Re: [orca-list] [Kde-accessibility] Ubuntu Unity Desktop to go to Mir and QT

2013-07-24 Thread Frederik Gladhorn
Onsdag 24. juli 2013 12.08.32 skrev Alex Midence: > I'll create a virtual machine and begin testing before the month is up. Do > I need to have something like Fedora Rawhide or Ubuntu 13.10 to test in an > environment that will give you valuable data? No, any reasonalbly recent linux distro shoul

RE: [orca-list] VINUX-SUPPORT: RE: Ubuntu Unity Desktop to go to Mir and QT

2013-07-24 Thread Alex Midence
Hi, Luke, Just to be clear, I don't think and have never thought you were part of the problem. What I do think is that it sucks that you are the only one having to do all this work. They really should hire you some help. There is only so much one person can do and a11y is a big job. Apple has

Re: [Kde-accessibility] Ubuntu Unity Desktop to go to Mir and QT

2013-07-24 Thread Frederik Gladhorn
Hello, On Tuesday 23. July 2013 13.23.47 Alex Midence wrote: > Hi, all, > > > > It looks like Ubuntu's Unity desktop will be switching to QT/QML in the near > future. It looks like they'll be using QT5. Does anyone know the current > state of accessibility for qt5 or QML? We were all disappo

RE: [orca-list] VINUX-SUPPORT: RE: Ubuntu Unity Desktop to go to Mir and QT

2013-07-24 Thread Alex Midence
The way accessibility was approached by Google is pretty smart. Eyes-free they call it implying that someone who can see might choose to operate their smartphone without using their vision. This is so they can keep their eyes on the road, for instance. Thus, it became something valuable to inclu

Re: [orca-list] VINUX-SUPPORT: RE: Ubuntu Unity Desktop to go to Mir and QT

2013-07-24 Thread Al Sten-Clanton
It strikes me that, from the perspective you're describing, a "viable product" apparently does not include accessibility as a matter of course. (I'm not saying that's your own view, but only that this is the view you describe--all too well and concisely.) Until our access needs are deemed equa

RE: [orca-list] [Kde-accessibility] Ubuntu Unity Desktop to go to Mir and QT

2013-07-24 Thread Alex Midence
I'll create a virtual machine and begin testing before the month is up. Do I need to have something like Fedora Rawhide or Ubuntu 13.10 to test in an environment that will give you valuable data? Alex M -Original Message- From: Frederik Gladhorn [mailto:frede...@gladhorn.de] Sent: We

Re: [orca-list] Ubuntu Unity Desktop to go to Mir and QT

2013-07-24 Thread Jean-Philippe MENGUAL
Hi, On mardi 23 juil. 2013 à 15:38:37 (-0500), Christopher Chaltain wrote: > In Unity, you can use the alt+f10 key to bring up the global menus, > arrow left to get to the devices pull down and then down arrow to > shutdown. Excellent! Thanks! it works fine. But given there's a desktop, is it pos

RE: [orca-list] [Kde-accessibility] Ubuntu Unity Desktop to go to Mir and QT

2013-07-24 Thread Alex Midence
Very true. The thing that I want to test is editable text areas in QT. That was the biggest problem I saw last year when I was trying out KDE. If you were in Kate or Kmail and there was some text you wanted to put in either because you were editing a file or filling out a form of some kind, Orca

Re: [orca-list] VINUX-SUPPORT: RE: Ubuntu Unity Desktop to go to Mir and QT

2013-07-24 Thread Jean-Philippe MENGUAL
Hi, Thanks Luke for this very interesting mail. I'm aware of accessibility issues in the modern free software world, and I try everyday to go on belfeving more success, even if I'm disappointed by recent GUI. But I go on trying to understand. You say that GNOME shell works fine today. I feel tha

RE: [orca-list] VINUX-SUPPORT: RE: Ubuntu Unity Desktop to go to Mir and QT

2013-07-24 Thread Alex Midence
I hadn't heard that one. I don't know how someone would have had a case against Apple since there was a largely accessible alternative in the form of Windows or Windows Mobile. All through my years growing up, Apple and inaccessible were more or less synonymous. I remember how pleasantly surpris

RE: [Kde-accessibility] Ubuntu Unity Desktop to go to Mir and QT

2013-07-24 Thread Alex Midence
Wonderful news! I certainly feel better for it. Thanks for all your hard work on qt-at-spi. Alex M From: Frederik Gladhorn [mailto:frede...@gladhorn.de] Sent: Wednesday, July 24, 2013 3:21 AM To: kde-accessibil...@kde.org Cc: Alex Midence; orca-l...@gnome.org; vinux-supp...@googlegr

Re: [orca-list] [Kde-accessibility] Ubuntu Unity Desktop to go to Mir and QT

2013-07-24 Thread Frederik Gladhorn
Onsdag 24. juli 2013 08.47.34 skrev Alex Midence: > Very true. The thing that I want to test is editable text areas in QT. > That was the biggest problem I saw last year when I was trying out KDE. If > you were in Kate or Kmail and there was some text you wanted to put in > either because you wer

Re: [orca-list] Ubuntu Unity Desktop to go to Mir and QT

2013-07-24 Thread Jean-Philippe MENGUAL
Hi, On mardi 23 juil. 2013 à 15:38:37 (-0500), Christopher Chaltain wrote: > In Unity, you can use the alt+f10 key to bring up the global menus, > arrow left to get to the devices pull down and then down arrow to > shutdown. Excellent! Thanks! it works fine. But given there's a desktop, is it pos

Re: [orca-list] VINUX-SUPPORT: RE: Ubuntu Unity Desktop to go to Mir and QT

2013-07-24 Thread Christopher Chaltain
I hadn't heard that Apple was actually sued. My understanding was that back when Windows had an accessible option through 3rd party screen readers and Apple had no screen reader at all that Apple was losing out to Microsoft, or at least had the potential to lose such deals, when selling system

Re: [orca-list] VINUX-SUPPORT: RE: Ubuntu Unity Desktop to go to Mir and QT

2013-07-24 Thread Christopher Chaltain
I agree. You also see this on all of the GPS apps which provide turn by turn spoken directions. True accessibility, for a blind user though, does need to go a bit beyond just what needs to be done for eyes free use. On 07/24/2013 03:24 PM, Alex Midence wrote: The way accessibility was approach

Re: [orca-list] VINUX-SUPPORT: RE: Ubuntu Unity Desktop to go to Mir and QT

2013-07-24 Thread Christopher Chaltain
I know you didn't say this, but Mark Shuttleworth and Jane Silver are aware that totally blind people can use computers and smart phones. I think you're right in that it's hard for any one to quantify their return on investment into accessibility, even a smart business man or woman. I'm not eve

Re: [orca-list] VINUX-SUPPORT: RE: Ubuntu Unity Desktop to go to Mir and QT

2013-07-24 Thread Krishnakant Mane
I think the issue here is the total mindset and also the fact that many so called smart business men don't realize the business they can generate out of accessibility. Firstly, there are those who don't *still* beleive that a totaly blind person like me can actually use a Phone, let alone a comp

Re: [orca-list] Ubuntu Unity Desktop to go to Mir and QT

2013-07-24 Thread Christopher Chaltain
I haven't done this myself, but since the Desktop is just a folder in your home directory, you can place symbolic links to applications you want to start into that folder. I did this just now with a link to /usr/lib/thunderbird/thunderbird.sh. On 07/24/2013 11:07 AM, Jean-Philippe MENGUAL wrot

Re: [orca-list] VINUX-SUPPORT: RE: Ubuntu Unity Desktop to go to Mir and QT

2013-07-24 Thread Christopher Chaltain
I agree accessibility should be baked in from the beginning. It's cheaper than bolting it on later, opens up more revenue streams, provides positive PR and so on. It's the law here in the US, and just the right thing to do. I wasn't speaking from my own opinion, but just echoing where I think t

Re: [orca-list] VINUX-SUPPORT: RE: Ubuntu Unity Desktop to go to Mir and QT

2013-07-24 Thread Christopher J Chaltain
I agree it's unfortunate that Luke is the only one working on Unity accessibility, but there is a big difference between Canonical and Apple or Google. Apple is the wealthiest company in the world. Google is also a large company and is also quite profitable. Apple and Google are already well es

Re: VINUX-SUPPORT: RE: [orca-list] [Kde-accessibility] Ubuntu Unity Desktop to go to Mir and QT

2013-07-24 Thread Krishnakant Mane
yeah, I had tryed as well and had the same problem. I think there could be some more things to test and if they are not fundamentally broke, then we are in for a happy surprise. I would be interested to see how Firefox works under this infra structure and how libre office works as well. Person

Re: [orca-list] [Kde-accessibility] Ubuntu Unity Desktop to go to Mir and QT

2013-07-24 Thread Krishnakant Mane
This essentially means we must try things pretty early on and start reporting bugs agressively. happy hacking. Krishnakant. On 07/24/2013 06:37 PM, Alex Midence wrote: Wonderful news! I certainly feel better for it. Thanks for all your hard work on qt-at-spi. Alex M From: Fred