Re: Topband: 160 Shunt-Fed Tower Readings

2014-12-10 Thread Charlie Cunningham
es should help you a LOT! Have fun and have a Merry Christmas! 73, Charlie, K4OTV -Original Message- From: Larry K4AB [mailto:larry.k...@gmail.com] Sent: Wednesday, December 10, 2014 8:23 PM To: Charlie Cunningham Cc: topband@contesting.com Subject: Re: Topband: 160 Shunt-Fed Tower Readin

Re: Topband: 160 Shunt-Fed Tower Readings

2014-12-10 Thread Larry K4AB
gt; BTW - I AM an RF engineer and I have spent q lot of my career designing and > measuring antennas > > 73, > Charlie, K4OTV > > > > -Original Message----- > From: Topband [mailto:topband-boun...@contesting.com] On Behalf Of Larry > K4AB > Sent: Wednesday, December

Re: Topband: 160 Shunt-Fed Tower Readings

2014-12-10 Thread Charlie Cunningham
e: Topband: 160 Shunt-Fed Tower Readings >I would like to know how you can get 15893pf from a 1000pf capacitor. That >has to be a mis-read value there...gary maybe rounded off to 159pf?? That's a great question. Where is the analyzer actually getting that reading? 73, Larry K4

Re: Topband: 160 Shunt-Fed Tower Readings

2014-12-10 Thread Charlie Cunningham
sting.com] On Behalf Of Larry K4AB Sent: Wednesday, December 10, 2014 6:14 PM To: Charlie Cunningham Cc: topband@contesting.com Subject: Re: Topband: 160 Shunt-Fed Tower Readings " line >Why do you feel a need to improve it? Thanks for the response, Charlie! I'm concerned about a fe

Re: Topband: 160 Shunt-Fed Tower Readings

2014-12-10 Thread Larry K4AB
>I would like to know how you can get 15893pf from a 1000pf capacitor. That >has to be a mis-read value there...gary maybe rounded off to 159pf?? That's a great question. Where is the analyzer actually getting that reading? 73, Larry K4AB On 12/10/14, Tom W8JI wrote: >> I'm concerned about

Re: Topband: 160 Shunt-Fed Tower Readings

2014-12-10 Thread Tom W8JI
I'm concerned about a few things: 1) I'm thinking the antenna is electrically too short. After all, the Yagi at the top really isn't adding too much top loading. And I'm thinking adding a couple of top loading wires connected to the tower might be beneficial. If you run any power, you will

Re: Topband: 160 Shunt-Fed Tower Readings

2014-12-10 Thread Larry K4AB
>Why do you feel a need to improve it? Thanks for the response, Charlie! I'm concerned about a few things: 1) I'm thinking the antenna is electrically too short. After all, the Yagi at the top really isn't adding too much top loading. And I'm thinking adding a couple of top loading wires conne

Re: Topband: 160 Shunt-Fed Tower Readings

2014-12-10 Thread Charlie Cunningham
>From your description and your measured data, Larry, I don't see how you could improve the antenna noticeably! Why do you feel a need to improve it? I appears to be resonant, well-matched and it appears to have an excellent ground image system! I think you might be kidding yourself if you chang

Re: Topband: 160 Shunt-Fed Tower Readings

2014-12-10 Thread Herbert Schoenbohm
You may be able to improve the antennas performance by taking the out side insulated elements at the center to the boom with hand wound chokes that pass only below 5 Mhz or lower to provide some top loading without impacting the Force 12 performance. You may also be able to get a better feed