Re: [Trisquel-users] Any plans to dump systemd ?

2018-04-17 Thread calmstorm
I would say Parabola is very easy to break though even if you are doing all the updates upgrades, etc... Hyperbola though doesn't have a graphical install yet... so that is also complicated. Devuan however is childs play for me. :) Still, I prefer Hyperbola any day of the week.

Re: [Trisquel-users] Any plans to dump systemd ?

2018-04-16 Thread hd-scania
If Patrick is ok to a rolling system Parabola/OpenRC is also recommended to him that’s rolling and nosystemd, otherwise please stick to Devuan and Hyperbola those are LTS and nosystemd. I use both of Parabola/OpenRC, Devuan, Hyperbola which I’m easy going alongside rolling and LTS systems.

Re: [Trisquel-users] Any plans to dump systemd ?

2018-04-16 Thread hd-scania
I need to here remind Patrick once if you dnt want systemd you need to instead install Parabola, Devuan, Hyperbola, which I need to admit that systemd is quite complicated to config, with Parabola, Devuan, Hyperbola you will have a simple and modern init system named OpenRC under FreeBSD

Re: [Trisquel-users] Any plans to dump systemd ?

2018-04-16 Thread dahunt
My concern is that Uruk may not get cirtified, it's Trisquel with a slightly different ui.

Re: [Trisquel-users] Any plans to dump systemd ?

2018-04-16 Thread arod-gnu
Jodiendo la bandera la puso ahí porque me gustó la calavera. No del PIP son unos cobardes vendidos. Nacionalista sangre o libertad

Re: [Trisquel-users] Any plans to dump systemd ?

2018-04-16 Thread arod-gnu
Freenix applied back in March 1, 2016 but were denied because the first name was similar to Slackware. The first name was FreeSlack. So they changed the name and they are waiting for the approval. They are still under the review process. That information was posted on their forum.

Re: [Trisquel-users] Any plans to dump systemd ?

2018-04-16 Thread strypey
Off-topic, but I notice there are now a number of libre distros that aren't in the FSF list, including FreeNix and ConnochaetOS mentioned here, as well as Uruk, Hyperbola, and Heads: https://www.gnu.org/distros/free-distros.html Is this because they don't meet the criteria, or because the

Re: [Trisquel-users] Any plans to dump systemd ?

2018-04-16 Thread jodiendo
GNU-BORICUA QUE ES ESO? LA CABEZA CALABERA DE TU ICONO! PREFIERO la banderita pipiola! LOL\ nO LO SUENES TAN ALTO EL DISPARATE PIPIOLO! lol que viva la estadidad 51!!

Re: [Trisquel-users] Any plans to dump systemd ?

2018-04-15 Thread superbyelich
There is also ConnochaetOS which is supposed to be a liberated Slackware/Salix https://connochaetos.org/wiki/home

Re: [Trisquel-users] Any plans to dump systemd ?

2018-04-15 Thread Mason Hock
> Devuan actually booted faster on a 20 year old > libreboot laptop. for me also. (X200) The X200 is 10 years old, not 20. The X60 is 12 years old, and it has worked fine for me both with Upstart on Trisquel 7 and systemd on Trisquel 8. I haven't tried any other init systems, although I'm

Re: [Trisquel-users] Any plans to dump systemd ?

2018-04-15 Thread calmstorm
No, FreeNix is a good idea.

Re: [Trisquel-users] Any plans to dump systemd ?

2018-04-15 Thread Patrick
I am mixed up. What is biased? FreeNix? It seems like a good idea...

Re: [Trisquel-users] Any plans to dump systemd ?

2018-04-15 Thread calmstorm
I have too, Devuan actually booted faster on a 20 year old libreboot laptop. for me also. (X200) I am hesitant to say more given the furher has many servants here at this point. I would prefer not to start another thread war over this, but yeah, I highly doubt its worth it.

Re: [Trisquel-users] Any plans to dump systemd ?

2018-04-15 Thread calmstorm
This feels too biased for me. Sometimes people do after all, try to save face by showing faultly information. I could be wrong of course, but yeah... don't trust it myself.

Re: [Trisquel-users] Any plans to dump systemd ?

2018-04-15 Thread arod-gnu
You can try Freenix (used to be FreeSlack) if you want a libre-sytem and systemd free. However, you have to comfortable dealing with a package manager that do not resolve dependencies.

Re: [Trisquel-users] Any plans to dump systemd ?

2018-02-26 Thread calmstorm
I suppose they might have made improvements since I learned of that tidbit, The only thing is, people should be able to switch init systems if they want on debian. And, some people want to do that and others are willing to do the work. Though I have witnessed first hand how hard it is, to

Re: [Trisquel-users] Any plans to dump systemd ?

2018-02-26 Thread strypey
BTW for anyone interested, this forum has already discussed the systemd wars in some details here: https://trisquel.info/en/comment/reply/23010/120736

Re: [Trisquel-users] Any plans to dump systemd ?

2018-02-26 Thread jodiendo
even do systemd IS PART AND APROVE BY fsf is not that popular as systenini is at the same time part of FSF IS ALL ABOUT DEVELOPERS PREFER USAGE. mE, iM STILL USE SYSTEINI BECAUSE ITS MORE SIMPLE AND IT TAKES LESS HARD DRIVE SPACE. CALL ME OLD FASHION, BUT LOOK AT THE CODE OF WRITING USING

Re: [Trisquel-users] Any plans to dump systemd ?

2018-02-26 Thread enduzzer
https://wiki.debian.org/Debate/initsystem/systemd#Why_Debian_should_default_to_systemd https://www.freedesktop.org/wiki/Software/systemd/ "Embedded systems benefit from speed improvements, shell-less design, ability to remove optional components, and lower memory footprint."

Re: [Trisquel-users] Any plans to dump systemd ?

2018-02-26 Thread fbits
>Yes, that is also my thought. I don't really understand why >debian switched to it, given that it isn't as good for older >hardware. meh... what can you do I suppose... I've used systemd on a 10 year old librebooted laptop and never had a problem. What is old hardware for you and what do you

Re: [Trisquel-users] Any plans to dump systemd ?

2018-02-25 Thread onpon4
> I don't really understand why debian switched to it, given that it isn't as good for older hardware. What init system you use has nothing to do with hardware support. That is the kernel (Linux) and the kernel alone. As for not understanding why Debian switched to it, perhaps that should

Re: [Trisquel-users] Any plans to dump systemd ?

2018-02-25 Thread calmstorm
Not everyone "Rejects systemd" as you say, some just don't want it while others are just frustrated that they have trouble escaping it. Yes there are people who are harsh on it, but the reverse is also true. Systemd people sometimes cannot stand people critcizing it. whether they support

Re: [Trisquel-users] Any plans to dump systemd ?

2018-02-25 Thread calmstorm
This I agree with 100% Hyperbola is although a bit strange, the best way forward if you want to recieve updates regularly without systemd being in the way. ps, they do have systemd dummy packages but no, they are not real. its only so you can use gnome 3 and other stuff. ;)

Re: [Trisquel-users] Any plans to dump systemd ?

2018-02-25 Thread calmstorm
"I see systemd as solving a problem I don't have." Yes, that is also my thought. I don't really understand why debian switched to it, given that it isn't as good for older hardware. meh... what can you do I suppose...

Re: [Trisquel-users] Any plans to dump systemd ?

2018-02-25 Thread strypey
Going by your forum picture, you don't look a day over 30 ;P

Re: [Trisquel-users] Any plans to dump systemd ?

2018-02-25 Thread strypey
Linked from the second of those links (and probably also the first), rebuttals to most of the major anti-systemd talking points, written by members of the systemd team: http://0pointer.de/blog/projects/the-biggest-myths.html I strongly recommend reading this in full, after reading a few

Re: [Trisquel-users] Any plans to dump systemd ?

2018-02-25 Thread Patrick
Hi Stypey WHy did I bring up lilo? That was dumb! Heee hee, I am 42 -Patrick

Re: [Trisquel-users] Any plans to dump systemd ?

2018-02-25 Thread strypey
There is a saying that any new technology that comes out before you turn 30 is the greatest thing ever, and any that comes out after you turn 30 is a pointless disruption and probably the end of civilization. Most of your post gives me the impression you are over 30 (as am I) ;-P >> Just to add

Re: [Trisquel-users] Any plans to dump systemd ?

2018-02-25 Thread Patrick
Hi, thanks for responding to my post. The other Trisquel member sent some good links. Just to add to the content of these, I see systemd as solving a problem I don't have. I am just a regular guy, I am open minded with most things and I don't think anyone would consider my social or

Re: [Trisquel-users] Any plans to dump systemd ?

2018-02-25 Thread studio
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Systemd#Criticism http://www.zdnet.com/article/linus-torvalds-and-others-on-linuxs-systemd/

Re: [Trisquel-users] Any plans to dump systemd ?

2018-02-25 Thread strypey
Patrick, I've read some commentary from both sides of the Systemd wars and its all seems like a storm in a teacup to me. The anti-Systemd rants often remind me of the the anti-GNU/ anti-FSF fanatics I find on sites like this: https://discuss.haiku-os.org/t/making-haiku-free-software/3084

Re: [Trisquel-users] Any plans to dump systemd ?

2018-02-25 Thread fbits
>I want to stay as pure unix as possible, or as possible as >this can be with Linux which is not pure unix either. GNU/Linux AMOF, GNU's Not Unix.

Re: [Trisquel-users] Any plans to dump systemd ?

2018-02-24 Thread alonivtsan
Hyperbola is the closest you will find to updated Trisquel without systemd - it is based on Arch (with Debian patches) without being a rolling release, so packages will usually only receive security updates and long term versions are preferred (e.g. a libre version of Iceweasel ESR as

Re: [Trisquel-users] Any plans to dump systemd ?

2018-02-24 Thread onpon4
Maybe, rather than rejecting systemd, you should ask systemd users for help on how to do the things you haven't figured out. To my knowledge, systemd includes the most advanced and efficient init system out there, and that's why the vast majority of distros have chosen to use it.

Re: [Trisquel-users] Any plans to dump systemd ?

2018-02-24 Thread Patrick
Hi Mason This is very helpful. I feel silly now but I thought that Trisquel has already made the switch to systemd. If I can buy myself another year to think this over, why not. I will re-install Trisquel and remain at 7 for as long as I can. In a years time there might also be an easy path

Re: [Trisquel-users] Any plans to dump systemd ?

2018-02-24 Thread Mason Hock
It seems that Trisquel does not generally remove or replace anything from Ubuntu unless it is proprietary or facilitates installing proprietary software. Since systemd is free software, it will probably be present in Trisquel as long as it is present in Ubuntu, starting with Trisquel 8. If

[Trisquel-users] Any plans to dump systemd ?

2018-02-24 Thread Patrick
Hi Everyone I have been using Trisquel since version 5. I have been very-very happy with the project. However I moved to Salix recently. The Slackware universe has not and will not adopt systemd. The FSF is not upset about systemd because it's free software. There might not be moral reasons