[Bug 1878682] Re: IPv6 not enabled by default

2020-05-29 Thread Ryan Harper
** Changed in: cloud-init (Ubuntu) Importance: Undecided => High ** Changed in: cloud-init (Ubuntu) Status: New => Triaged -- You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu. https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1878682 Title:

[Bug 1878682] Re: IPv6 not enabled by default

2020-05-29 Thread Ryan Harper
> Ryan, > > Thank you so much for taking the time to go over the constraints and > competing goals. It's always helpful to know what constituencies are > involved. Sure. > > > That said, I do think that cloud-init can make it easier to enable ipv6 > > where > > it's desired (but without having

[Bug 1878682] Re: IPv6 not enabled by default

2020-05-28 Thread Kevin Otte
Ryan, Thank you so much for taking the time to go over the constraints and competing goals. It's always helpful to know what constituencies are involved. > That said, I do think that cloud-init can make it easier to enable ipv6 where > it's desired (but without having to write your own network

[Bug 1878682] Re: IPv6 not enabled by default

2020-05-27 Thread Ryan Harper
Hi Kevin, > In the year 2020, IPv6 should be a first class citizen and I should not need > to provide additional config for it to work right. The issue here is not > that I can't find a workaround to make my scenarios work. The issue here is > that I should not need any such workarounds on a

[Bug 1878682] Re: IPv6 not enabled by default

2020-05-23 Thread Kevin Otte
> If you are not providing any network config to cloud-init, current the default fallback is to DHCP (ipv4) only This is precisely the bug I am reporting. > And for ipv6 config, I suspect you'll want to provide an netplan config with: In the year 2020, IPv6 should be a first class citizen and I

[Bug 1878682] Re: IPv6 not enabled by default

2020-05-21 Thread Ryan Harper
In your dual stack example, can you run cloud-init collect-logs and attach the created tarball? In particular the cloud-init.log and what, if any network configuration you're supplying in your NoCloud datasource. > This tells me that someone enabled dhcp4 but not dhcp6 for cloud-init. We >

[Bug 1878682] Re: IPv6 not enabled by default

2020-05-19 Thread Kevin Otte
Executive summary: I expected this test to go much differently. This bug should probably be "cloud-init does not wait for IPv6 config in dual- stack network" -- One of my initial tests was in my primary dual-stack network, and it also worked similar to your example. Excerpt from my deploy

[Bug 1878682] Re: IPv6 not enabled by default

2020-05-15 Thread Paride Legovini
Hi Kevin, I did some testing and ipv6 seems to work as expected for me. I did the following: 1. `virsh net-edit default` and added: to have IPv6 configured on virbr0. As the prefix is a /64 dnsmasq will automatically send router advertisements on the