Topband: A "valid" QSO????

2015-12-27 Thread James Rodenkirch
Jim K9YC wrote, "A valid contact is the exchange of callsigns and one additional piece of information, followed by acknowledgement by both stations. When running QRP at the limits of propagation, that exchange can take a while." Where would one find official documentation to support that

Re: Topband: A "valid" QSO????

2015-12-27 Thread James Rodenkirch
es Rodenkirch Cc: Top Band Contesting Subject: Re: Topband: A "valid" QSO Ahem... some notable contests require more than one additional piece of information. And the acknowledgement of which K9YC speaks can vary greatly depending on context and ham. Many contests involve an exch

Re: Topband: A "valid" QSO????

2015-12-27 Thread Jorge Diez CX6VM
; topband@contesting.com > > > > From: Jorge Diez - CX6VM <cx6vm.jo...@gmail.com> > Sent: Sunday, December 27, 2015 7:33 AM > To: James Rodenkirch > Subject: Re: Topband: A "valid" QSO > > Yesterday, a USA station worked me on the Stew Perry. But did

Re: Topband: A "valid" QSO????

2015-12-27 Thread Ed Sawyer
When did this become the QRP reflector? There has to be some better place for this expanding and off topic dialog than here. 73 Ed N1UR _ Topband Reflector Archives - http://www.contesting.com/_topband

Re: Topband: A "valid" QSO????

2015-12-27 Thread Dave Clouser
___ From: "James Rodenkirch" <rodenkirch_...@msn.com> To: w...@w5zn.org Cc: "Top Band Contesting" <topband@contesting.com> Sent: Sunday, December 27, 2015 8:21:05 AM Subject: Re: Topband: A "valid" QSO I believe the gentlemen I conversed

Re: Topband: A "valid" QSO????

2015-12-27 Thread Jim Brown
On Sun,12/27/2015 6:21 AM, James Rodenkirch wrote: I believe the gentlemen I conversed with would qualify as holding a position, Joel. Joel is a Past President of ARRL and a very active operator. I suspect that he knows what he's talking about. :) The definition I've cited is published and

Re: Topband: A "valid" QSO????

2015-12-27 Thread Tim Shoppa
Ahem... some notable contests require more than one additional piece of information. And the acknowledgement of which K9YC speaks can vary greatly depending on context and ham. Many contests involve an exchange that depends on power level at least a little. e.g. DX side in ARRL DX, it can

Re: Topband: A "valid" QSO????

2015-12-27 Thread Roger D Johnson
In these days of deregulation, a QSO can be whatever you want it to be. Operating another station using your callsign, having another ham make the contact for you or even on a chat room where little or nothing is actually exchanged on the air. 73, Roger _ Topband Reflector

Re: Topband: A "valid" QSO????

2015-12-27 Thread nn4t
James Rodenkirch" <rodenkirch_...@msn.com> To: w...@w5zn.org Cc: "Top Band Contesting" <topband@contesting.com> Sent: Sunday, December 27, 2015 8:21:05 AM Subject: Re: Topband: A "valid" QSO I believe the gentlemen I conversed with would qualify as hold

Re: Topband: A "valid" QSO????

2015-12-27 Thread Tim Shoppa
CX6VM <cx6vm.jo...@gmail.com> > > Sent: Sunday, December 27, 2015 7:33 AM > > To: James Rodenkirch > > Subject: Re: Topband: A "valid" QSO > > > > Yesterday, a USA station worked me on the Stew Perry. But didnt send me > his grid locator. I asked him s

Re: Topband: A "valid" QSO????

2015-12-27 Thread Jorge Diez CX6VM
James Rodenkirch <rodenkirch_...@msn.com> >> > escribió: >> > >> > >> > Jorge - I'm unsure about that one...ask everyone else - send your question >> > to topband@contesting.com >> > >> > >> > >> > From: Jorge Diez - C

Re: Topband: A "valid" QSO????

2015-12-27 Thread VE3FH
As the song goes, it's sad but true... HNY Julio VE3FH Sent from Yahoo Mail on Android _ Topband Reflector Archives - http://www.contesting.com/_topband

Re: Topband: A "valid" QSO????

2015-12-27 Thread James Rodenkirch
referring to a every day, garden variety QSO - not a contest-related Q. From: Joel Harrison <w...@w5zn.org> Sent: Sunday, December 27, 2015 5:19 AM To: James Rodenkirch Cc: Top Band Contesting Subject: Re: Topband: A "valid" QSO

Re: Topband: A "valid" QSO????

2015-12-27 Thread Joel Harrison
I would be very interested to know "who" at ARRL HQ told you than and holds that position! Is it someone in a position to render an "ARRL position"? I have always been told, have understood and followed the same position Jim has so I'm just curious if there was a "change" somewhere along the way