Re:[tips] Teacher evaluations and learning

2010-12-12 Thread Allen Esterson
Jim Clark writes on >the striking contrast is the emphasis on clarity in >Beijing (50) and sensitivity in Chicago (42). Only >one of many differences, of course, between Asian >and American schooling. And, I would add, between Asian and British schooling as well. Some idea of the differences, an

[tips] Football,contingency,and God reinforcer

2010-12-12 Thread michael sylvester
There was an interesting event at a High school football game here in Central Florida.A player who scored a touchdown fell on his knees and began thanking God while still holding the ball in hand. He was reprimanded for this behavior.However it was emphasized that had he dropped the ball and beg

[tips] Becoming a Teacher of Statistics Course

2010-12-12 Thread Michelle Everson
Hi Everyone, We hope you will be able to pass this announcement on to colleagues and to students you know who might be able to take this course and have it apply toward their degree programs. We are pleased to announce that the unique, online course, "Becoming a Teacher of Statistics," will be of

Re: [tips] Teacher evaluations and learning

2010-12-12 Thread Jim Clark
Hi There is a great book by Charters and Waples (1929) which asked students (among others) about the qualities of good teachers. It is actually on-line if one wants to wade through its 700 pages. http://www.archive.org/details/commonwealthteac027990mbp Here's a brief idea about how Allan Pai

Re: [tips] Self-plagiarism loose in Canada

2010-12-12 Thread Jim Clark
Hi One issue I would have with the article is the mention of 79,000 PAIRS of articles with duplicate text, which gives an impression that appears to be wildly out of line with the demonstrated instances of duplicate publication. I think the large number is a product of at least two factors: (1

RE: [tips] Self-plagiarism loose in Canada

2010-12-12 Thread Paul C Bernhardt
Don't miss the link to the apparent self-plagiarism database drawn from Medline http://spore.vbi.vt.edu/dejavu/ It is astonishing the amount of this that appears to have been happening over the years. A student of mine came across a case essentially similar to those in that database when he wa

Re: [tips] Distinguished scientist descends into pseudoscience

2010-12-12 Thread Jim Clark
Hi I was struck by the avoidance of the word "homeopathy" in the article. A little googling revealed Harriet Hall's excellent piece on why Montagier's earlier research contradicted rather than supported homeopathy. http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/?p=2081 The article also explains the "fin

Re: [tips] Distinguished scientist descends into pseudoscience

2010-12-12 Thread sblack
On 12 Dec 2010 at 15:27, Claudia Stanny wrote: > Any connection to the old (and, I assume, discredited) hypothesis > about "structured water" from the 1960s? Perhaps you're thinking of "polywater" which attracted much excitement as an alleged anomalous new form of water? I don't think there's

Re: [tips] Distinguished scientist descends into pseudoscience

2010-12-12 Thread Rick Stevens
I think he has added a bit of new... something... to the memory of water story. It sounds like you could hook an EEG to water with memory, receive the electromagnetic signals and send it to people over the internet. It sounds like a business opportunity to me. ...controversial idea championed by

[tips] Teacher evaluations and learning

2010-12-12 Thread Joan Warmbold
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/12/11/education/11education.html?src=me&ref=general Intriguing article in the NYT's today about how students are actually quite aware of how well their teacher is using their time and helping them to learn. Joan jwarm...@oakton.edu --- You are currently subscribed to

Re: [tips] Distinguished scientist descends into pseudoscience

2010-12-12 Thread Claudia Stanny
Any connection to the old (and, I assume, discredited) hypothesis about "structured water" from the 1960s? Bad ideas just never seem to go away . . . . Claudia On Sun, Dec 12, 2010 at 12:35 PM, wrote: > That's Luc Montagnier of France, who received the Nobel Prize in 2008 for > the discovery

Re: [tips] Distinguished scientist descends into pseudoscience

2010-12-12 Thread Christopher D. Green
Eek! Water memory. Isn't that the excuse homeopaths use for how infinitesimal bits of (whatever), diluted by millions of times as much water, might still be able to cure disease (rather than just be extremely expensive water). The least he could do is indulge in an interesting fantasy. Chris -

[tips] Self-plagiarism loose in Canada

2010-12-12 Thread sblack
Another item of possible interest to TIPSters from Nature News, although (as a reader points out) the transgression is better characterized as "duplicate publication". http://www.nature.com/news/2010/101207/full/468745a.html Don't miss the comprehensive list of high-profile plagiarism cases ap

[tips] Distinguished scientist descends into pseudoscience

2010-12-12 Thread sblack
That's Luc Montagnier of France, who received the Nobel Prize in 2008 for the discovery of HIV. http://www.nature.com/news/2010/101208/full/468743a.html Why do they do it? And while you're there, check out the first reader comment (by Robert Loblay). Stephen -