Re: [time-nuts] science projects

2012-02-10 Thread Steve .
The best inventions are the ones that nobody ever thought to ask for. If Edison had done marketing studies, he would have spent his life designing incremental improvements to gas lights. Nobody asked him to invent the electric light. First let me say that what I'm about to write is

Re: [time-nuts] science projects

2012-02-10 Thread Hal Murray
It's the international science and engineering fair, so both kinds show up. The line between applied science and engineering is pretty fuzzy. There is another category. I'm not sure what the right term is. How about just having fun? I think it's neat to see an experiment or demo that

Re: [time-nuts] science projects

2012-02-10 Thread Chris Dawes
measurement Subject: Re: [time-nuts] science projects It's the international science and engineering fair, so both kinds show up. The line between applied science and engineering is pretty fuzzy. There is another category. I'm not sure what the right term is. How about just having fun? I

Re: [time-nuts] science projects

2012-02-10 Thread Jim Lux
On 2/10/12 1:37 AM, Hal Murray wrote: It's the international science and engineering fair, so both kinds show up. The line between applied science and engineering is pretty fuzzy. There is another category. I'm not sure what the right term is. How about just having fun? Most

Re: [time-nuts] science projects

2012-02-10 Thread Jim Lux
On 2/10/12 2:05 AM, Chris Dawes wrote: Thanks Hal, Will have to visit next time I am in San Fran sounds interesting Makes a nice, but busy, day to do the Exploratorium and the California Academy of Sciences/Steinhart Aquarium. They're pretty close to each other, so it's not like you have

Re: [time-nuts] science projects

2012-02-09 Thread Ray Xu
Hi Jim Thank you for your reply, especially for your input on how science fair is judged. I've saved your reply and I'll be sure to read over it again before regional competition in a few weeks! No I have not done any research into Peter Siegel's work...Thanks for pointing that out to me.

Re: [time-nuts] science projects

2012-02-09 Thread Brooke Clarke
Hi Jim: Check out: http://www.ted.com/talks/lang/eng/clifford_stoll_on_everything.html Here's part of an email from Clifford: Oh, the speed of light? For detectors, I use two fast-response photodiodes and feed their outputs into opamps. The experiment uses one cheap laserpointer (they cost

Re: [time-nuts] science projects

2012-02-09 Thread Chris Albertson
I think it's odd that all these science projects are NOT doing any science. They sound like engineering to me. So you build a neat mouse trap? That is not science unless you have a theory about mouse behavior and your trap is intended to test the theory.Around here we do have these

[time-nuts] science projects

2012-02-09 Thread Bill Fuqua
My experiments with CW laser diodes is that they don't take well to being switched on and off with out a soft start. They will only last a certain number of on off cycles before output begins to drop and they quit working. Perhaps something has changed in the last few years. I need to

Re: [time-nuts] science projects

2012-02-09 Thread Neville Michie
Do not be misled by the conventional theory that scientists develop a theory and then do an experiment to prove it. This theory was dreamed up by some vertical thinker who was incapable of any scientific progress. It has been reinforced by commentators who reconstruct the path of discovery

Re: [time-nuts] science projects

2012-02-09 Thread Chris Albertson
On Thu, Feb 9, 2012 at 2:04 PM, Neville Michie namic...@gmail.com wrote: Do not be misled by the conventional theory that scientists develop a theory and then do an experiment to prove it. This theory was dreamed up by some vertical thinker who was incapable of any scientific progress. Yes

Re: [time-nuts] science projects

2012-02-09 Thread Bill Hawkins
Fellow time scientists, Here's my view of the difference between science and engineering: Someone with better measuring equipment finds a discrepant result while verifying some physical law or accepted truth. That person needs to know the existing truths and create ideas about testing the new

Re: [time-nuts] science projects

2012-02-09 Thread Jim Lux
On 2/9/12 8:23 AM, Chris Albertson wrote: I think it's odd that all these science projects are NOT doing any science. They sound like engineering to me. So you build a neat mouse trap? That is not science unless you have a theory about mouse behavior and your trap is intended to test the

Re: [time-nuts] science projects

2012-02-09 Thread Jim Lux
Yes, a fun project, and a fine physics lab exercise. But not a good science fair project because it doesn't meet the originality bar. This is something that I confess I had a hard time figuring out what that meant when I was entering science fairs... as it happened, my projects *were*

Re: [time-nuts] science projects

2012-02-09 Thread Jim Lux
On 2/9/12 4:00 PM, Bill Hawkins wrote: Fellow time scientists, Here's my view of the difference between science and engineering: snip If marketing studies show a positive return on investment, engineers are turned loose to solve the problems revealed as the details of building or

Re: [time-nuts] science projects

2012-02-09 Thread Chris Albertson
On Thu, Feb 9, 2012 at 4:09 PM, Jim Lux jim...@earthlink.net wrote: On 2/9/12 8:23 AM, Chris Albertson wrote: I think it's odd that all these science projects are NOT doing any science.   They sound like engineering to me. So you build a neat mouse trap?  That is not science unless you have

Re: [time-nuts] science projects

2012-02-09 Thread Daniel Schultz
If marketing studies show a positive return on investment, engineers are turned loose to solve the problems revealed as the details of building or manufacturing the new thing are studied. The best inventions are the ones that nobody ever thought to ask for. If Edison had done marketing studies,

[time-nuts] science projects

2012-02-08 Thread Jim Lux
While delayed, I would think that the signal freqs would still need to be maintained... hmmm, maybe not... interesting science project... anyone? anyone? ;-) Jerry I'm waiting to see a good time-nuts project at the science fair. (at any level up to ISEF) There's a lot of good

Re: [time-nuts] science projects

2012-02-08 Thread Chris Albertson
The number one TN science fair project would have to be measuring the speed of light using some simple, inexpensive method such as reflecting sunlight from rotating mirrors On Wed, Feb 8, 2012 at 5:44 PM, Jim Lux jim...@earthlink.net wrote:  While delayed, I would think that the signal freqs

Re: [time-nuts] science projects

2012-02-08 Thread Ray Xu
Hi guys My 2 cents...from first person experience ;-) (although this doesn't have much to do with frequency standard-related science fair projects...) I am actually a high school junior in one of Dallas/Ft Worth, Texas's, suburbs, and I have been competing in ISEF science fairs for the last 3

Re: [time-nuts] science projects

2012-02-08 Thread Jim Lux
On 2/8/12 6:03 PM, Chris Albertson wrote: The number one TN science fair project would have to be measuring the speed of light using some simple, inexpensive method such as reflecting sunlight from rotating mirrors Actually, that's probably not a good project: it's been done, in almost

Re: [time-nuts] science projects

2012-02-08 Thread Jim Lux
On 2/8/12 7:37 PM, Ray Xu wrote: Hi guys My 2 cents...from first person experience ;-) (although this doesn't have much to do with frequency standard-related science fair projects...) I am actually a high school junior in one of Dallas/Ft Worth, Texas's, suburbs, and I have been competing in

Re: [time-nuts] science projects

2012-02-08 Thread Attila Kinali
On Wed, 8 Feb 2012 21:37:36 -0600 Ray Xu rayxu...@gmail.com wrote: I am actually a high school junior in one of Dallas/Ft Worth, Texas's, suburbs, and I have been competing in ISEF science fairs for the last 3 years. [...] This year, I'm working on making a monolithic CMOS THz imaging array