[Bug 146737] Re: Ubuntu offers no "zero configuration network" or so (unlike Apple)

2008-06-02 Thread oss_test_launchpad
"Zero configuration" would mean that it requires "zero configuration", so you are wrong. This is btw. not against avahi or any other specific program but about a missing feature which could IMHO easily be implemented using technologies already shipping with Ubuntu. It is about configuration. Once

[Bug 146737] Re: Ubuntu offers no "zero configuration network" or so (unlike Apple)

2008-05-31 Thread Loye Young
Avahi implementation of zero configuration network is installed by default. Filer refuses to answer debugging questions from Avahi developer. ** Changed in: kdenetwork (Ubuntu) Status: New => Invalid -- Ubuntu offers no "zero configuration network" or so (unlike Apple) https://bugs.launch

[Bug 146737] Re: Ubuntu offers no "zero configuration network" or so (unlike Apple)

2008-05-31 Thread Loye Young
Bug report is both invalid and incomplete. Report is invalid because premise of bug that "Ubuntu offers no zero configuration network" is incorrect. Avahi is an implementation of zero configuration and ships with Ubuntu by default. Report is incomplete because filer refuses to answer debugging ques

[Bug 146737] Re: Ubuntu offers no "zero configuration network" or so (unlike Apple)

2008-05-31 Thread oss_test_launchpad
I understand that you feel strongly about this topic. I suppose this is the reason why you paste other people's e-mail adresses (which you have from launchpad's notification mail server) into this thread, making them subject to mail spamming, which I would regard as a lack of sensitivity for questi

Re: [Bug 146737] Re: Ubuntu offers no "zero configuration network" or so (unlike Apple)

2008-05-30 Thread Loye Young
>I am not a computer security specialist but I think there must be a way >of doing this, and doing this in such way that it is safe for the >system. There are several existing safe methods to transfer files between computers. The method you describe is not safe because any other computer connected

[Bug 146737] Re: Ubuntu offers no "zero configuration network" or so (unlike Apple)

2008-05-30 Thread oss_test_launchpad
I might add that connecting B and C via USB cable would probably be similarly acceptable for the average user. Maybe this solves some of the security issues you see. -- Ubuntu offers no "zero configuration network" or so (unlike Apple) https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/146737 You received this bug

[Bug 146737] Re: Ubuntu offers no "zero configuration network" or so (unlike Apple)

2008-05-30 Thread oss_test_launchpad
I am not a computer security specialist but I think there must be a way of doing this, and doing this in such way that it is safe for the system. I do not know what DHCP is. Neither do I know what NAT is. Neither does the average user know. Btw. for reasons of safety, I would greatly encourage th

Re: [Bug 146737] Re: Ubuntu offers no "zero configuration network" or so (unlike Apple)

2008-05-30 Thread Loye Young
> Application scenario: A works on his notebook B and wants to easily get > 1GB to his workplace desktop C. What he would expect would be the > following: > > - He connects B and C using an ethernet cable. > - C says: "Computer B has been connected to your computer. Do you > - want to allow the B t

[Bug 146737] Re: Ubuntu offers no "zero configuration network" or so (unlike Apple)

2008-05-30 Thread oss_test_launchpad
Maybe I put this wrong. I do not support any special program to solve this. All I am saying is that Ubuntu users, unlike Mac users, cannot just connect two computers with a cable and in this way get data from one computer to another. This would, however, be an important comfort feature. Applicatio

[Bug 146737] Re: Ubuntu offers no "zero configuration network" or so (unlike Apple)

2008-03-06 Thread Loye Young
This bug report should be marked as invalid because (i) zeroconf / avahi is already present, and (ii) it should be deprecated anyway. Avahi presents security risks and is rarely useful. >From a security standpoint, Avahi should be used only if (i) no computers are connected to the Internet at all,

[Bug 146737] Re: Ubuntu offers no "zero configuration network" or so (unlike Apple)

2008-02-03 Thread Sebastien Estienne
Using a twisted pair cable or a switch should make no difference. How are you testing ? zeroconf networking (aka bonjour) is basically 3 things: 1) automatically assigning an ip when no dhcp is available (169.254.0.0/16), this feature is also available on Windows, you can check that you have an

[Bug 146737] Re: Ubuntu offers no "zero configuration network" or so (unlike Apple)

2008-02-03 Thread Tormod Volden
** Changed in: avahi (Ubuntu) Sourcepackagename: gnome-network => avahi -- Ubuntu offers no "zero configuration network" or so (unlike Apple) https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/146737 You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is the bug contact for Ubuntu. --

[Bug 146737] Re: Ubuntu offers no "zero configuration network" or so (unlike Apple)

2007-10-03 Thread oss_test_launchpad
> what version of ubuntu is each machine running? Both Gutsy, always fully updated. > do they have avahi installed? (check for the avahi-daemon package). Yes. > have you made changes to the network settings? No. Just noted that I did not use a twisted pair cable. This does not change the issu

[Bug 146737] Re: Ubuntu offers no "zero configuration network" or so (unlike Apple)

2007-10-02 Thread sam tygier
i am sorry if i offended you. what version of ubuntu is each machine running? do they have avahi installed? (check for the avahi-daemon package). have you made changes to the network settings? please attach /etc/network/interfaces (please remove any WEP keys that it might have) how are the machi

[Bug 146737] Re: Ubuntu offers no "zero configuration network" or so (unlike Apple)

2007-10-02 Thread oss_test_launchpad
1.) Marking a bug report invalid FIRST and THEN asking what someone meant (see above) is rather inefficient, don't you think? Do you believe this method keeps people motivated to work on Ubuntu? 2.) It's fine to have avahi installed, but with not little power user knowledge I have not been able

[Bug 146737] Re: Ubuntu offers no "zero configuration network" or so (unlike Apple)

2007-10-02 Thread sam tygier
i am sorry to mark this invalid, but it is too vague and not really true. ubuntu comes with avahi installed by default, so if you connect too ubuntu computers together they choose ip address, and can resolve each other with hostname.local. see https://help.ubuntu.com/community/HowToZeroconf it is