Re: Topband: Fwd: ARRL Board meets next week - I'm looking for input

2015-07-11 Thread Herbert Schoenbohm
Why should we be concerned where the operator of a remote station is actually located. The location of the actual station is all that really matters. Remote control of your station provides an amazing advance of our hobby. It provides an reliable escape to so many who are not able to

Re: Topband: Fwd: ARRL Board meets next week - I'm looking for input

2015-07-11 Thread Larry Burke
This issue is actually bigger than the farce it is making of the ARRL awards programs. When you write your Division Director you might also ask him at what point will the League consider 'for rent' commercial remotes -- which are already in operation today -- an affront to the amateur

Re: Topband: Fwd: Fwd: ARRL Board meets next week - I'm looking for input

2015-07-11 Thread Tom W8JI
I don't understand the sudden hysteria, except it may be Internet driven. Around 52 years ago, my first or second 160 meter California contact was with remote W6YY. I can't remember if W6VSS Dale or W6YY was first, but that was when the band was split and the power limit was maybe 25 watts

Re: Topband: Fwd: ARRL Board meets next week - I'm looking for input

2015-07-11 Thread Roger D Johnson
I sat down to write an intelligent response to the remote question but realized I don't really care anymore. The Amateur Radio that I grew up with, and loved, is gone forever. Thanks to the ARRL and the FCC, it has been dumbed down and deregulated to the point where it's just another Citizens

Re: Topband: Fwd: Fwd: ARRL Board meets next week - I'm looking for input

2015-07-11 Thread T R Mortimer
...These are individual awards. How you get them is your business, how I get mine is my business... Excellent ! May I inject 39 Cents'-worth ? [allowing for inflation] That seems to me to sum it up, totally, completely, utterly, and entirely. There must be 75 dB (give or take a few S

Re: Topband: Fwd: ARRL Board meets next week

2015-07-11 Thread Jim Murray via Topband
Here in the Virgin Islands I have built and functional SO2R  station (NP2P) which provides for the operator (N2TTA) to operate from  his apartment in NYC. Not sure I understand this correctly.  Like the majority  of amateurs I haven't gotten into remote operation at this point.  Does the op in

Re: Topband: Fwd: ARRL Board meets next week - I'm looking for input

2015-07-11 Thread Chortek, Robert L
People should be free to operate any way they please - within the rules. I understand this discussion is about what the rules should be. It's all about having fun! It's also about striking a reasonable balance between the many benefits of remote operation (discussed here multiple times) and

Re: Topband: Fwd: Fwd: ARRL Board meets next week - I'm looking for input

2015-07-11 Thread W0MU
Instead of embracing ways to get and keep more people on the air they want to regulate a certificate into the ground just like the Gov't seems to do with everything it touches. Obviously remote ham radio is very popular as these stations are popping up all over the place, which is a good

Re: Topband: Fwd: ARRL Board meets next week - I'm looking for input

2015-07-11 Thread Cecil
All excellent points and very well stated Larry Cecil K5DL Sent using recycled electrons. On Jul 11, 2015, at 6:48 AM, Larry Burke w...@sbcglobal.net wrote: This issue is actually bigger than the farce it is making of the ARRL awards programs. When you write your Division

Re: Topband: Fwd: Fwd: ARRL Board meets next week - I'm looking for input

2015-07-11 Thread W7RH
Many of you folks are too sensitive, especially to legitimate use of remotes. Yes, DX'ing and constesting on a competitive level can be challenging to the pocket book but, contrary to comments one does not have to be a Rich to compete in awards or competitions. Tom W8JI, made the most logical

Re: Topband: Fwd: Fwd: ARRL Board meets next week - I'm looking for input

2015-07-11 Thread mstangelo
Technology is always giving us new tools to work with. You cannot compare past accomplishments with present ones. As we age or downside our living conditions may force me to operate RHR. I'm fine with that and will acknowledge the fact during the QSO. The League should provide different

Re: Topband: Maunder minimum solar cycle in 2030?

2015-07-11 Thread donovanf
After hundreds of years of scientific research of sunspot cycles, no long range solar cycle forecasting model has ever been able to reliably forecast the intensity of a solar cycle until after the cycle begins to rise. Perhaps this will be the first model to reliably forecast the intensity of

Re: Topband: Fwd: ARRL Board meets next week - I'm looking for input

2015-07-11 Thread John K9UWA
Although I agree with many who have posted to this thread I will only say this. The ARRL can not create a DXCC rule that they have no ability to enforce. Other than some He Said She Said that Joe Doe's signal was coming from the wrong direction so he wasn't transmitting from his home

Re: Topband: Fwd: ARRL Board meets next week - I'm looking for input

2015-07-11 Thread Dave AA6YQ
What's the ethical difference between an NA east coast op who uses an NA west coast remote to work 160m Asian DX, and an NA east coast op who flies to a friend's NA west coast QTH for a week to work 160m Asian DX? What's the ethical difference between paying someone to assemble and maintain a

Re: Topband: more on DXCC remotes

2015-07-11 Thread Michael Adams
Here's what I sent my director: For whatever it’s worth, I’m generally OK with leaving DXCC as-is as regards to remote operating. I don’t necessarily see remote operating as any more or less “troubling” as going to a neighbor’s/buddy’s big gun station to grab a new one, or traveling across

Re: Topband: DXCC Issues !

2015-07-11 Thread Jim Brown
On Sat,7/11/2015 4:06 PM, Dick Bingham wrote: How disheartning it is to work a weak W1-station calling CQ on six meters I almost never use /6 except occasionally on 6M during band openings. On SSB, if I'm calling CQ, I'll identify K9YC in California. The WSJT modes are great -- it's common

Re: Topband: Fwd: ARRL Board meets next week - I'm looking for input

2015-07-11 Thread W0MU
While the horse and carriage still exist very few use them. I am sorry you feel badly about ham radio as we have had some very amazing advancesWeak signal programs are amazing. On 7/11/2015 10:09 AM, Roger D Johnson wrote: I sat down to write an intelligent response to the remote question

Re: Topband: Fwd: Fwd: ARRL Board meets next week - I'm looking for input

2015-07-11 Thread Robert Harmon
Mike, I agree 120% !! The different classes make perfect sense. Bob K6UJ On Jul 11, 2015, at 1:00 PM, mstang...@comcast.net wrote: Technology is always giving us new tools to work with. You cannot compare past accomplishments with present ones. As we age or downside our

Re: Topband: Maunder minimum solar cycle in 2030?

2015-07-11 Thread Bill Tippett
I had to do a memory refresh but finally recalled that Leif Svalgaard, et.al. accurately predicted Cycle 24 in October 2004. He did not use conveyor belt theory but polar field measurements: Using direct polar field measurements, now available for four solar cycles, we predict that the

Re: Topband: Fwd: Fwd: ARRL Board meets next week - I'm looking for input

2015-07-11 Thread Jim Brown
On Sat,7/11/2015 9:29 AM, W7RH wrote: Many of you folks are too sensitive, especially to legitimate use of remotes. Yes, DX'ing and constesting on a competitive level can be challenging to the pocket book but, contrary to comments one does not have to be a Rich to compete in awards or

Re: Topband: Fwd: ARRL Board meets next week - I'm looking for input

2015-07-11 Thread wb6rse1
It’s an easy problem to solve. Just change every country with districts into multiple DXCC entities. WØ-W9. Ten new countries. VE1, VE2, VK1 etc. Move to another “country,” start all over. And restart DXCC by band and mode from scratch. No grandfathered credits. How about on April 1, 2016? If

Re: Topband: Maunder minimum solar cycle in 2030?

2015-07-11 Thread JC
Thanks Bill There is another video about Maunder minimum coming fast. As you can hear on the video paid Scientist are paid to say so. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MARk49q5FFY 73's JC N4IS -Original Message- From: Topband [mailto:topband-boun...@contesting.com] On Behalf Of Bill

Re: Topband: Maunder minimum solar cycle in 2030?

2015-07-11 Thread Bill Tippett
Hi Frank, Please correct me if I'm wrong but I thought the conveyor belt theory was used to predict the weakness of the current cycle. Hathaway himself did not predict this weakness: NASA's Hathaway, along with colleague Robert Wilson at a meeting of the American Geophysical Union in San

Topband: more on DXCC remotes

2015-07-11 Thread JAYB1943
I have sent the following to my ARRL Director: Hi Mike – I don’t think we really can’t deny the advance of technology...in fact, traditionally, hams have always been in the forefront of new technical developments. Personal specific actions by the individual ham operator to accomplish the QSO

Re: Topband: Fwd: ARRL Board meets next week - I'm looking for input

2015-07-11 Thread Robert Harmon
Jim, Thanks, I have done the same. You can give your opinion on this subject by contacting your ARRL division director. Click on this webpage, select your director, and send an email ! http://www.arrl.org/divisions http://www.arrl.org/divisions 73, Bob K6UJ On Jul 11, 2015, at 12:49

Re: Topband: Fwd: ARRL Board meets next week - I'm looking for input

2015-07-11 Thread JC
Hi Larry You right, I sent my comments to the board. The main rule I would like to see implemented it the one in place, or almost in place I should say it. All 160m QSL cards are verified by a certified 160m DXCC holder. QSO's during day time are rejected. However LOTW does not have a simple

Topband: DXCC Issues !

2015-07-11 Thread Dick Bingham
Greetings All Where Tom - W8JI - says I think the real solution is a DXCC endorsement or a new DXCC that requires the holder to swear he did it all transmitting and receiving from one ​ location all by himself with gear he assembled I totally agree ! What good, really, is a QSO with someone you

Re: Topband: Fwd: ARRL Board meets next week - I'm looking for input

2015-07-11 Thread Gary and Kathleen Pearse
I told myself when I started Amateur Radio I was going to be a Goose…where every day’s a new day. No awards, just work who you can, when you can, any way you can. So now when I hear DX or there’s a contest I try to make a contact if it’s of interest. As I say, that way every day and contact’s