Re: [tor-dev] tor relay process health data for operators (controlport)

2020-11-16 Thread nusenu
I've put this thread into a new ticket: "provide relay health prometheus metrics via MetricsPort/MetricsSocket" https://gitlab.torproject.org/tpo/core/tor/-/issues/40194 ___ tor-dev mailing list tor-dev@lists.torproject.org https://lists.torproject.org/

Re: [tor-dev] tor relay process health data for operators (controlport)

2019-07-30 Thread nusenu
nusenu: > Hi, > > every now and then I'm in contact with relay operators > about the "health" of their relays. > Following these 1:1 discussions and the discussion on tor-relays@ > I'd like to rise two issues with you (the developers) with the goal > to help improve relay operations and end user

Re: [tor-dev] tor relay process health data for operators (controlport)

2019-02-05 Thread Iain Learmonth
Hi All, On 04/02/2019 06:35, teor wrote: > If we add enough noise to protect most users, then we will have privacy by > design. I would argue that noise does not help here, as we would have to add enough noise to protect against a guard discovery attack, which is too much noise for the stats to

Re: [tor-dev] tor relay process health data for operators (controlport)

2019-02-03 Thread teor
On February 3, 2019 10:19:00 PM UTC, nusenu wrote: >> Thanks for this email. I exporting more metrics on the control port >is a >> great idea. I wanted to have that for a while > >Great to hear that so we have a realistic chance it >gets actually implemented :) > > >> There are safety questions

Re: [tor-dev] tor relay process health data for operators (controlport)

2019-02-03 Thread nusenu
> Thanks for this email. I exporting more metrics on the control port is a > great idea. I wanted to have that for a while Great to hear that so we have a realistic chance it gets actually implemented :) > There are safety questions to ask ourselves here before blindly > exporting many stats.

Re: [tor-dev] tor relay process health data for operators (controlport)

2019-02-03 Thread David Goulet
On 03 Feb (00:24:00), nusenu wrote: > Hi, Hello nusenu, Thanks for this email. I exporting more metrics on the control port is a great idea. I wanted to have that for a while so quite happy you started rolling the ball :). There are safety questions to ask ourselves here before blindly exporting

Re: [tor-dev] tor relay process health data for operators (controlport)

2019-02-02 Thread grarpamp
All sorts of statistical counters could be useful to graph from some API... a control port stats dump in something like var=value, a BSD sysctl text format, and even up to a proper SNMP port which many graphers already speak. Logging isn't really the right place for such things, unless they've rea

[tor-dev] tor relay process health data for operators (controlport)

2019-02-02 Thread nusenu
Hi, every now and then I'm in contact with relay operators about the "health" of their relays. Following these 1:1 discussions and the discussion on tor-relays@ I'd like to rise two issues with you (the developers) with the goal to help improve relay operations and end user experience in the long