Re: Prenatal effect on language?

1999-04-13 Thread Michael Sylvester
On Mon, 12 Apr 1999, Becky Columbus wrote: > > While I haven't come across any studies that answer question #1, there is > some evidence that babies can discriminate between languages earlier than 6 > months. > Apparently, human babies can differentiate between languages as early as 4 > days a

Prenatal effect on language?

1999-04-12 Thread Becky Columbus
At 09:28 AM 4/10/99 -0400, Stephen Black wrote: >My question: is there any evidence to the contrary, either that: > >1) early babbling of babies is _not_ the same the world over > >2) babies no older than six months _do_ show differences in their >ability to detect phonemic pairs depending on wh

Prenatal effect on language?

1999-04-10 Thread Stephen Black
In child psychology I reviewed evidence that the fetus can hear, and that she can learn from the sound of the human voice she hears in utero. Later, in language development I discussed Chomsky's LAD, and said it was a mistake to think that it includes innate knowledge of a particular language. I