Re: Topband: Aluminium roof vs antenna performance

2013-10-20 Thread Riccardo Negro
Grant, tnx also to you. I think you highlight the very critical point; electrical connectivity along panels is likely to change along time and could randomly impact the pattern/SWR of nearby antennas. I think I will opt for a neutral (no aluminium) roof: I'll miss a good ground for a roof mounted v

Re: Topband: Aluminium roof vs antenna performance

2013-10-20 Thread Riccardo Negro
Jim, tnx for sharing your direct experience. Best 73 de Rik, IK2CAW 2013/10/18 Jim Bennett > Rik - > > Last year we replaced the 20+ year old roof on our house. It was made of > treated cedar "shake boards", with simple tar paper and plywood underneath. > My antennas consist of (1) 26.8 meter

Re: Topband: Aluminium roof vs antenna performance

2013-10-18 Thread Grant Saviers
I had a 40m and 80m top loaded vertical on galvanized steel roofs. The 80m was outstanding for DX and the 40m so-so since the roof was not well bonded electrically. IMO, unless you can insure electrical connectivity along the panel seams there will be no advantage to the foil. You would proba

Re: Topband: Aluminium roof vs antenna performance

2013-10-18 Thread Jim Bennett
Rik - Last year we replaced the 20+ year old roof on our house. It was made of treated cedar "shake boards", with simple tar paper and plywood underneath. My antennas consist of (1) 26.8 meter long doublet fed with 450 ohm ladder line, (2) 80 meter Inverted L, (3) 160 meter Inverted L, (4) 5/4

Topband: Aluminium roof vs antenna performance

2013-10-18 Thread Riccardo Negro
Hi all, tomorrow I must decide which type of insulating system to be used under the tiles of my new roof. Roof's structure is classic wooden and total surface is 220 square meters. Since there will be several antennas for 80 / 160 sorrounding the house I am wondering if using insulating panels (pol