Re: Topband: Cheating etc

2020-02-14 Thread Fred Moeves
Roger, I agree 100%. If it's easy enough to get the card I'll send off for it. I don't chase for the ARRL's certificate. I have a couple from the 80's and 90's couple DXCC's WAS WAZ... Truthfully I can't even remember...I don't think I even have 160 DXCC from ARRL. I know I have worked eno

Re: Topband: Cheating etc

2020-02-14 Thread Michael Walker
To put it simply You are only cheating yourself. It is not up to me to control other adults. Mike va3mw On Fri, Feb 14, 2020 at 6:43 AM Roger Kennedy wrote: > > Personally, I don't really care what anyone else does ! > > I achieved DXCC on 160m many years ago . . . and stopped even counting

Topband: Cheating etc

2020-02-14 Thread Roger Kennedy
Personally, I don't really care what anyone else does ! I achieved DXCC on 160m many years ago . . . and stopped even counting new countries once I had worked over 200. (it used to be really hard, as so few Countries were licensed for Top Band, but these days almost everyone is) I KNOW I worke

Re: Topband: Cheating the system

2018-01-17 Thread Radio KH6O
John wrote: Just for being nosey, I ran the ft8 software last night before bed to see what I could see and boy, there were stations from all over the world on topband, happily working each other. 73John - M0ELS = John -- were those

Topband: cheating the system

2018-01-16 Thread John Randall via Topband
Well, I had to have a last last say did'nt I. In the latest February Edition of Practical Wireless magazine is an article on a diversity adapter, whereby one can connect your receiver to one ant port and say a websdtr or another receiver at your 2nd home to the other port and than adjust the con

Topband: Cheating the system

2018-01-15 Thread John Randall via Topband
My final thoughts on this is that perhaps one way around this problem is to allow websdr qso's via designated websdr sites only for the award chasers and then to penalize them to "try and even the scorecard".Any qso made via other websdr's will not be validated. Maybe its a start ! Anyway or eit

Re: Topband: cheating

2018-01-15 Thread Cecil Acuff
Well that was a lot of help Steve You can crawl back under your rock now... Cecil K5DL Sent using recycled electrons. > On Jan 15, 2018, at 9:23 PM, STEVE DANIEL wrote: > > Guy. You did it the "hard" way did you? I have been a ham and DXer since 1973 > and have always encountered people

Re: Topband: cheating

2018-01-15 Thread STEVE DANIEL
Guy. You did it the "hard" way did you? I have been a ham and DXer since 1973 and have always encountered people like you. "You don't know how hard it was when I was your age. You have no idea how hard it was to work DX back then" Blah Blah Blah. It was BS then and it is BS now. The only thing t

Re: Topband: cheating

2018-01-15 Thread JL PFIRMAN
well said Guy,you hit a home run with the bases loaded! thank you 73 Jim W3TO > On January 15, 2018 at 7:28 PM Guy Olinger K2AV wrote: > > > With apologies to Tree, who has asked that this subject be dropped... > > The question of the effect of a remote receiver or receivers has > already been de

Re: Topband: cheating

2018-01-15 Thread Guy Olinger K2AV
With apologies to Tree, who has asked that this subject be dropped... The question of the effect of a remote receiver or receivers has already been dealt with by some contest organizers needing clarity and consistency using current actual technical possibilities while retaining the flavor and char

Re: Topband: cheating

2018-01-15 Thread Peter Voelpel
. Januar 2018 20:48 To: topband@contesting.com Subject: Re: Topband: cheating Read: http://www.arrl.org/dxcc-rules Section I. Basic Rules, #9 ... 9. Station Location and Boundary: a) All stations used to make contacts for a specific DXCC award must be located within the same DXCC entity. b) All

Topband: cheating

2018-01-15 Thread DXer
I may be missing something here. The way I interpret the excerpt below is that it's ok to use remote stations, within the same DXCC entity or outside of it. 'Station' here meaning TX and RX together, or up to 500 meters apart. I would add that the remote, in addition to being legally licensed, mus

Re: Topband: cheating

2018-01-15 Thread terry burge
; > > # - > > > -Original Message- > From: Topband [mailto:topband-boun...@contesting.com &g

Re: Topband: cheating

2018-01-15 Thread Lloyd - N9LB
a great local club project if legalized by ARRL. 73 Lloyd - N9LB - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -Original Message- From: Topband [mailto:topband-boun...@contesting.com] On Behalf Of Steve Daniel Sent: Monday, January 15, 2018 1:32 PM To: topband@contesting.com

Re: Topband: cheating

2018-01-15 Thread Steve Daniel
John, is the use of a remote receiver not allowed for DXCC? I don’t believe it is prohibited. I ask because your use of the word “cheating” suggests that it is. Is that what you are saying? Steve Daniel NN4T Sent from my iPhone > On Jan 15, 2018, at 12:31 PM, John Randall via Topband > wrote:

Topband: cheating

2018-01-15 Thread John Randall via Topband
Although I have never chased awards, I too am shocked at how easy it has become for those so inclined to cheat the system, but not only the system ,but themselves as well. Ofcourse not everyone will cheat but perhaps what we should be discussing is how to detect those who do cheat. Perhaps a DIY