PROPOSAL: build directories

2002-06-07 Thread costinm
Some of you may remember back in tomcat3.0 we used to build all the stuff in jakarta-tomcat/../build and ../dist. What do you think about moving back to that layout ? Also, we curently rely on having all dependency as a full package. It may be better to just have all the .jar files built (

Re: PROPOSAL: build directories

2002-06-07 Thread Remy Maucherat
Some of you may remember back in tomcat3.0 we used to build all the stuff in jakarta-tomcat/../build and ../dist. What do you think about moving back to that layout ? I'd vote -1. I like the current style better. I have lots of different Tomcat 4.x repositories (4.0.4-b3, 4.0.x, 4.1.x,

Re: PROPOSAL: build directories

2002-06-07 Thread costinm
On Fri, 7 Jun 2002, Remy Maucherat wrote: Some of you may remember back in tomcat3.0 we used to build all the stuff in jakarta-tomcat/../build and ../dist. What do you think about moving back to that layout ? I'd vote -1. I like the current style better. I have lots of different

Re: PROPOSAL: build directories

2002-06-07 Thread Eric Rescorla
Remy Maucherat [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Some of you may remember back in tomcat3.0 we used to build all the stuff in jakarta-tomcat/../build and ../dist. What do you think about moving back to that layout ? I'd vote -1. I like the current style better. I have lots of different

Re: PROPOSAL: build directories

2002-06-07 Thread Remy Maucherat
On Fri, 7 Jun 2002, Remy Maucherat wrote: Some of you may remember back in tomcat3.0 we used to build all the stuff in jakarta-tomcat/../build and ../dist. What do you think about moving back to that layout ? I'd vote -1. I like the current style better. I have lots of different

Re: PROPOSAL: build directories

2002-06-07 Thread costinm
On Fri, 7 Jun 2002, Remy Maucherat wrote: I agree this is not perfect, but IMO it is a lot less risky that ../build. I could indeed maintain completely separate environments, but this is not very convinient or efficient (at least for me). Note that the current system doesn't prevent you from

Re: PROPOSAL: build directories

2002-06-07 Thread Remy Maucherat
On Fri, 7 Jun 2002, Remy Maucherat wrote: The problem is that I loose track of all the dozens of projects, each with different conventions and locations. By 'clean build' I meant building all the projects from their sources, to make sure all things are in sync. My conclusion so far - it's

Re: PROPOSAL: build directories

2002-06-07 Thread Pier Fumagalli
Remy Maucherat [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Some of you may remember back in tomcat3.0 we used to build all the stuff in jakarta-tomcat/../build and ../dist. What do you think about moving back to that layout ? I'd vote -1. I like the current style better. I have lots of different Tomcat

Re: PROPOSAL: build directories

2002-06-07 Thread costinm
On Fri, 7 Jun 2002, Remy Maucherat wrote: We have a different definition of what a full build is. You define it as: rebuild everything from HEAD, including the dependent JARs (Gump style), while I define it as: rebuild all the Tomcat components (the 7 you defined above) based on stable