Re: [tor-relays] BadExit: Rerouting exit relays detected (1) 45.63.11.98

2020-10-11 Thread nusenu
Thanks for the report, I have forwarded it for removal. li...@for-privacy.net: > Wtf, this exit has addresses that do not belong to it! > https://metrics.torproject.org/rs.html#details/385527185E26937D05E0933DD29FF1699056CAF3 Yes, rerouting exit traffic is a practice we have observed in the past.

Re: [tor-relays] BadExit: Rerouting exit relays detected (1) 45.63.11.98

2020-10-11 Thread Mike Perry
On 10/11/20 10:20 AM, nusenu wrote: > Thanks for the report, I have forwarded it for removal. > > li...@for-privacy.net: >> Wtf, this exit has addresses that do not belong to it! >> https://metrics.torproject.org/rs.html#details/385527185E26937D05E0933DD29FF1699056CAF3 > > Yes, rerouting exit t

Re: [tor-relays] BadExit: Rerouting exit relays detected (1) 45.63.11.98

2020-10-11 Thread nusenu
> I am losing patience with the "let's play nice and let exit IP addresses > be predictable" model... We are not being treated well by the banhammer > brigade, and it might be time to flip some tables. I would not call > simply using a different exit IP than your relay's OR port a bad exit. I'm no

Re: [tor-relays] BadExit: Rerouting exit relays detected (1) 45.63.11.98

2020-10-11 Thread Mike Perry
On 10/11/20 1:17 PM, nusenu wrote: >> I am losing patience with the "let's play nice and let exit IP addresses >> be predictable" model... We are not being treated well by the banhammer >> brigade, and it might be time to flip some tables. I would not call >> simply using a different exit IP than y

Re: [tor-relays] BadExit: Rerouting exit relays detected (1) 45.63.11.98

2020-10-11 Thread Roger Dingledine
On Sun, Oct 11, 2020 at 01:39:17PM -0500, Mike Perry wrote: > > I believe I can tell rerouting exits from exits having distinct IPs for > > inbound and outbound connections - in most cases. > > Are your scanners available for others to run? I understand that it is a > risk that making them public

Re: [tor-relays] BadExit: Rerouting exit relays detected (1) 45.63.11.98

2020-10-11 Thread lists
On 11.10.2020 22:41, Roger Dingledine wrote: Right, in this particular case, we already run a scanner which provides public output: it's the tordnsel scanner, and check out https://check.torproject.org/exit-addresses Damn it, the boy was hardworking. ExitNode 385527185E26937D05E0933DD29FF1699

Re: [tor-relays] BadExit: Rerouting exit relays detected (1) 45.63.11.98

2020-10-12 Thread niftybunny
Just woke up. So, whats wrong with some of my relays in this list? nifty > On 12. Oct 2020, at 00:13, li...@for-privacy.net wrote: > > On 11.10.2020 22:41, Roger Dingledine wrote: > >> Right, in this particular case, we already run a scanner which provides >> public output: it's the tordnsel sc

Re: [tor-relays] BadExit: Rerouting exit relays detected (1) 45.63.11.98

2020-10-12 Thread Dr Gerard Bulger
- From: tor-relays On Behalf Of li...@for-privacy.net Sent: 11 October 2020 23:13 To: tor-relays@lists.torproject.org Subject: Re: [tor-relays] BadExit: Rerouting exit relays detected (1) 45.63.11.98 On 11.10.2020 22:41, Roger Dingledine wrote: > Right, in this particular case, we already

Re: [tor-relays] BadExit: Rerouting exit relays detected (1) 45.63.11.98

2020-10-12 Thread nusenu
niftybunny: > Just woke up. So, whats wrong with some of my relays in this list? some "exit" relay routed its traffic back into tor by using a tor client. That tor client used exit relays - yours were among them. So nothing wrong on your side. signature.asc Description: OpenPGP digital sig

Re: [tor-relays] BadExit: Rerouting exit relays detected (1) 45.63.11.98

2020-10-12 Thread nusenu
Dr Gerard Bulger: > Torrc allows you to exit from a different IP. I thought it a good > idea to stop arbitrary blocking of the advertised Tor exit IP, the > captchas and blacklists that tor users suffer. When IPv6 implemented > fully we have a wide range of IPs to send from on each server. > >

Re: [tor-relays] BadExit: Rerouting exit relays detected (1) 45.63.11.98

2020-10-14 Thread lists
On 12.10.2020 15:05, Dr Gerard Bulger wrote: Torrc allows you to exit from a different IP. I thought it a good idea to stop arbitrary blocking of the advertised Tor exit IP, the captchas and blacklists that tor users suffer. When IPv6 implemented fully we have a wide range of IPs to send from on