[Bug 235254] Re: a: should allow IPv4 addresses

2008-05-27 Thread Scott Kitterman
The a: mechanism is not allowed to be an IP address. Arguably this was a poor design decision, but that is what's codified in RFC 4408. See http://www.openspf.org/RFC_4408#mech-a (and the rest of the ABNF) for details. Whenever feasible, the package design follows RFC 4408. Note that the

[Bug 235254] Re: a: should allow IPv4 addresses

2008-05-27 Thread Roger C. Pao
** Description changed: - Binary package hint: postfix-policyd-spf-perl + Binary package hint: python-policyd-spf May 12 00:38:47 rolly-dmz postfix/smtpd[3808]: connect from sn16.seed.net.tw[139 .175.54.16] May 12 00:38:47 rolly-dmz policyd-spf[3818]: SPF fail: REMOTEIP=139.175.54.16

[Bug 235254] Re: a: should allow IPv4 addresses

2008-05-27 Thread Roger C. Pao
Thank you for your prompt reply. I agree with your assessment that a: does not allow IPv4. I will follow up with seed.net.tw. FYI: The wizard at http://www.openspf.org/Project_Overview will forward to http://old.openspf.org/wizard.html?mydomain=seed.net.twsubmit=Go%21. -- a: should allow IPv4

[Bug 235254] Re: a: should allow IPv4 addresses

2008-05-27 Thread Scott Kitterman
From the version, I see you are running Feisty. The version of the Python policy server in the regular release does not, in fact, have a config file and, IIRC, rejects on permerror. I substantially improved one is available in feisty-backports. That's the one that supports the config file. --

Re: [Bug 235254] Re: a: should allow IPv4 addresses

2008-05-27 Thread Scott Kitterman
On Tuesday 27 May 2008 14:09, Roger C. Pao wrote: FYI: The wizard at http://www.openspf.org/Project_Overview will forward to http://old.openspf.org/wizard.html?mydomain=seed.net.twsubmit=Go%21. Thanks. I'd forgotten that. -- a: should allow IPv4 addresses