Re: [Bug 105694] Re: Ubuntu should add user 'mpd' to audio group upon install

2007-04-11 Thread Sakumatti Luukkonen
On Wed, 2007-04-11 at 23:17 +, Lionel Porcheron wrote: > The reasons you give ("it is fixed" in feisty) should leads to status > "Fix released" and not "Rejected" ! See > https://wiki.ubuntu.com/Bugs/Responses for details. > > On edgy I can not reproduce this issue (a ffresh built chroot): > $

Re: [Bug 105694] Re: Ubuntu should add user 'mpd' to audio group upon install

2007-04-11 Thread Micah Cowan
Also: dpkg -l mpd (madison displays what packages are available, dpkg -l will display what package is installed). -- Ubuntu should add user 'mpd' to audio group upon install https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/105694 You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which

[Bug 105694] Re: Ubuntu should add user 'mpd' to audio group upon install

2007-04-11 Thread Lionel Porcheron
The reasons you give ("it is fixed" in feisty) should leads to status "Fix released" and not "Rejected" ! See https://wiki.ubuntu.com/Bugs/Responses for details. On edgy I can not reproduce this issue (a ffresh built chroot): $ id mpd uid=103(mpd) gid=29(audio) groups=29(audio) Could you precise

Re: [Bug 105694] Re: Ubuntu should add user 'mpd' to audio group upon install

2007-04-11 Thread Micah Cowan
>> Assignee: Scott Zawalski => Micah Cowan This happened entirely by accident; Scott and I apparently were editing this bug at the same time. I've left it up to him to decide who should remain the assignee. Sakumatti: > I am aware that the audio group doesn't own the audio files. The probl

[Bug 105694] Re: Ubuntu should add user 'mpd' to audio group upon install

2007-04-11 Thread Scott Zawalski
Since you are using edgy and feisty is going to be released this month I am rejecting this bug. Feisty handles this properly and it is unlikely that a fix will be backported to edgy. Thank you for your bug report. ** Changed in: mpd (Ubuntu) Status: Needs Info => Rejected -- Ubuntu shoul

Re: [Bug 105694] Re: Ubuntu should add user 'mpd' to audio group upon install

2007-04-11 Thread Sakumatti Luukkonen
On Wed, 2007-04-11 at 22:16 +, Micah Cowan wrote: > Hello, and thank you for submitting this bug report. > > The audio group isn't the group that owns audio files; it's the group > that has authorization to play sounds through the sound card. Since mpd > doesn't actually play any music, and mp

[Bug 105694] Re: Ubuntu should add user 'mpd' to audio group upon install

2007-04-11 Thread Lionel Porcheron
Micah you're wrong, mpd is playing the music and need access to audio devices. On a fresh feisty install I have: $ id mpd uid=110(mpd) gid=29(audio) groups=29(audio) As Skott said, we need to know which Ubuntu version and which mpd version you are using. -- Ubuntu should add user 'mpd' to audio

[Bug 105694] Re: Ubuntu should add user 'mpd' to audio group upon install

2007-04-11 Thread Scott Zawalski
Thank you for your bug report. Please provide the following information What version of Ubuntu are you using (dapper, edgy, feisty)? Package version (You can find this by looking in synaptic or tpying aptitude show in a terminal) ** Changed in: mpd (Ubuntu) Assignee: (unassigned) => Scott

[Bug 105694] Re: Ubuntu should add user 'mpd' to audio group upon install

2007-04-11 Thread Micah Cowan
Hello, and thank you for submitting this bug report. The audio group isn't the group that owns audio files; it's the group that has authorization to play sounds through the sound card. Since mpd doesn't actually play any music, and mpd-client should be run by (and therefore as) a real user that ha