[Bug 1865949] Re: nm-tray silently fails with bad wifi password; saves connection

2020-03-04 Thread Walter Lapchynski
This is not a limit of Ubuntu. It's a limit of the IEEE standard on WPA2. See here: https://serverfault.com/questions/164930/can-a-wpa-key-be-shorter-than-8-characters -- You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu. https://bugs.launc

[Bug 1865949] Re: nm-tray silently fails with bad wifi password; saves connection

2020-03-04 Thread MarkF
Good news. I found the problem. It's entirely related to passphrase length. - If I type a passphrase less than 8 characters long: I get the behavior I reported (it appears nothing happens, no activity indicator, no balloon error msg, nothing in the msg tray. But, the failed connection is saved as

[Bug 1865949] Re: nm-tray silently fails with bad wifi password; saves connection

2020-03-04 Thread Walter Lapchynski
> In an hour or two I will try 20200404. I'm hoping this is just a glitch in the copy I have Maybe it's because you're using Lubuntu in a time machine? XD Are you sure you have notifications on? There is an icon for it in the system tray. Unless you removed it or silenced it. The log output

[Bug 1865949] Re: nm-tray silently fails with bad wifi password; saves connection

2020-03-04 Thread MarkF
FYI: I booted 20200303 Lubuntu daily on a i7-2630QM 2.0ghz; NVIDIA GeForce GT540M 2GB; Intel Centrino 6230 (Dell XPS L502X laptop). It has the same behavior I reported in this bug. In an hour or two I will try 20200404. I'm hoping this is just a glitch in the copy I have (but, I did burn it to USB

[Bug 1865949] Re: nm-tray silently fails with bad wifi password; saves connection

2020-03-04 Thread MarkF
@Chris, can you be more specific about what you did to get the failure balloon? Did you left click nm-tray, click the non-hidden SSID, type a bad password? This bug report is a little confusing because that's what I reported. But, there's a lot of examples about it working differently if accessed

[Bug 1865949] Re: nm-tray silently fails with bad wifi password; saves connection

2020-03-03 Thread MarkF
@Chris, I did add the log info in #11 (one before yours). I do see a "connection established" balloon when I use the correct passphrase. But, I don't see a failure balloon when I use the wrong passphrase. I have to believe it's something screwy with my iso, how it was burned. Something that isn't

[Bug 1865949] Re: nm-tray silently fails with bad wifi password; saves connection

2020-03-03 Thread MarkF
I just booted Lubuntu 20200303 (same LiveUSB I've been testing throughout all this). I started journalctl. I then clicked nm-tray, clicked the access point, and this is what appeared: start Mar 04 07:02:44 lubuntu NetworkManager[1632]: [1583305364.9596] device (wlp4s0): Activa

[Bug 1865949] Re: nm-tray silently fails with bad wifi password; saves connection

2020-03-03 Thread Chris Guiver
I changed a wifi network to be not-hidden, booted sl510 again using current daily, and get balloons telling me 'lost.connection', or if deleted & enter the correct password 'connection.established', ie. exactly what Walter describes (where balloon=notification). On the discourse thread (https://d

[Bug 1865949] Re: nm-tray silently fails with bad wifi password; saves connection

2020-03-03 Thread Walter Lapchynski
I can add a new connection manually with the wrong password and it fails. The icon in the system tray changes to grey with three white horizontally-arranged dots and then returns to the grey rectangle with a white x in the lower right hand corner. A notification displays that the connection is lost

[Bug 1865949] Re: nm-tray silently fails with bad wifi password; saves connection

2020-03-03 Thread MarkF
I left click on nm-tray, choose my wifi access point, enter an incorrect passphrase. Maybe the difference is that you're using a hidden ssid, and have to go to network connections to get the job done? I'm doing the more normal(?) choice of available access points from nm-tray. I only right-click t

[Bug 1865949] Re: nm-tray silently fails with bad wifi password; saves connection

2020-03-03 Thread Chris Guiver
I also tried on and found them the same as sony ultracrap lenovo thinkpad sl510 (c2d-t6570, 2gb ram, i915) lenovo thinkpad x201 (i5-m520, 4gb, i915) Steps I do - Boot daily 'live' - right click `nm-tray` on panel select Edit.Connections - Network.Connections window appears. I click + to add - Sel

[Bug 1865949] Re: nm-tray silently fails with bad wifi password; saves connection

2020-03-03 Thread MarkF
FYI: I have a Ryzen 3 with intel wireless. I booted the Lubuntu 20200303 image on it. Same behavior. There's no progress or error message about being unable to connect. I don't know why my experience is different on 3 computers than you guys'. I've verified the iso checksum. The file-verification

[Bug 1865949] Re: nm-tray silently fails with bad wifi password; saves connection

2020-03-03 Thread MarkF
@Chris, I'm not having the same experience as you. I enter an invalid passphrase, nothing happens. No connection-lost msg. And, it saves the failed connection. The only msg I see is when I fix the password and it connects successfully. It doesn't appear to be machine dependent (although, both the

[Bug 1865949] Re: nm-tray silently fails with bad wifi password; saves connection

2020-03-03 Thread Chris Guiver
Thank you for taking the time to report this issue and helping to make Ubuntu better. I just tested the daily (20200303) on 'live' sony vaio ultrabook (i5-9400u, 4gb, intel haswell-ULT) and got a "Connection Lost" top right when an incorrect password was used (WPA2, hidden). The incorrect pass

[Bug 1865949] Re: nm-tray silently fails with bad wifi password; saves connection

2020-03-03 Thread MarkF
@Dan, I just tried the same 20200303 Lubuntu image on a Ryzen 5 machine. It had the same behavior as reported on the old Toshiba. I click on nm- tray, choose my wifi access point, enter an incorrect passphrase. Nothing happens. No message that the connection was attempted/failed. That access point

[Bug 1865949] Re: nm-tray silently fails with bad wifi password; saves connection

2020-03-03 Thread Dan Simmons
I tested this on a new daily install using the 20200303 install media. I never received a connection success message. I received a nm-tray message indicating the connection was lost to my wireless network every time I tried to connect using the wrong passphrase. As noted, I was able to delete the c

[Bug 1865949] Re: nm-tray silently fails with bad wifi password; saves connection

2020-03-03 Thread Dan Simmons
** Changed in: nm-tray (Ubuntu) Status: New => Invalid -- You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu. https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1865949 Title: nm-tray silently fails with bad wifi password; saves connection To manage

[Bug 1865949] Re: nm-tray silently fails with bad wifi password; saves connection

2020-03-03 Thread Ubuntu QA Website
This bug has been reported on the Ubuntu ISO testing tracker. A list of all reports related to this bug can be found here: http://iso.qa.ubuntu.com/qatracker/reports/bugs/1865949 ** Tags added: iso-testing -- You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is s