[Bug 221550] Re: add a note for translators regarding loading linux kernel message

2008-06-30 Thread Launchpad Bug Tracker
This bug was fixed in the package gfxboot-theme-ubuntu - 0.6.3 --- gfxboot-theme-ubuntu (0.6.3) intrepid; urgency=low * Update language names from localechooser 2.03ubuntu1, adding Amharic and Marathi, adjusting the default locale for Esperanto, and fixing the localised

[Bug 221550] Re: add a note for translators regarding loading linux kernel message

2008-06-30 Thread Colin Watson
Fixed for my next upload by removing the progress bar along with that translatable string. ** Changed in: gfxboot-theme-ubuntu (Ubuntu) Assignee: (unassigned) = Colin Watson (kamion) Status: New = Fix Committed ** Changed in: gfxboot-theme-ubuntu (Ubuntu) Importance: Undecided =

[Bug 221550] Re: add a note for translators regarding loading linux kernel message

2008-04-25 Thread Thomas Thurman
I think possibly I didn't make myself clear. The situation is indeed as you describe. However, if it is legitimate to describe the whole OS as Linux, then a phrase equivalent to loading Linux's kernel in various languages is also legitimate, since the kernel is the kernel of the whole OS. If

[Bug 221550] Re: add a note for translators regarding loading linux kernel message

2008-04-25 Thread Przemysław Kulczycki
The official description is Ubuntu is a Linux-based operating system, not Ubuntu = Linux. http://www.ubuntu.com/aboutus/faq So let's stay with the official terminology, not community slang ;) -- add a note for translators regarding loading linux kernel message

[Bug 221550] Re: add a note for translators regarding loading linux kernel message

2008-04-25 Thread Thomas Thurman
FWIW, I think you can get either reading out of Ubuntu is a Linux-based operating system. If Linux is a kernel, Ubuntu is based around that kernel. If Linux is an entire OS, Ubuntu is a version of that entire OS, and is therefore based on it. Actually, I think the second reading is the more

[Bug 221550] Re: add a note for translators regarding loading linux kernel message

2008-04-25 Thread Colin Watson
Thomas (hi!): In context, I think simply reducing it to Loading kernel or even just Loading would be sufficient; I doubt that people really care about the detail here on the boot menu. In fact, I've previously speculated on removing this dialog altogether. It's the last thing that happens before

[Bug 221550] Re: add a note for translators regarding loading linux kernel message

2008-04-25 Thread Colin Watson
FWIW, it was our intention when founding Ubuntu to dodge the Linux vs. GNU/Linux controversy entirely. I remember an early discussion about whether we should be Ubuntu Linux or Ubuntu GNU/Linux, and eventually we agreed that it was better just to be Ubuntu and not have to worry about it. Now, this

[Bug 221550] Re: add a note for translators regarding loading linux kernel message

2008-04-24 Thread Thomas Thurman
This is going to open a big can of worms about whether people mean the kernel when they say Linux (hence why the FSF ask you to say GNU/Linux to describe the whole thing) or whether it's legitimate to use Linux to mean the whole thing. It's a rather politicised question. -- add a note for

[Bug 221550] Re: add a note for translators regarding loading linux kernel message

2008-04-24 Thread balleyne
I disagree. Those who refer to the entire operating system name it after the kernel, do they not? I don't think there is a dispute over whether the kernel is called Linux or not, that's a fact. The political dispute is over whether an entire operating system running on the Linux kernel should be