Re: [tor-relays] uptime "algorithm"

2015-12-15 Thread Tim Wilson-Brown - teor
> On 15 Dec 2015, at 13:12, Nima Fatemi wrote: > > Roger Dingledine: >> We should somehow teach everybody that losing their flags for a few days >> is totally fine and normal, and even something to be proud of because >> you took a useful step at keeping your Tor relay safe and secure > > Maybe

Re: [tor-relays] uptime "algorithm"

2015-12-14 Thread Nima Fatemi
Roger Dingledine: > We should somehow teach everybody that losing their flags for a few days > is totally fine and normal, and even something to be proud of because > you took a useful step at keeping your Tor relay safe and secure Maybe we should introduce a new flag for the relays that are runn

Re: [tor-relays] uptime "algorithm"

2015-12-14 Thread Green Dream
I'm not sure why operators care so much about the HSDir flag. It naturally comes and goes. Try not worry about it. :) I've noticed that it can take 30+ minutes after a version upgrade before the directory service on my nodes is fully responsive again [1]. I'm not entirely sure what's happening in

Re: [tor-relays] uptime "algorithm"

2015-12-14 Thread Roger Dingledine
On Mon, Dec 14, 2015 at 08:14:12PM +0100, Logforme wrote: > Can't see why, for example the Debian /etc/init.d/tor script, couldn't > send tor a flag telling it that this is a restart, causing tor to > save/restore its uptime information. Yes, this would be possible. > Circuits auto-reconnect if t

Re: [tor-relays] uptime "algorithm"

2015-12-14 Thread Logforme
On 2015-12-14 19:12, Dr. Who wrote: > Wouldn't it be better to monitor the reason for a drop in uptime? In > case at the same time a restart occurs the version increases it might be > given the HSdir flag again? > Can't see why, for example the Debian /etc/init.d/tor script, couldn't send tor a fla

[tor-relays] uptime "algorithm"

2015-12-14 Thread Dr. Who
As far as understand it is the flag HSdir given to nodes with a fast enough connection and a long enough uptime. If I keep my tor relay version always up to the current stable version I sometimes do have to restart the process. So I get a drop in my uptime and loose the HSdir flag for several days