Re: Topband: An oddball question about a BOG.

2019-08-25 Thread K4SAV
The comments in your first paragraph are very confusing, mixing up information on different antennas, old or proposed, and parts data, without clearly distinguishing what each comment refers to. I doubt that anyone will be able to sort that out unless they went thru the thread on QRZ. https:/

Re: Topband: An oddball question about a BOG.

2019-08-25 Thread Mikek
I have never modelled an inductively-loaded Beverage, but my intuition is that it will not perform any better than an unloaded wire of the same physical length.   I haven't modeled for 10 years and even then I was in the dark.  I started on this quest when I saw this W8JI page about inductively

Re: Topband: An oddball question about a BOG.

2019-08-24 Thread Grant Saviers
ZL3IX I think by accident had a fence with a break in it. My not working Beverage was 4'up over a continuous welded wire fence. Then some NEC2 modeling of a 600' Beverage 6' above a continuous 3 wire (wires at 2,3, & 4') barb wire fence, showed poor F/B. Mine was worse over the welded 6"x 6"

Re: Topband: An oddball question about a BOG.

2019-08-24 Thread Greg - ZL3IX
My own experience is that a fence does not degrade the Bev pattern too much as long as the Bev is sufficiently high above the fence wire. I mount my wires about 3 m above the fence. I have never modelled an inductively-loaded Beverage, but my intuition is that it will not perform any better th

Re: Topband: An oddball question about a BOG.

2019-08-24 Thread Mike Waters
As long as the fence is pointed in the right direction. :-) www.w0btu.com/Beverage_antennas.html#Misc_Beverage_antenna_notes On this page, there are some links to ZL3IX (?) experiences with his Beverages mounted at different heights above metal fences. 73, Mike www.w0btu.com On Sat, Aug 24, 201

Re: Topband: An oddball question about a BOG.

2019-08-24 Thread Chuck Dietz
And, by the way, K5GN and W5KU report that their Beverage above a barbed wire fence is the BEST Beverage at their place. Chuck W5PR On Sat, Aug 24, 2019 at 12:41 PM Chuck Dietz wrote: > I seem to remember someone saying the modelling programs are unreliable > when a wire is close to the ground.

Re: Topband: An oddball question about a BOG.

2019-08-24 Thread Mike Waters
Good point, Chuck! You are absolutely right. I would have modeled it above the ground, at least at first. 73, Mike www.w0btu.com On Sat, Aug 24, 2019, 12:41 PM Chuck Dietz wrote: > I seem to remember someone saying the modelling programs are unreliable > when a wire is close to the ground. Also

Re: Topband: An oddball question about a BOG.

2019-08-24 Thread Chuck Dietz
I seem to remember someone saying the modelling programs are unreliable when a wire is close to the ground. Also, there is really no way to model the properties of "ground." It can vary in just a few feet and the moisture content varies from day to day. I think this is a "try it" kind of antenna. R

Re: Topband: An oddball question about a BOG.

2019-08-24 Thread Mikek
 The trick is to take the dc control winding and it's inductance out of the antenna circuit, which I think can be done with a large bypass capacitor. Here's a simple drawing. The BOG goes to antenna in, through the .47uF cap (Xc=.67ohms at 500kHz, 0.1 ohm at 4Mhz) through variable inductor,

Re: Topband: An oddball question about a BOG.

2019-08-24 Thread Mike Waters
The only way to predict the RDF and pattern is by modeling it. I don't know of anyone who has done this. I have a few of my .ez Beverage models in w0btu.com/files/ as a starting point, but I don't think that I uploaded everything there. There are free antenna modeling programs out there. I have on

Topband: An oddball question about a BOG.

2019-08-24 Thread Mikek
But what did you mean by "proper pattern"? I should have said, the best pattern that adjusting the Inductive loads will provide. Yes, I understand the pattern changes with frequency. What I want to do is inductively load the antenna, so it will have the same pattern as if we increased the l

Re: Topband: An oddball question about a BOG.

2019-08-23 Thread Grant Saviers
Lots of questions, maybe a little bit of useful answers from me. First, I doubt there is any BOG that will cover 8 octaves with a useful pattern. Unobtanium, IMO. Second, your question did cause me to investigate improving the RDF of a 240' BOG which is on my to try list. So using EZNEC/Pro

Re: Topband: An oddball question about a BOG.

2019-08-23 Thread Mike Waters
Thank you for asking this, because I have always been fascinated with the concept of loaded Beverages (either BOGs or shortened overhead). But what did you mean by "proper pattern"? I assume that you mean "usable pattern" and that realize that the pattern will change with frequency. See for yourse

Topband: An oddball question about a BOG.

2019-08-23 Thread Mikek
 I want a BOG that will have a proper pattern over 500kHz to 4Mhz.  As I understand it, "loaded Beverages show increased directivity because velocity of propagation along the antenna is /*decreased*/." I assume that is for antennas that are shorter than what is required for that frequency. I