off to eager readers across > Europe. > > It was a logistical marvel, and it fueled a cultural explosion that would > change the course of history. > > Took only about thirty years for the printing press to become ubiquitous > in Europe. That's lightning fast for the 15th century. > > It wasn't just about books; it was about ideas, knowledge, and the power > to communicate on a scale never before seen > > Q4 Can you name any politicians in India who have not been > involved in corruption or bad politics? > > A4 Himanshu Rai, Studied M.A PSIR from Banaras Hindu > University Sat > > Ayub Khan, a 6 feet 2 inches tall cancelled his plan to visit New Delhi > after the death of India’s first prime minister, Pandit Jawaharlal Nehru in > 1964. He apparently said ‘who is there [in India] to talk to. > > Ayub Khan was known to judge leaders by their physical appearance and > Lal Bahadur Shastri was thin and short. > > The India-Pakistan War of 1965 ended officially with an agreement signed > in Tashkent with the mediation by then USSR on January 10, 1966. Within 12 > hours of the agreement, Shastri died of heart attack in the plane flying > him back home. > > By now Ayub Khan was so impressed with Shastri that not only the Soviet > Russia government but also the Pakistan government lowered all their > national flags on all buildings enroute. > > Ayub Khan was the first foreign dignitary to reach Shastri’s home after > his death on January 11, 1966. > > This was the example how Shastri made his image as a strong leader in > global politics. > > But before becoming Prime Minister there was also many incidents where he > proved that he is not in politics to do bad politics. > > Indian railway minister Lal Bahadur Shastri wanted to take political > responsibility for the accident and offered his resignation to prime > minister Jawaharlal Nehru, but he refused. After the 1956 Ariyalur train > accident a similar accident about three months later, Shastri again offered > his resignation and was accepted. > > Even when he was prime minister, country was facing food crisis. At that > time ,Lal Bahadur Shastri announced to his family one evening that for the > next few days they would all give up on their evening meal. > > There is also one incident > > It is said that he had a Chevrolet Impala car for official use, which > his son once used for a drive. > > When Shastri learned about it, he asked his driver to check the > distance the car was used for and later deposited the money in the > government account > > This all examples showed Shastri was the ideal example of good politics. > > Footnotes[1]‘Man who could have brought India, Pakistan together’: When > Pak military dictator praised Lal Bahadur Shastri > > [2]A PM who paid when sons used official car > > Q5 Why don't we demolish slums and tell the inhabitants to go > back to their villages (India)? > > A5 Makarand Sahasrabuddhe, In politics for over 20 years. > Updated 5y > > Why don't we demolish slums and tell the inhabitants to go back to their > villages (India)? > > What a brilliant idea. I wonder why no one has thought about it. Oh wait > a minute. > > Someone did. In 1976. Sanjay Gandhi. He went on a demolition of slums at > Turkman gate which then led to rioting. We all know how that ended for > Sanjay Gandhi and the Congress in the next elections. > > Do you really think that people like and choose to stay in slums? > > Do you know how miserable life is for someone living in a slum? How > dangerous it is for women and children? How expensive it is since they have > to pay for everything at much higher rates cos thugs control the resources? > Do you really think that people would live in a slum if they had a choice? > > Repeat after me - Slums are a manifestation of a failed rural livelihood > and urban housing mechanisms. > > It is because we screw up in establishing sustainable livelihood systems > in rural areas that populations come under stress and migrate to urban > areas. > > It is because there is no provision of low cost housing and no unskilled > or semi-skilled migrant can afford housing in cities (a lot of time even > the skilled find it difficult to get good housing) that they stay in > absolute horrific conditions in slums. > > But suppose someone brave leader did demolish all slums and make people > ‘go back’## to where they came from, do you realise what impact it will > have on a big city**? Let me try to tell you > > No more house-help since most of them come from slums or slum-like > tenements. Ditto for security guards, nurses, ward boys, ambulance > drivers, bus drivers, railway motormen, personal drivers, class IV > employees of municipal corporation who are responsible for sanitation and > garbage clearance etc. > > More than 1/2 the police constables would be gone. > > Most of the petty traders, plumbers, carpenters and other skilled workers > - gone. > > Since you have internet, can speak English and are on Quora - you are > likely to belong to the urban middle class. Do you realise what this means > to you and your life? > > Any skilled or semi skilled labour you hire - you pay more. > > Any domestic worker you hire - you pay more. > > If you are ailing or involved in an accident, it is more difficult to get > to an hospital and get services. > > You do more work at home. You are at increased health risk from poor > sanitation services. > > I could go on but I suppose you get the point. > > To conclude, slum eradication is not the solution. You need to alleviate > (eradicate) poverty and not the poor. (गरीबी हटाओ, गरीब को नहीं) Removing > slum dwellers from cities and sending them ‘back’ is like taking a pill for > a headache when the real problem is probably strain on the eyes or > constipation. The headache is only the manifestation of the problem. > > > > I am not saying that slums need to stay as they are, we can and should > build low cost housing so that the essential service providers can live > with dignity. We should invest in rural livelihoods & infrastructure so > that people are not forced to migrate; they can move of course but not in > distress, by choice. > > ## Of course the ‘go back’ in case of 3rd or 4th generation slum dwellers > may pose a slight problem. Where ‘exactly’ would they go back to? > > ** I am not even speaking at length about what will happen ‘back home’ > where they go to. Starvation, rupture of social fabric, children dropping > out of school, increased violence and collapse of socio-economic-political > fabric. And this will just be the start. > > -- > You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups > "iyer123" group. > To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an > email to iyer123+unsubscr...@googlegroups.com. > To view this discussion on the web visit > https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/iyer123/CAEE2L%2B3kN_uoemMoryhNu9zRbYwew%2BwEZoGeicw%2B4agNzdg%3DVA%40mail.gmail.com > <https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/iyer123/CAEE2L%2B3kN_uoemMoryhNu9zRbYwew%2BwEZoGeicw%2B4agNzdg%3DVA%40mail.gmail.com?utm_medium=email&utm_source=footer> > . > -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "Thatha_Patty" group. To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to thatha_patty+unsubscr...@googlegroups.com. To view this discussion on the web visit https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/thatha_patty/CAL5XZoo-PthxXas%3DJO8xjfdM%3DrNFx%3D1F7ganokMbWj5Askjm8w%40mail.gmail.com.