RE: [tips] Query about Type of Multi-Choice Question

2012-07-26 Thread Zasloff, Lee
I use these types of questions and have never had a complaint. The way I see it, C and D could just as well say "Both of these are true" and "Neither of these is true". I don't see the puzzle so much as having to think it through and decide on the correct answer - just like any other question.

Re: [tips] Query about Type of Multi-Choice Question

2012-07-26 Thread Jim Clark
Hi I guess I do not see the puzzle solving element. The relevant study found that Love marriages start out with higher Love scores than Arranged marriages, but due to a decline in the scores for Love marriages and an increase in scores for Arranged marriages, Arranged marriages had higher love sc

RE: [tips] Query about Type of Multi-Choice Question

2012-07-26 Thread Wuensch, Karl L
Not wanting to have general intelligence too big a contributor to performance on my exams, I have replaced C and D with options such as C. Increased worship of Lord Priapus among young wives. D. Decreased complaints about Jim Clark. Regretfully, these changes have not affected th

Re: [tips] Query about Type of Multi-Choice Question

2012-07-26 Thread William Scott
These items and other "puzzle solving" type items such as odd-item-out almost always show the highest index of discrimination when I do an item analysis of my tests. Of course, if the tests are meant to score "thinkers" more highly than "knowers", then this will probably not be a surprising result.

Re: [tips] Query about Type of Multi-Choice Question

2012-07-26 Thread Claudia Stanny
I never use a question with this type of structure. I also avoid options like "A and B," "C or B but not A," and similar logic puzzles. I still smile over an exam question I encountered as an undergraduate, where a typo in test creation resulted an option D that read "one of the above." What is

Re: [tips] Query about Type of Multi-Choice Question

2012-07-26 Thread Carol DeVolder
I would use this type of question, in fact I do whenever I can if I need to write multiple choice questions. I get complaints that my exams are too difficult, but never that this format is unfair. Students refer to them as multiple uglies, but I like to make them think about why an answer should be

[tips] Query about Type of Multi-Choice Question

2012-07-26 Thread Jim Clark
Hi I had a student recently complain vigorously that a kind of multi-choice question I use was unfair. The type of question is illustrated below: 12. Relative to Love marriages, Arranged marriages in India have been found to result in: A. lower levels of love early in the marriage B. lower lev

Re: [tips] Cruel and unusual punishment

2012-07-26 Thread Paul Brandon
On Jul 26, 2012, at 4:09 PM, Joan Warmbold wrote: > Am in total agreement with treating Division I major sport athletes as > professionals and "paid as such," but would lead to so many dicey issues. Such as? How would they differ from other professional university employees? The whole point is s

Re: [tips] Cruel and unusual punishment

2012-07-26 Thread Joan Warmbold
Am in total agreement with treating Division I major sport athletes as professionals and "paid as such," but would lead to so many dicey issues. Whatever, some type of compensation for these top-level athletes who are drawing immense amounts of $$ for their colleges only seems reasonable and fair.

[tips] re: [tips] On Leaving Academia « Ars Experientia

2012-07-26 Thread Michael Palij
On Thu, 26 Jul 2012 08:59:25 -0700, Christopher Green wrote: >An interesting essay by a professor who decided to pack it in. But before you >read it, try to guess in advance what he calls the "festering, suppurating, >gangrenous wound in the zeitgeist of the country." > >http://cs.unm.edu/~terran/a

RE: [tips] On Leaving Academia < Ars Experientia

2012-07-26 Thread Marc Carter
Thanks for that, Chris. When I first started teaching I considered my job to be the best job in the world. No longer. It's fundamentally a different world than it was then -- at that was only 20 years ago. m PS And I guessed correctly about the festering zeitgeist. :) -- Marc Carter, PhD

[tips] On Leaving Academia « Ars Experientia

2012-07-26 Thread Christopher Green
An interesting essay by a professor who decided to pack it in. But before you read it, try to guess in advance what he calls the "festering, suppurating, gangrenous wound in the zeitgeist of the country." http://cs.unm.edu/~terran/academic_blog/?p=113 Chris ... Christopher D Green Departmen

Re: [tips] The same brain areas involved in

2012-07-26 Thread mjchael sylvester
It depends on what you use yor cell for.If you are expecting a critical call from the chairman or the VP for Academic affairs on a Friday by 4:30 pm,you should be anxious if you left your cell at home. michael - Original Message - From: Zasloff, Lee To: Teaching in the Psychologica

Re: [tips] Cruel and unusual punishment

2012-07-26 Thread Paul Brandon
The next analytic step is to take into account what the athletes in each sport major in, and compare their GPA's and graduation rates with those of nonathletes in the same programs. Personally, I feel that Division I major sport athletes are professionals and should be paid as such. If a univer

RE: [tips] Cruel and unusual punishment

2012-07-26 Thread Rick Froman
Maybe the article you linked actually compared the graduation rates of athletes to other students at the specific schools they were looking at. I was just citing the overall six-year graduation rate (it was specifically 52.9% for same-school grad rate with an additional 11.3% graduating from ano

RE: [tips] The same brain areas involved in

2012-07-26 Thread Zasloff, Lee
If internet addiction is going to be in the DSM, how about cell phone addiction? I'm convinced that it's real. And not just for students. Ever feel anxious when you've left home without your cell phone? Lee R. Lee Zasloff, PhD Adjunct Instructor, Psychology American River College Sacrame

[tips] The same brain areas involved in

2012-07-26 Thread mjchael sylvester
cocaine addiction light up in digital addicted individuals.This could imply that internet addiction can be correlated with sexual and food satiation feelings.Ironically,since drug addiction,can lead to weight loss,internet addiction could also produce this effect.Just as in the classic Milner and

RE: [tips] Cruel and unusual punishment

2012-07-26 Thread Joan Warmbold
Rick, Where did you get the data you cite. According to the article I had checked out in "The Bootleg's 2011 Graduation Analysis," as cited below, the last chart compares the graduation rate of football players compared to the graduation rate of all students and is between 15% and 35% lower. Ma

RE: [tips] Uncertainty shrouds psychologist's resignation : Nature News & Comment

2012-07-26 Thread Jim Clark
Hi My note did include another approach to increasing acceptance rates. Adopt the shorter format that once was common in such psychology journals as the Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior or the Journal of Experimental Psychology, and is still the dominant format in many (most? all

RE: [tips] Cruel and unusual punishment

2012-07-26 Thread Rick Froman
Not arguing one way or the other on this overall issue of exploitation of student athletes but, for some context, the overall six year graduation rate from colleges (the same college from matriculation to graduation) is generally a little over 50% so the 44% to 85% shown below is actually fairly

RE: [tips] Uncertainty shrouds psychologist's resignation : Nature News & Comment

2012-07-26 Thread Rick Froman
Following up on Jim Clark's suggestion to raise acceptance rates and thus be free to publish more failures to replicate: It seems there are only two approaches to increasing the acceptance rate: decreasing the denominator or increasing the numerator. As to the denominator, decreasing interest a