Re: [tips] behavioral dilemma

2010-10-10 Thread michael sylvester
- Original Message - From: To: "Teaching in the Psychological Sciences (TIPS)" Sent: Sunday, October 10, 2010 1:57 PM Subject: Re: [tips] behavioral dilemma I agree, and am delighted that many seem to recognize the value of good observation and description, and the role of presump

Re: [tips] behavioral dilemma

2010-10-10 Thread Ken Steele
At this point, I would say to the student that he has made an interesting anecdotal observation and that he needs to verify his observation first. I like the idea of videotaping. First, the student could do a simple count of how many people take glasses from the pile vs. the tidy line. Ne

Re: [tips] behavioral dilemma

2010-10-10 Thread peterson
I agree, and am delighted that many seem to recognize the value of good observation and description, and the role of presumptive vantage points underlying such accounts. The class could explore the assumptions and biases involved in naive descriptions as a critical thinking exercise. How do ps

Re: [tips] behavioral dilemma

2010-10-10 Thread Michael Smith
I hesitate to point this out, butthere is no evidence that this behavior exists or is "automatic" and that the "fact" that "he fully understands that when people go to these places they are not 'themselves' but rather some zombie-like shell of themselves" to me is a bizzarre assumption. Especia

Re: [tips] behavioral dilemma

2010-10-10 Thread Paul C Bernhardt
Because the behavior is almost certainly automatic, then I think it is likely a 'apparently/possible newness is better' heuristic is operating, and it may be related to individual differences in germ awareness. I agree with Beth that doing some videotaping and observation to see if there are a

Re: [tips] Zuckerberg film?

2010-10-10 Thread michael sylvester
Description is not explanation. Michael "omnicentric "Sylvester,PhD Daytona Beach,Florida --- You are currently subscribed to tips as: arch...@jab.org. To unsubscribe click here: http://fsulist.frostburg.edu/u?id=13090.68da6e6e5325aa33287ff385b70df5d5&n=T&l=tips&o=5532 or send a blank email to

Re: [tips] behavioral dilemma

2010-10-10 Thread michael sylvester
I have been to Sea World in Orlando many times and have observed no such thing.But as the cross-cultural dude on Tips,the characteristics of the audience could be of some import,in Orlando the audience is significantly European. I magine in San Diego it has a large Asian contingent and Latin.I

[tips] Zuckerberg film?

2010-10-10 Thread peterson
Just saw movie Social Network about Facebook founder Mark Zuckerberg. The portrayal left me thinking of autism spectrum. Anyone else see this and think Aspbergers (sp?) when seeing him? He seemed very IQ-bright, and aloof emotionally; and Facebook really fits this picture of being able to cont

re: [tips] behavioral dilemma

2010-10-10 Thread Mike Palij
On Sun, 10 Oct 2010 07:01:29 -0700, Annette Taylor wrote: >[snip] >... His job is to take a HUGE pile of these glasses as people >deposit them into a barrel, exiting the previous show, and to >disentangle the pile and lay them out neatly on a table so that >people going into the show can just gr

Re: [tips] behavioral dilemma

2010-10-10 Thread Beth Benoit
For a start, I'd think the student might want to set up a video camera and take a video of people selecting their glasses. There might be some clues there. Are men more likely to select from the tangled pile? Or women? Taller people? Do difficult-pile selecters seem more friendly? Less/more i

RE: [tips] behavioral dilemma

2010-10-10 Thread DeVolder Carol L
Hi Annette, I'm sure others will have a more sophisticated answer, but a few things came to mind as I read your post. First, people often display strange superstitious behavior--especially if they think "germs" are involved. Could it be that the tangled pile seems like it could be a newer, perha

[tips] behavioral dilemma

2010-10-10 Thread Annette Taylor
A student in my intro to psych class asked me this question, which I think would have an answer someplace in social psych: He works at SeaWorld, a large amusement park. He prefaced his question by telling me that he fully understands that when people go to these places they are not 'themselves'